[CCWG-ACCT] Poll results

Kavouss Arasteh kavouss.arasteh at gmail.com
Tue Feb 23 12:11:00 UTC 2016


Dear Thomas, Dear Alice
Tks pls then revise Poll 2
Regards
Kavouss


2016-02-23 12:41 GMT+01:00 Edward Morris <egmorris1 at toast.net>:

> Hello,
>
> I object to the inclusion in the tally of votes those individuals who are
> neither Appointed Members nor Participants of the CCWG on Enhancing
> Accountability. The full roster of Participants are listed here:
> https://community.icann.org/pages/viewpage.action?pageId=50823968 .
>
> The participation of staff, other than liaisons, is particularly
> troublesome. The number of Board members participating in a voting capacity
> in this poll despite not being a member, liaison or participant of the
> group is also a problem. Certainly the Board does not wish to leave itself
> open to charges of packing the meeting so it would achieve it's desired
> outcome despite the desires of regularly and properly participating members
> of the community.
>
> The barrier to becoming a CCWG participant is admirably low. The process
> should be respected. I would request all tallies be redone to reflect only
> the votes who have properly joined the CCWG as a Member, Participant or
> Liaison.
>
> Respectfully,
>
> Edward Morris
>
>
>
>
>
> ------------------------------
> *From*: "Grace Abuhamad" <grace.abuhamad at icann.org>
> *Sent*: Tuesday, February 23, 2016 10:29 AM
> *To*: "Accountability Cross Community" <
> accountability-cross-community at icann.org>
> *Subject*: [CCWG-ACCT] Poll results
>
> Dear all,
>
>
>
> To ensure full transparency around the polling, the staff have reviewed
> the recording for the call and crosschecked the results. The Adobe Connect
> recording is available here for your viewing as well:
> https://icann.adobeconnect.com/p2ner13u4kd/.
>
>
>
> Please note that the instructions regarding participation in the polls
> were as follows:
>
> ·      Anyone on the call was invited to participate in the poll (members
> & participants).
>
> ·      To participate, participants in the Adobe Connect room used either
> a red or green tick to respond to the poll question.
>
> ·      Those on audio-only could express their position over the phone.
>
> ·      After the polls, analysis would be conducted to assess
> participation from CCWG members (for the purposes of these results, the
> members’ names are in bold font).
>
>
>
> The Chairs conducted four polls in a group that varied between 85-90
> participants. The text used as the basis for the polls is Paragraph 72 of
> the CCWG report (see attached slide for the text as well as the 2nd
> bullet highlighted in red). The first two poll questions were based on
> objections and the second two poll questions were based on expressions of
> support.
>
>
>
> *Summary of results: *
>
>
>
> ·      11 objections to removing the 2nd bullet in Paragraph 72 (in red
> on the slide)
>
> o   (2 CCWG member objections)
>
>
>
> ·      27 objections to sending the report forward as it is currently,
> with the full text in Paragraph 72
>
> o   (8 CCWG member objections, including all ALAC members)
>
>
>
> ·      36 support removing the language in the 2nd bullet in Paragraph 72
> (in red on the slide)
>
> o   (10 CCWG members supporting)
>
>
>
> ·      14 support sending the report forward as it is currently, with the
> full text in Paragraph 72
>
> o   (2 CCWG members supporting)
>
>
>
> *Detailed results: *
>
>
>
> *Poll #1* – Who objects to removing the 2nd bullet in Paragraph 72 (in
> red on the slide), (“If the IRP is not available to challenge the Board
> action in question”)?
>
>
>
> 1.    Brett Schaefer (NCSG – Participant)
>
> 2.    Edward Morris (NCSG – Participant)
>
> 3.    Farzaneh Badii (NCSG – Participant)
>
> 4.    James Gannon (NCSG – Participant)
>
> 5.    Malcolm Hutty (ISPCP – Participant)
>
> 6.    Milton Mueller (NCSG – Participant)
>
> 7.    Paul Rosenzweig (NCSG – Participant)
>
> 8.    *Robin Gross* (NCSG – Member)
>
> 9.    Stephen Deerhake (ccNSO – Participant)
>
> 10. Tatiana Tropina (NCSG – Participant)
>
> 11. *Eberhard Lisse* (ccNSO – Member)
>
>
>
> *Poll #2* – Who objects to sending the report forward (to Chartering
> Organizations) as it is currently, (i.e. the 19 February version with the
> full text in Paragraph 72)?
>
>
>
> 1.    *Alan Greenberg* (ALAC – Member)
>
> 2.    Asha Hemrajani (ICANN Board – Participant)
>
> 3.    Cherine Chalaby (ICANN Board – Participant)
