[CCWG-ACCT] L. Gordon Crovitz in the WSJ: "Ted Cruz's Fight to Protect the Open Internet"

[Greg Shatan]

This opinion piece (behind a paywall) appeared on The Wall Street Journal's
website yesterday.

http://www.wsj.com/articles/ted-cruzs-fight-to-protect-the-open-internet-1438551531

I'm not sure what's more troubling; his embrace of Ted Cruz or his
misinterpretation of "consensus."

Sen. Ted Cruz (R-TX) wants to safeguard the open Internet from
> authoritarian regimes. You’d think that would be an easy position to take,
> but it’s not. The Texas senator and presidential candidate is bucking the
> leadership of his Republican Party to push hard against the Obama
> Administration plan to abandon America’s protection of the Internet from
> political interference. The Obama plan for Icann if the US contract ends
> now requires only a “consensus” among governments to dictate Internet
> policy. That’s a far lower standard than today’s requirement of unanimity
> and would further sideline US influence. The majority of authoritarian
> governments could act together to politicize Icann. Instead of censoring
> GayRightsInRussia.org or LiberateTibet.org only in their own countries,
> Russia and China could forge a “consensus” to impose a global ban.
> Protecting the open Internet was a bipartisan issue for many years and
> should be one again. The Obama Internet giveaway invites a high-profile
> campaign issue for politicians who oppose it. Considering the popularity of
> the Internet, being for it is better politics than being against it.


I wonder if Crovitz (and Cruz) would see a bylaws commitment to Human
Rights as a way to "protect the open Internet" and combat "political
interference" from "authoritarian governments"?  It might be the first time
they were Human Rights crusaders (other than for things like the "right" to
discriminate on the basis of religious beliefs, e.g., regarding gay
marriage)....​

Greg​
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mm.icann.org/pipermail/accountability-cross-community/attachments/20150803/c7f6572a/attachment.html>