[CWG-Stewardship] Conditional Accountability Requirements

Jonathan Robinson jrobinson at afilias.info
Thu Jan 15 11:48:29 UTC 2015



I recall from the weekend sessions that we agreed to work on the
"Conditional Accountability" requirements to be developed as part of the CWG

And moreover, to the extent that it was possible, to formulate these in such
a way as to guide the work (on work stream 1) of the CCWG next week.


I believe Alan Greenberg was going to hold the pen on this but have not seen
anything on list so will make a contribution here to be synthesised with
anything Alan has led or developed.


It seems to me that we have three categories as follows:


1.    General i.e. work that will be done by the CCWG and on which the CWG
will rely on regardless of the variant proposal it produces.
>From previous correspondence with the CCWG, we know that they have
identified the following areas:

o   Independent Review of Board Actions

o   Independent certification for delegation and re-delegation

o   Independent Appeals Panel

2.    Relating to RFP 3a - A (potentially) limited set of requirements given
the strength of recourse associated with 3a

o   A

o   B

o   C

3.    Relating to RFP 3b - A (potentially) more extensive list of
requirements given the likely integrated nature of the outcome from this

o   D

o   E

o   F



Now, clearly the key question is formulating the bullet points A-F under 3a
and 3 b above and deciding whether 3a is a subset of 3b or whether there are
unique conditions associated with 3a.


It will be very helpful to have clear input on A-F above in a form that we
can transmit to the CCWG ahead of their meetings next week.







-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mm.icann.org/pipermail/cwg-stewardship/attachments/20150115/c567f7d7/attachment.html>

More information about the CWG-Stewardship mailing list