[Ccwg-auctionproceeds] Revised review/assessment proposal
sam at lanfranco.net
Mon Aug 26 21:14:04 UTC 2019
Becky’s comments touch on an area that may need better clarity. This is
the start of a new undertaking and the annual review wording might be
cast slightly differently. Something like:
* The prime function of the APPRP will be to perform an annual review,
starting at the end of year 2. The first annual review will focus on
Mechanism development and an assessment of approved projects
relative to auction proceeds goals. Subsequent reviews will include
an assessment of funded projects, based on interim and final
assessments provided to the APPRP.
* The APPRP will focus on the Mechanism in terms of its operational
performance and the auction proceeds goals. It will not investigate
individual projects beyond what is provided in the assessments
provided to the APPRP.
Casting the wording something like this (a) distinguishes between the
initial assessment and subsequent assessments, and (b) limits individual
project assessment to evidence “provided to the APPRP”. That does leave
open the question of who provides that evidence. I assume that is the
project recipient’s own self reporting, with the Mechanism responsible
for assessing the quality of the reporting.
On 8/26/2019 4:07 PM, Becky Burr wrote:
> I am having a little trouble reconciling this:
> * The prime function of the APPRP will be to perform an annual
> review (starting at the end of year 2) of the ongoing operational
> process including an assessment of approved projects vs auction
> proceeds goals *and an assessment of the success of funded
> projects* (based on interim and final assessments provided to the
> with this:
> * For avoidance of doubt, the APPRP will focus on the overall
> operation of the Mechanism and w*ill not evaluate the success of
> individual funded projects*, although the APPRP may take into
> consideration such evaluations performed by the Mechanism.
> In the first bullet, perhaps it would be clearer to say "an assessment
> of the overall success of the program"?
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the Ccwg-auctionproceeds