>
> 4.    *Cheryl Langdon-Orr* (ALAC – Member)
>
> 5.    Chris Disspain (ICANN Board – Participant)
>
> 6.    David McAuley (GNSO – Participant)
>
> 7.    Fadi Chehade (ICANN Board – Participant)
>
> 8.    George Sadowsky (ICANN Board – Participant)
>
> 9.    Jorge Cancio (GAC – Participant)
>
> 10. *Julia Wolman* (GAC – Member)
>
> 11. Keith Drazek (RySG – Participant)
>
> 12. *Leon Sanchez* (ALAC – Member)
>
> 13. Lito Ibarra (ICANN Board – Participant)
>
> 14. Louisewies Van del Laan (ICANN Board – Participant)
>
> 15. Markus Kummer (ICANN Board – Participant)
>
> 16. *Olga Cavalli* (GAC – Member)
>
> 17. Olivier Crepin-Leblond (ALAC – Participant)
>
> 18. Pedro da Silva (GAC – Participant)
>
> 19. Rafael Perez Galindo (GAC – Participant)
>
> 20. Rinalia Abdul Rahim (ICANN Board – Participant)
>
> 21. *Roelof Meijer* (ccNSO – Member)
>
> 22. Ron da Silva (ICANN Board – Participant)
>
> 23. Samantha Eisner (ICANN Staff Liaison)
>
> 24. Seun Ojedeji (ALAC – Participant)
>
> 25. Steve Crocker (ICANN Board – Participant)
>
> 26. *Sebastien Bachollet* (ALAC – Member)
>
> 27. Stephen Deerhake (ccNSO – Participant)
>
> 28. Tarek Kamel (ICANN Staff – Participant)
>
> 29. *Tijani Ben Jemaa* (ALAC – Member)
>
>
>
> *Poll #3* – Who supports removing the language in the 2nd bullet in
> Paragraph 72 (in red on the slide), (“If the IRP is not available to
> challenge the Board action in question”)?
>
>
>
> 1.    *Alan* *Greenberg* (ALAC – Member)
>
> 2.    Annaliese Williams (GAC – Participant)
>
> 3.    Asha Hemrajani (ICANN Board – Participant)
>
> 4.    Avri Doria (NCSG – Participant)
>
> 5.    Cherine Chalaby (ICANN Board – Participant)
>
> 6.    *Cheryl Langdon-Orr* (ALAC – Member)
>
> 7.    Chris Disspain (ICANN Board – Participant)
>
> 8.    David McAuley (GNSO – Participant)
>
> 9.    Fadi Chehade (ICANN Board – Participant)
>
> 10. Finn Petersen (GAC – Participant)
>
> 11. George Sadowsky (ICANN Board – Participant)
>
> 12. Greg Shatan (IPC – Participant)
>
> 13. *James Bladel* (RrSG – Member)
>
> 14. *Julia* *Wolman* (GAC – Member)
>
> 15. Kavouss Arasteh (GAC – Participant)
>
> 16. Keith Drazek (RySG – Participant)
>
> 17. *Leon* *Sanchez* (ALAC – Member)
>
> 18. Lito Ibarra (ICANN Board – Participant)
>
> 19. Louisewies Van del Laan (ICANN Board – Participant)
>
> 20. Mark Carvell (GAC – Participant)
>
> 21. Markus Kummer (ICANN Board – Participant)
>
> 22. Mary Uduma (ccNSO – Participant)
>
> 23. Niels Ten Oever (Participant)
>
> 30. *Olga* *Cavalli* (GAC – Member)
>
> 24. Olivier Crepin-Leblond (ALAC – Participant)
>
> 25. Paul Szyndler (ccNSO – Participant)
>
> 26. Pedro da Silva (GAC – Participant)
>
> 31. Rafael Perez Galindo (GAC – Participant)
>
> 27. Rinalia Abdul Rahim (ICANN Board – Participant)
>
> 28. *Roelof* *Meijer* (ccNSO – Member)
>
> 29. Ron da Silva (ICANN Board – Participant)
>
> 30. Sabine Meyer (GAC – Participant)
>
> 31. Seun Ojedeji (ALAC – Participant)
>
> 32. Steve Crocker (ICANN Board – Participant)
>
> 33. *Steve DelBianco* (CSG – Member)
>
> 34. *Sebastien* *Bachollet* (ALAC – Member)
>
> 35. Tarek Kamel (ICANN Staff)
>
> 36. *Tijani* *Ben Jemaa* (ALAC – Member)
>
>
>
> *Poll #4* – Who supports sending the report to Chartering Organizations
> as it is currently, (i.e. the 19 February version with the full text in
> Paragraph 72)?
>
>
>
> 1.    Aarti Bhavana (NCSG – Participant)
>
> 2.    Brett Schaefer (NCSG – Participant)
>
> 3.    Edward Morris (NCSG – Participant)
>
> 4.    Farzaneh Badii (NCSG – Participant)
>
> 5.    James Gannon (NCSG – Participant)
>
> 6.    *Jordan Carter* (ccNSO – Member)
>
> 7.    Martin Boyle (ccNSO – Participant)
>
> 8.    Matthew Shears (NCSG – Participant)
>
> 9.    Malcolm Hutty (ISPCP – Participant)
>
> 10. Milton Mueller (NCSG – Participant)
>
> 11. Paul Rosenzweig (NCSG – Participant)
>
> 12. *Robin* *Gross* (NCSG – Member)
>
> 13. Stephen Deerhake (ccNSO – Participant)
>
> 14. Tatiana Tropina (NCSG – Participant)
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Accountability-Cross-Community mailing list
> Accountability-Cross-Community at icann.org
> https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/accountability-cross-community
>
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mm.icann.org/pipermail/accountability-cross-community/attachments/20160223/76fc7432/attachment-0001.html>


More information about the Accountability-Cross-Community mailing list