eggert at twinsun.com
Tue Aug 31 06:44:58 UTC 1999
Date: 31 Aug 1999 05:51:17 -0000
From: "D. J. Bernstein" <djb at cr.yp.to>
Why aren't transition times labelled with the starting offset? Or, more
simply, always specified in terms of standard time?
Part of the motivation for the seemingly unnecessary complexity of the
rule lines is a desire to match the natural-language statutes as
closely as possible. When translating statutes or regulations into tz
format, if the original text specifies standard time, that's what I
put into the Rule line, and likewise for wall-clock or universal time.
Also, standard time is not always the simplest. The current EU rules
are specified in terms of universal time, and translating this to
standard time would complicate them.
I see that Tunisia one year had two transitions in the same month. Why
are these part of the rule rather than the zone?
Unfortunately, when I entered the Tunisian rules, I didn't have access
to the primary data -- just a series of transition times -- so I
couldn't easily tease out which changes corresponded to DST
transitions and which changes corresponded to rule changes (due to the
Allies taking territory from the Axis or vice versa). In cases like
these I generally just tried to minimize the length of the tz text
rather than guess exactly what the original data were.
Are there other examples of two transitions in the same month?
Certainly there have been others in real life. They may not have made
it into the tz tables. The Tunisian example is the shortest that I
know of in the current tables. Hawaii had DST for only three weeks in
1933; is that close enough?
Are there any DST systems that don't consist of two jumps in each
applicable year, one jump early in the year, one jump late in the year?
Yes. For example, occasionally Britain has had four jumps per year,
with double daylight saving in the middle. A more obscure example:
from October 1918 to February 1943 British Honduras used DST in the
winter, not the summer -- though obviously this can be modeled using
the same techniques that model ordinary southern-hemisphere DST.
Are there any rule lines that cover multiple years without being part of
such a pair?
I'd guess that you could find an example of a rule line that (for some
year) has no paired line, because the rules changed in the middle of
the year. Can't think of one offhand though.
More information about the tz