[CWG-Stewardship] A letter circulated on the IANA transition NRO/RIR list

[Kris Seeburn]

People,

I just wanted to share this with all of you as we move. Just information sake nothing to diverge our initial thinking. But more as a take note of happenings.

Kris


Message: 1
Date: Thu, 23 Oct 2014 09:43:16 -0500
From: Techno CAT <mars.techno.cat at gmail.com <mailto:mars.techno.cat at gmail.com>>
To: "ianaxfer at nro.net <mailto:ianaxfer at nro.net>" <ianaxfer at nro.net <mailto:ianaxfer at nro.net>>
Subject: [NRO-IANAXFER] [IANAtransition] LETTER to Mr. Eric H. Holder,
	Jr - U.S. Attorney General
Message-ID:
	<CAK41CSS0AfWjXriKzsXQ1YDUFRV0W8f8Y+i3oBNOCE+nh=AKew at mail.gmail.com <mailto:CAK41CSS0AfWjXriKzsXQ1YDUFRV0W8f8Y+i3oBNOCE+nh=AKew at mail.gmail.com>>
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8

ICANN is a Contractor of the US Government - Department of Commerce
The following TEXT from .MARS is provided for .EARTH Archive Purposes Only
cat is one of the original UNIX commands - Sending email to C at T uses
the .T Top Level Domain
===============================================================
http://mm.icann.org/pipermail/ianatransition/2014/000648.html <http://mm.icann.org/pipermail/ianatransition/2014/000648.html>

Mr. Eric H. Holder, Jr
U.S. Attorney General
Office of the Attorney General
U.S. Department of Justice
950 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW
Washington, DC 20530-0001

Via eMail: AskDOJ at usdoj.gov <http://usdoj.gov/>

Dear Attorney General _______________:

The Internet is in serious trouble. The legacy DOD DARPA Internet was
built using a Tin-Can and Kite-String Architecture (TCKS). Bob
connects his treehouse to Carol?s cave. Carol connects to Alice?s hut.
Ted comes along, on his mountain; he connects to all three. All four
get their Unique Addresses from some mysterious, opaque, private citizen(s)
who claim to have government authority. The IANA.of.OZ baffles people.

Naive academics, military funders, computer hackers, idealistic
opportunists and cut-throat business people combined to build the
early Internet. Anyone with expensive IPv4 ARPA-centric TCP/IP routers
could expand the Legacy Internet. Unsuspecting consumers had no idea
who was processing their packets. Unseen Street Gangs and Router Wars
shaped the CyberSpace. Some people worship this as their Multi-Stakeholder
Model. Other people recognize the BGP BiGProblems of Self-Governance.

Internet Governance of unique Artificially Scarce Network Resources
(ASNR) emerged. A Cyber TAX system was constructed using Domain Names
(DNS). Three high-school chums, Jon Postel, Vinton Cerf, and Steve
Crocker have dominated the CyberSpace DNS Governance for decades.
Other insiders have been added to the small IANA clique that controls the
allocation of resources. Jaw-dropping compensation packages are used
to pad organizations with people who seem to accomplish very little.

An Internet Society (1992) was formed to protect jack-booted thugs who
claimed to be Internet Engineers. Some did not have a high-school
diploma. Vigilantes emerged, as Internet self-government took on a life
of its own. Socialist/Communist structures dominated. Mercenaries and
Soldiers of Fortune are now becoming more common.

Some describe the state of affairs as the book, "Lord of the Flies",
combined with the book, "A Brave New World"[1]. Juvenile delinquents
populate many of the Internet Governance Forums. They SELF-APPOINT
themselves to Internet Governance roles. The Multi-Stakeholder Model
allows anyone to claim anything and even represent the U.S. Government.

[1]"Orwell feared we would become a captive culture. Huxley feared we
would become a trivial culture, preoccupied with some equivalent of
the feelies, the orgy porgy, and the centrifugal bumblepuppy."

Pseudo-Governance Officials [Private Citizens] make up the rules, to
suit their PRIVATE financial needs. Corruption, kick-backs,
black-listing, red-lining, etc. are common. Off-Shore operations in
the Cayman Islands, the Caribbean and Switzerland handle the anonymous
opaque financial transactions. The ISOC-IETF-IANA-ICANN-RIR Cartel is called
The Eco.System. It is actually a simple Multi-Level-Marketing empire
built on TAX collections from unsuspecting Netizens. The insiders are
well-funded and travel the world, promoting their Multi-Stakeholder MLM.

One participant in the ISOC-IETF Meetings and the ARIN Meetings claims
he "Represents the JUSTICE DEPARTMENT". This juvenile delinquent has a
long history working with Jon Postel - IANA. They both use "word games"
to misinform novice observers and the general public. These unprofessional
players think omitting "US" from the title gets them by. At a subsequent
meeting, the individual claimed he was "contracted with the FBI".
Later in the meeting, he gave his affiliation as [not audible mumble words].

