[Gnso-newgtld-wg-wt5] Notes & Action Items - New gTLD Subsequent Procedures PDP Work Track 5 - 15 May 2019

Wed May 15 22:28:27 UTC 2019

Dear Work Track 5 members,

Please see below the action items and notes from the Work Track 5 meeting today, 15 May 2019.  These high-level notes are designed to help WT5 members navigate through the content of the call and are not a substitute for the recording, transcript, or the chat, which will be posted on the wiki at: https://community.icann.org/display/NGSPP/2019-05-15+New+gTLD+Subsequent+Procedures+PDP+Work+Track+5.

Kind regards,

Julie

Julie Hedlund, Policy Director

Notes and Action Items:

Actions:

Staff to go back through the tabs and make sure any BRG/RrSG mis-assignments are fixed

Notes:

1. Updates to Statements of Interest (SOIs): Annebeth has changed her work title, but will still be on WT5 doing the same work.

2. Review of Public Comments:

Names requiring government support/non- objections from the 2012 AGB (see deliberations section f.2.3.2 for context)

Question 19, Variant 2:
Line 40 -- ALAC -- Agreement/Divergence
Lines 41-54: Divergence

Question 19, Variant 3:
Line 56 -- Dotzon GmbH -- Agreement
Line 57 -- ALAC -- Agreement/Divergence
Lines 58-70: Divergence

Question 20:
Lines 72-78: Agreement
Line 79 -- United States -- Agreement/Concerns
Line 80 -- RySG -- Agreement/Divergence
Lines 81-89: Divergence

Question 21:
Lines 91-98: Agreement
Line 99 -- Agreement/Divergence
Line 100 -- RySG -- Agreement (qualified)/Divergence
Lines 101-108: Divergence

Question 22:
Lines 110-113: Agreement
Line 114 -- ALAC -- Agreement/Divergence
Lines 115-125: Divergence
Lines 126-7: No comment

Question 23:
Lines 129-134: Agreement
Line 135 -- RySG -- Agreement (qualified)/Divergence
Lines 136-146: Divergence

Question 24:
Lines 148-154: Agreement
Line 155 -- ALAC -- Agreement/Divergence
Lines 156-165: Divergence

Question 25:
Lines 167-169: Agreement
Line 170 -- dotBerlin et al. -- Agreement (partially -- first part)
Line 171 -- Dotzon GmbH -- Agreement (partially - second part) Divergence (with first part)
Line 172 -- IPC -- Agreement (partially - first part) Divergence (with second part)
Line 173 -- ALAC -- Agreement/Divergence
Line 174 -- RyST -- Agreement (qualified)/Divergence
Lines 175-183: Divergence

Question 26:
Lines 185-198: Agreement
Lines 199-201: Divergence

Names requiring government support/non- objections from the 2012 AGB (see deliberations section f2.3.3 for context)

Question 27:
Lines 6-13: Agreement
Line 14 -- RySG -- Agreement (qualified)/Divergence
Lines 15-23: Divergence

Question 28:
Lines 25-27: Agreement
Line 28 -- BRG -- Agreement (qualified)
Line 29 -- IPC -- Agreement/Divergence
Line 30 -- RySG -- Agreement (qualified)/Divergence
Lines 31-42: Divergence

Question 29:
Line 44 -- BRG -- Agreement (qualified)
Lines 45-49: Agreement
Line 50 -- Group of Registries -- Agreement (qualified)
Line 51 -- RySG -- Agreement (qualified)/Divergence
Lines 52-61: Divergence

Names requiring government support/non- objections from the 2012 AGB (see deliberations section f.2.3.4 for context)

Question 30:
Lines 6-13: Agreement
Line 14 -- RySG -- Agreement (qualified)/Divergence
Lines 15-23: Divergence

Question 31:
Lines 25-26: Agreement (qualified)
Lines 27-28: Agreement
Line 29 -- IPC -- Change to Divergence
Line 30 -- RyST -- Agreement (qualified)/Divergence
Lines 31-42: Divergence

Question 32:
Lines 44-50: Agreement (some qualified)
Line 51 -- RySG -- Agreement (qualified)/Divergence
Lines 52-61: Divergence

Options/Proposals: terms not included in the 2012 Applicant Guidebook (see deliberations section f.2.4 for context)

Line 4 -- Christopher Wilkinson -- Concerns

Question 33:
Lines 5-14: Agreement (some qualified)
Line 15 -- ALAC -- Change to Divergence
Lines 16-22: Divergence
Lines 23 - RySG -- Doesn’t appear to address the proposal

Question 34:
Lines 25-30: Agreement
Line 31 -- DotBERLIN -- Agreement/Concerns
Line 32 -- dotzon GmbH -- Agreement
Lines 33 -- RySG -- Agreement/Concerns/Divergence
Line 34-35: Concerns/Divergence
Lines 36-40: Divergence
Line 41 -- Portuguese Govt.

Question 35:
Lines 43-49: Agreement
Lines 50-51: Concerns/Divergence
Lines 52-59: Divergence
Line 60 -- RySG. -- no position

Question 36:
Lines 62-71: Agreement (IPC line 72 is qualified)
Line 72 -- NCSG -- Agreement/Concerns -- change to Agreement, qualified
Line 73 -- RrSG -- Concerns/Divergence -- This is really divergence with explanation
Lines 74-77: Divergence
Line 78 -- RySG -- no position

  *   There are a few cases where a group has given the rationale has been given followed by divergence. Sometimes it is categorized as concerns followed by divergence, but perhaps it should just be divergence with a rationale provided. There are a number of cases on tab F 2.4). Comments from BRG (line 50) and RrSG (line 51) may have this problem. Lines 34 (suggestion to change to divergence) and 35 are also cited.
  *   Staff will pull out these items for the summary document regardless, the highlighting helps staff condense the material. It is not a problem from staff perspective to change these to divergence if the group prefers.

Question 37:
Lines 80-86: Agreement
Line 87 -- ALAC -- Agreement/Concerns - should be Agreement (Qualified) + Concerns
Lines 88-96: Divergence
Line 97 -- RySG -- no position

Question 38:
Lines 99-107: Agreement
Lines 108-115: Divergence
Line 116 -- RySG -- no position

AOB

  *   Leadership Team is thinking about how to use the time at ICANN65
  *   There will likely be two sessions on the first day
  *   Feedback is welcome on the agenda for these sessions
  *   The time may be used to summarize points of agreement and focus on difficult issues

  *   Additional substantive comment from one member -- geographic names must be protected for future generations. This protection should not be limited to specific lists.

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mm.icann.org/pipermail/gnso-newgtld-wg-wt5/attachments/20190515/ff3c22eb/attachment-0001.html>