[tz] Non-valid timezones, is there a rule to remove them?
guy at alum.mit.edu
Thu Jan 23 09:21:42 UTC 2014
On Jan 22, 2014, at 6:31 PM, Paul Eggert <eggert at cs.ucla.edu> wrote:
> Fabiano Fidêncio wrote:
>> Looking at the zone.tab file I can see a few timezones that, although valid
>> in the past, they are not valid anymore. I can pick as example, reported on
>> the GNOME Bugzilla, Asia/Novosibirsk, that used to be UTC+7, but
>> nowadays is considered the same one than Asia/Almaty, which one is UTC+6.
> This appears to be a problem with some mapping between MSDN and the tz database. If so, I suggest writing to whoever's maintaining that mapping.
The link in the GNOME bug goes to
which is *NOT* a mapping between Microsoft's Time Zone Indexes and tz database tzids; it's a list of Time Zone Indexes, names for the zone in question, and time offsets and descriptions of the locale for the zone.
Some people might take the description of the locale for the name and use it to try to guess the tzid to which it maps, but, as far as I know, Microsoft makes no claim that the "Time" column on the page can be easily mapped to a tzid.
So there's no mapping to correct, other than perhaps a mapping made by Evolution-EWS.
As Tim Parenti asks:
> If the data we have is wrong, that's another matter. We currently have Novosibirsk as observing UTC+7 year-round since March 2011. If they switched back to UTC+6, do you know when they did so, or have any news reports documenting the change?
The entry in the europe file for Asia/Novosibirsk is
# From Paul Eggert (2006-08-19): I'm guessing about Tomsk here; it's
# not clear when it switched from +7 to +6.
# Novosibirskaya oblast', Tomskaya oblast'.
Zone Asia/Novosibirsk 5:31:40 - LMT 1919 Dec 14 6:00
6:00 - NOVT 1930 Jun 21 # Novosibirsk Time
7:00 Russia NOV%sT 1991 Mar 31 2:00s
6:00 Russia NOV%sT 1992 Jan 19 2:00s
7:00 Russia NOV%sT 1993 May 23 # say Shanks & P.
6:00 Russia NOV%sT 2011 Mar 27 2:00s
7:00 - NOVT
and the entry in the asia file for Asia/Almaty is
# Almaty (formerly Alma-Ata), representing most locations in Kazakhstan
Zone Asia/Almaty 5:07:48 - LMT 1924 May 2 # or Alma-Ata
5:00 - ALMT 1930 Jun 21 # Alma-Ata Time
6:00 RussiaAsia ALM%sT 1991
6:00 - ALMT 1992
6:00 RussiaAsia ALM%sT 2005 Mar 15
6:00 - ALMT
If Microsoft's table is correct to say
201 N. Central Asia Standard Time (GMT+06:00) Almaty, Novosibirsk
then the tzdb's Asia/Novosibirsk is wrong and needs to be updated to have a standard-time offset of +6:00, starting at whatever date and time it changed from +7:00. (As Parenti notes, this does *NOT* mean that Asia/Novosibirsk should be made an alias of Asia/Almaty, much less deleted, unless the history of the two zones is known to be identical post-1970 and appears to be identical pre-1970.)
If, however, Novosibirsk is 7 hours from GMT and Almaty is 6 hours from GMT, then Microsoft's table is wrong and needs to be updated to separate Almaty and Novosibirsk.
More information about the tz