Juvenile delinquents treat the Internet Governance meetings as some sort
of Video Game. They are not accountable for their actions. It is not
clear if the US Department of Justice provides any over-sight of these
individuals. In one case, it appears that ICANN is contracting with a
private security company, which claims to have a long history of "working
with the FBI". That is not the same as "being the FBI".

In another case, ICANN appears to employ a well-known computer hacker who
runs a major trade-show in Las Vegas each year. He commands an army of over
twenty-five thousand techies who pride themselves on breaking into computer
systems. ICANN and the ISOC-IETF Eco.System endorse and promote the
Culture of Corruption. Young people are confused and drawn into the CULT.
Bob, Carol, Ted, and Alice now control the packet flows, sell copies, and
contract with U.S. Government agencies or The.ECO.SYSTEM to compromise other
citizen's systems.

Most government officials were intentionally excluded from the early
Internet. Other Government officials were "used" as enablers and
shields, to hide the development of the insidious ISOC.IANA Cartel. Major
telecom carriers were also intentionally excluded. Internet operator
groups, dominated by psychopathic attention-starved jerks grew to
become the hubs of control. The NSF funded NANOG is one example.
Ted is a Member of NANOG. Carol lords over ARIN which secretly funds NANOG.

American consumers, are accustomed to regulated companies, with
ethical standards, managing their critical telecom and data
facilities. Unsuspecting consumers have been intentionally kept in the
dark by the Multi-Stakeholder Cartel (MSC). Juvenile delinquents
dominate the various gatherings of the MS Cartel. Consumers have no
idea they are vulnerable to these amateur network operators.
Self-serving academics coddle the juveniles and deflect government scrutiny
with fabricated distractions. They are called WMDs - Weapons of Mass
Distraction.

With the TCKS Internet Architecture, Non-Government [self-appointed]
Vigilantes can snoop and spy on individuals and groups. In some cases, they [Bob & Carol]
are willing to sell their services to anyone that will pay them. For
decades they have demonstrated that their ethical norms are far
different from the American Telco industry. They pride themselves on
being what many people would summarize as, Cyber Bullies.

These Cyber Bullies and Street Gangs have also taken it upon themelves
to SELL valuable US Government ASSETS in the form of Address Spectrum
The Internet IPv4 Address Space is no different from Radio Spectrum,
managed for the public, by the US FCC. A typical ICANN IANA IPv4 Address
Allocation has a street value of over $3,000,000,000 (yes Billion).

The U.S. Government has been a casual party to many of the legacy
Internet evolutions. In the early days, the National Science
Foundation NSF meddled in network developments, with mixed results. A
few major universities and academic personalities did very well,
financially, once they figured out how to game the NSF Grant
processes. They obtained Artificially Scarce Network Resources (ASNR)
via NSF Grants and then sold them for private gain. The NSF looked the
other way. Subtle financial kick-backs to the NSF greased the process.

As commercial companies began to migrate to the legacy Internet, the
U.S. Government over-sight shifted from the NSF to the U.S. Department
of Commerce (DOC). A DOC sub-agency, NTIA, handled
most of the tasks. The obscure Internet Cartel function called "IANA"
was morphed into a California Public Benefit Non-Profit company called
ICANN - the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names & Numbers. (1998)

In general, non-profit corporations have been used as shells to hide
the true financial dealings of the Internet Cartel (MSC). Cyber
Bullies openly proclaim that they are non-profit "religions" while
secretly banking millions. In some cases, they also have a for-profit
vest-pocket company. Their ethics are justified under THEIR, unwritten,
shifting rules of the "International" Multi-Stakeholder Model.

Since 1998, ICANN has evolved into a corrupt private companion to the
Internet Society (ISOC-IETF) founded in 1992. The private ISOC-IETF
ICANN-IANA ARIN Eco.System skillfully used the US Government as a
shield and enabler for decades. The DNS Cyber Tax system has been used
to fund their lavish travel and world-wide outreach programs. ICANN
has now been captured by nefarious "International Operatives",
primarily from Egypt and the Middle East.

The arrogance of the ISOC IANA Eco.System has no bounds. The ISOC IANA
Eco.System is carefully structured with Clerics, Insiders, Militia,
Operatives, Thugs, Groupies, and what Lenin and Stalin called
Useful Idiots. Artificially Scarce Network Resources (ASNR) are used
to control the Eco.System. Aging dictators control the cartel,
supported by people who attend meetings to "see famous people".
Elections are not viewed as desirable or possible in the Eco.System -
"The Wrong People Might Get Elected".

It is ironic, the Eco.System often claims credit for developments that
were done to protect USA consumers FROM the Eco.System. Many USA
Netizens work hard in normal business roles to AVOID the
Eco.System. The vast majority of USA Internet companies avoid the
Eco.System. The Eco.System attempts to co-opt key developments with
their vast war-chests of money. Some groups succumb to the bribes. The
W3C is one example. Tim has entered the picture using Bob, Carol, & TED.

