[Ssr2-review] dropping recommendation 25

k claffy kc at caida.org
Wed Oct 16 16:19:39 UTC 2019


i came late to the call so i don't know what was said
about recommendation 25, but eric and i proposed folding
it into all the abuse measurement recommendations that come
later (earlier? i can't tell from what's in this google doc).

per denise's suggestion, we should probably air this on
the list before we kill it.

	Recommendation 25: (Global SSR Measurement) -- Rec 24, 25, 30, 33, 34

	ICANN should propose or task the community to create a set of
	global (holistic) SSR-related measurements (including DNSSEC,
	availability, integrity, abuse, etc.) measurements that are both
	knowable and meaningful (i.e. what the community is likely to
	find informative and is also tractable to measure).  This data
	may (and likely will) involve the cooperation of non-ICANN-org
	resources. ICANN should propose a set of data that is useful to
	assess the global health of the DNS globally (including deployment
	of DNSSEC, availability, abuse, abuse) and post this proposal
	for public comment.  ICANN should then incorporate community
	feedback and produce a plan to create this public data/repository
	and an access model for these data. At the moment, it is difficult
	to assess DNSSEC deployment, including for members of the ICANN
	community. Better tracking of relevant indicators would serve
	strategic objectives 1, 2, and 3.

when we do write measurement recommendations, we need to
make them much more concrete ("measurement of abuse" won't
cut it), and/or delegate them to some independent measurement
expert to be contracted by icann, with all the resulting 
measurement methodology and data required to be public such 
that the analyses are reproducible.

k




More information about the Ssr2-review mailing list