[Internal-cg] Charter commenting

Daniel Karrenberg daniel.karrenberg at ripe.net
Wed Aug 6 06:11:33 UTC 2014

This text is good. Again: I hope that the comment *mechanism* can be set
up as a generic one and kept open until our work is done.


On 5.08.14 23:30 , Alissa Cooper wrote:
> Ok, I made a couple of edits to the proposed landing page text to
> accommodate suggestions received. I slightly softened the language around
> community comments being our preferred mechanism and added a new final
> paragraph to address Paul’s and Mohamed’s points. We can keep tweaking
> this, but I’d like for ICANN to start getting it up on a web page in the
> meantime. New text:
> ===
> ICG Charter Open for Public Comments
> On July 18, the IANA Stewardship Transition Coordination Group (ICG)
> produced a draft charter <link> that defines its own tasks. The charter is
> open for public comment until August XX, 2014 at 20:00 UTC. <bold>It is
> the strong preference of the ICG that comments about the charter from the
> public be submitted via existing IANA-related community processes, and not
> through the link provided below.</bold> If you need assistance finding
> those processes or contacting the appropriate ICG participant, please
> contact <secretariat-email>. If you are not able to provide comments
> through a relevant community or ICG participant, a mechanism for
> submitting comments via an email alias is linked below.
> Please be aware that the ICG views defining the broad outlines of its
> charter as important, but it views finalizing the charter and moving on to
> the real work of the transition planning to be of equal importance. As a
> result not all comments submitted concerning the charter will necessarily
> be incorporated.
> Public comments are considered to be for the public record, and for the
> information and consideration of all participants in this process, not
> just for the ICG. Everyone is encouraged to review any public comments
> that may be submitted via the process below.
> Public comment submission process links:
> Comment submission: <link>
> List of comments submitted via this site: <link>
> Charter: <link> 
> Deadline: August XX, 2014 at 20:00 UTC
> ===
> Alissa
> On 8/5/14, 11:47 AM, "Paul Wilson" <pwilson at apnic.net> wrote:
>> I agree with Daniel’s proposal here.
>> Can we state that public comments are considered to be for the public
>> record, and for the information and consideration of all participants in
>> this process, not just for the ICG.  This is reasonable I think, along
>> with the emphasis on contributions via the relevant communities.
>> Paul.
>> On 5 Aug 2014, at 1:30 am, Daniel Karrenberg <daniel.karrenberg at ripe.net>
>> wrote:
>>> Hash: SHA1
>>> I agree that we should set up a mechanism for comments from the
>>> general public with the following properties:
>>> It clearly, bluntly, repeatedly and unavoidably states that the
>>> preferred method for participation is via the relevant communities.
>>>  Maybe we should have a check box where people have to acknowledge
>>> that they understand this before they can post a comment. ;-)
>>> All comments should be stored in a public archive for all to see,
>>> including for us. Comments in this archive should be kept available
>>> for all to see for at least 5 years after they are made.
>>> Discussion should be strongly discouraged in this mechanism. There are
>>> other places for that already; the most appropriate are the relevant
>>> communities.
>>> We can then see all these comments and take them into account as
>>> appropriate.
>>> - ----
>>> Comments for the charter should be treated as just a special case of
>>> the above.  14 calendar days is about the right time for this as this
>>> is about the time we would need to get substantive comments from our
>>> communities and I do not see that final agreement on the charter will
>>> substantially delay our other current work.
>>> Daniel
>>> Version: GnuPG v1.4.7 (Darwin)
>>> iQIVAwUBU9+nINDY5Emqa716AQLdBQ//SiFPTNCCn69DUAeN44Q0zrUdzwnw924H
>>> JIGV5mNTO2BaHrwdgdJOm1D7PZUIHkyOPZ56OorvXWyQDgZy0bM7jA/P0IuHAfXL
>>> CtSGI2+o5jqmN/er00JaS1M7XvjD+1ELC0OkG5zmUY8PD1W+yOGreJ0P2e6y/T7A
>>> 9SQr1aaGCASlPrCRFTZ3yggSBzkIh1/atlcZk84tnYf04hnTmjuX3w8eJIt9kixp
>>> qzRZj8qOTyRW8fbQNYD9BeiMiqpcha4uaU27/gK0Xa91LtQoVGFY5sRceRcBHp4C
>>> XiqlH1QQa2vN2AXvQJ3uAVJep/CCUCBRl+i/rfAcjTA7TWegNL6PEidTbatJzGO4
>>> NC36/UDflT99KcGM7F8i/UBDcIiiv56vjbzRez7id7VRQMVxn58pLusKVDYHkkQc
>>> JDVgo3IB9HETfUqRr3gFQYA9Wx7gklF0ssbZuoz70534r2CQzEtqGOlqC/6OJzjx
>>> u4PsUhHPlnkzJk+P1k3o0eC6TqrRTzpGwblDiiq5/bGCDmNXBXZW9NXTWewwbB9q
>>> ZxuP6K0BNiM1pKLXkHlTw3IQNVtIFKodIjHnp/b0vcGtGYEz7gBu4lHhJHbzks9/
>>> SUNpeIRcPeVUD92+G75MDDNDlli/+sFu89pOrv0l8x6y0KOikILLpknlY9+BlHZC
>>> WmXf5z9aPHg=
>>> =1pee
>>> -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
>>> _______________________________________________
>>> Internal-cg mailing list
>>> Internal-cg at icann.org
>>> https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/internal-cg
>> _______________________________________________
>> Internal-cg mailing list
>> Internal-cg at icann.org
>> https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/internal-cg

More information about the Internal-cg mailing list