[ispcp] Fwd: [pdp-pcceg-feb06] current proposal - take 2

[Greg Ruth]

Dear ISPCP constituency members,
    The PDP task force for policy concerning existing registry
contracts (aka "Feb06") has now come to the point where the last
remaining piece of business is the recommendation concerning the 5th
item in the Terms of Reference, concerning the use of registry data. 
Our constituency has to decide whether it supports the proposed
recommendation or not.  
     For your reference, item 5 of the TOR is:

> 5a Examine whether or not there should be a policy regarding the
> use of registry data for purposes other than for which it was
> collected, and if so, what the elements of that policy should be.
> 
> 5b. Determine whether any policy is necessary to ensure non-
> discriminatory access to registry data that is made available to
> third parties.
 
The task force has been unable to reach conclusions to item 5 because
of a lack of hard data concerning the type of data collected and its
use.  (Generally, the Registries are against recommending any policy at
all, claiming our stated concerns lack any solid basis.)  Accordingly,
the task force is reduced to proposing the following recommendation, to
be included in the final task force report:
 
> In order to determine whether there is a need for a new consensus  
> policy on the collection and use of registry data, including traffic 
> data, for purposes other then which is was collected, there is first 
> a need for a properly targeted study by an independent third party on
> the data collected and the uses to which it is put.  The study should
> provide appropriate safeguards to protect any data provided  for the 
> purposes of the study, and the confidentiality of which registry, or 
> other group, provides the data. The findings of the study should be  
> published and available for public review.
> 
> A SOW should be developed by the GNSO council, with appropriate  
> public review, to cover an analysis of the concerns for data  
> collection and use, the practice involved in collection and use of  
> data - including traffic data, and the availability, when  
> appropriate, for  non disciminatory access to that data.
> 
> It is recommended that a current processes document be developed,  
> describing the current Registry practices for the collection of data 
> and the uses of that data; e.g. but not limited to, operating the  
> registry; preparing marketing materials to promote registration of  
> domain names; gathering of ‘null’ returns, ensuring the integrity of 
> 
> the Registry, or the DNS.  This report should be available to the  
> group doing the external study and should be made available to the  
> public for comment.
> 
> After examining the results of the independent
> study and public discussions recommended above, the GNSO council  
> should examine the findings and determine what, if any, further  
> policy process is required.

We simply need to report back to the Task Force whether the ISPCP
supports this recommendation or not.  Personally, I believe it is the
best we can hope for, but I invite comments from the constituency
members and will be guided by that inpur.  We need to respond by 22
February 2007.

Greg 


 
____________________________________________________________________________________
Get your own web address.  
Have a HUGE year through Yahoo! Small Business.
http://smallbusiness.yahoo.com/domains/?p=BESTDEAL