ICANN-IANA and ISOC-IETF have systematically delayed and derailed
competition as they have grown their non-profit empire to billions of
dollars and million dollar executive compensation packages. The lack
of Term-Limits has allowed individuals to become career Internet
politicians. Jaw-dropping compensation packages and non-profit war
chests of cash reserves are used by the Eco.System players to dominate
Internet Governance. American citizens have been openly threatened
with death by the ISOC-IETF Thugs, who surround the IANA as a protection
force.

Recently, the U.S. Government, via NTIA, has announced their intention
to distance themselves from the Legacy ICANN IANA ISOC Internet. This
Diplomatic move has confused many American consumers. Most Americans are not
aware of who runs their Internet [and from where??]. The ICANN-IANA ISOC
leaders have recently openly joined with South American leaders. Latin America has a
long history of some of the most corrupt telecom and social regimes on the
planet.

Bases have also been opened in Turkey and Singapore. The Eco.System Cartel
claims to be "international" and immune from USA laws and scrutiny. It is
ironic that the Eco.System finds much of its deep political support from
CHINA and the corrupt regimes of AFRICA. Africans fall all over themselves rushing
to the next Face-2-Face Meetings (Talk Shops) run by Self-Appointed
Napoleans.

Wisely, the U.S. Congress has directed the NTIA to lead the construction of
a
new Internet, called FirstNET. Federal funding is being allocated to
States that step forward to help. The State of Colorado has landed
the Technical Headquarters for FirstNet. The State of Virginia has
been selected to handle the FirstNet Administrative Headquarters. FEMA
Regions have been suggested for organizing FirstNet.

FirstNET does not directly and daily serve all Netizens. A NEW USA Domestic
Internet (SecondNET) is still needed. Netizens in the USA need to rely on an
Internet they can trust. One plan calls for FOUR-State Regions, called
SuperStates, to act as the major Hubs for the USA SecondNET.

Sixteen SuperStates would form the basic structure for the USA
DOMESTIC Internet. Since FirstNet plans to leverage existing network
facilities, FirstNET would be one of the first customers for the USA
DOMESTIC SecondNET. Elected US Senators, would automatically be appointed
as the leaders of SecondNET.

As the Attorney General of the United States of America, you have the
difficult task of helping Americans protect themselves from the Cyber
Bullies who control the Internet. This is very similar to trying to
protect American citizens living along the border of Mexico. It is very
hard to sort out and neutralize, the Cyber Bullies.

The design and construction of a SecondNET companion to FirstNET will help
to provide a more robust framework for the USA Internet. I hope that you
support the FirstNET and SecondNET movements. I also hope that you remain
vigilant about who is claiming to represent the US Justice Department and/or
the FBI.

Joe Concerned Citizen
State of ____________

P.S. The ISOC IANA Eco.System is not going away. They are rapidly
moving away from the USA to International venues, they can exploit.
They advocate splitting the Internet with their IPv6 technology. The
USA can protect itself with a unified solution. The USA is a Republic,
not a Democracy, and certainly not a MultiStakeholder Street Gang. The
Republic of States and SuperStates collectively designing, building
and operating a NEW USA Domestic FirstNET and SecondNET will help to
protect consumers and visitors to our CyberSpace.

===============================================================
"This is a temporary list to be used as the mechanism for collecting
public feedback on the IANA stewardship transition."

@Techno_CAT_r
http://Twitter.com/Techno_CAT_r <http://twitter.com/Techno_CAT_r>



> On Oct 24, 2014, at 8:16 AM, Eduardo Diaz <eduardodiazrivera at gmail.com> wrote:
> 
> Robert:
> 
> It will depend: if the final option is to keep the function under the ICANN umbrella, then my understanding is that ICANN will keep financing it. On the other hand, if it is moved outside ICANN, then i presume it can be supported by all entities requiring its services.
> 
> -ed 
> 
> On Thu, Oct 23, 2014 at 6:57 PM, Robert Guerra <rguerra at privaterra.org <mailto:rguerra at privaterra.org>> wrote:
> Curious if the question of how the "new" IANA would be financed has been asked ?
> 
> 
> 
> 
> Sent from my iPhone
> _______________________________________________
> CWG-Stewardship mailing list
> CWG-Stewardship at icann.org <mailto:CWG-Stewardship at icann.org>
> https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/cwg-stewardship <https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/cwg-stewardship>
> 
> 
> 
> -- 
> NOTICE: This email may contain information which is confidential and/or subject to legal privilege, and is intended for the use of the named addressee only. If you are not the intended recipient, you must not use, disclose or copy any part of this email. If you have received this email by mistake, please notify the sender and delete this message immediately.
> _______________________________________________
> CWG-Stewardship mailing list
> CWG-Stewardship at icann.org
> https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/cwg-stewardship

Kris Seeburn
seeburn.k at gmail.com
www.linkedin.com/in/kseeburn/ <http://www.linkedin.com/in/kseeburn/>




-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mm.icann.org/pipermail/cwg-stewardship/attachments/20141024/6aaac5db/attachment-0001.html>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: smime.p7s
Type: application/pkcs7-signature
Size: 4139 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://mm.icann.org/pipermail/cwg-stewardship/attachments/20141024/6aaac5db/smime-0001.p7s>