[CCWG-ACCT] objections to "decisions" taken in CCWG #65

[Dr Eberhard W Lisse]

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

Dear Co-Chairs,

I could not attend today's call, as I have to work for a living.

I agree with Robin on all items.

greetings, el


On 2015-11-03 16:26, Robin Gross wrote:
> I had to step away from today's CCWG meeting #65 and so want to be 
> sure my views are on the record on a couple issues.
> 
> 1.  I agree that bullet 4 on transparency reforms (disclosure of 
> the lobbying efforts) belongs in WS1.  The move to the designator 
> model makes dependence on transparency more critical than 
> previously thought and this issue can be quickly accommodated.
> 
> 2.  I strongly disagree with the decision making model proposed in 
> the meeting and declared as the new reference model.  I remain 
> concerned about the re-allocation of decisional power away from the
> SO's and towards the AC's, and in particular changing GAC's role
> away from "advisory" to having a decisional weight equal equal to
> SO's.  This change is in the opposite direction of that called for
> in public comments.
> 
> 3.  I also don't support the new proposal to ban split decisions 
> within SO's and AC's, which is a significant change to what was in 
> our first two draft proposals and has no public comment mandate and
> will silence minority views in the decisional process.
> 
> I will attach more detailed dissenting opinions on these issues to 
> the final report.
> 
> Thanks, Robin
[...]
- -- 
Dr. Eberhard W. Lisse  \        / Obstetrician & Gynaecologist (Saar)
el at lisse.NA            / *     |   Telephone: +264 81 124 6733 (cell)
PO Box 8421             \     /
Bachbrecht, Namibia     ;____/
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Comment: GPGTools - http://gpgtools.org
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=U1La
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----