[CCWG-ACCT] [community-finance] IANA Stewardship Transition - Project Expenses - FY16 Q3 update
Schaefer, Brett
Brett.Schaefer at heritage.org
Mon Aug 29 17:46:36 UTC 2016
Xavier,
Thank you for your response. I realize that the questions went beyond the scope of the quarterly spending report, but they were spurred by the additional details you provided. The questions are, I think, very important. I think we should know if the EC and individual SO/ACs will be able to access this type of information.
Best,
Brett
PS – I trimmed the cc list.
________________________________
Brett Schaefer
Jay Kingham Senior Research Fellow in International Regulatory Affairs
Margaret Thatcher Center for Freedom Davis Institute for National Security and Foreign Policy
The Heritage Foundation
214 Massachusetts Avenue, NE
Washington, DC 20002
202-608-6097
heritage.org<http://heritage.org/>
From: Xavier J. Calvez [mailto:xavier.calvez at icann.org]
Sent: Monday, August 22, 2016 11:04 AM
To: Schaefer, Brett; Zakir Syed; Marilyn Cade; Sam Lanfranco; Phil Corwin; Ken Stubbs; Paul Rosenzweig; cwg-stewardship at icann.org; 'CCWG-Accountability'
Cc: icann-board at icann.org; Executive Team; COMMS Team; community-finance at icann.org; 'Finance Staff'
Subject: Re: [CCWG-ACCT] [community-finance] IANA Stewardship Transition - Project Expenses - FY16 Q3 update
Dear Brett, Kavouss, et al,
As a reminder, this extensive email conversation was initiated by my email announcing the publication of our quarterly update on the IANA Stewardship transition expenses (Mid June). We have all used one of the item included in this information (Other professional services, and specifically the Engagement/education section) as an opportunity to exchange views on furthering ICANN’s transparency.
There have been many issues raised on this topic through this exchange, and well beyond the initial call of the email. This should move into a more structured conversation, such as WS2 Transparency subgroup, where issues of transparency and document disclosure are scheduled for conversation. I look forward to supporting the deliberations there and participating in the conversations.
Regarding your specific question at the end of your email below, I have already noted below that “ICANN does not have other lobbying activities, corresponding to the established definition of such activities.” ICANN does not have additional lobbying activities in the United States or outside of the U.S.
Best,
Thank you.
Best,
Xavier
Xavier Calvez
ICANN
CFO
12025 Waterfront Drive, Suite 300
Los Angeles, CA 90094
Office : +1 (310) 301 5838
Mobile : +1 (805) 312 0052
Fax : +1 (310) 957-2348
From: "Schaefer, Brett" <Brett.Schaefer at heritage.org<mailto:Brett.Schaefer at heritage.org>>
Date: Tuesday, August 9, 2016 at 1:19 PM
To: Xavier Calvez <xavier.calvez at icann.org<mailto:xavier.calvez at icann.org>>, Zakir Syed <zakirbinrehman at yahoo.com<mailto:zakirbinrehman at yahoo.com>>, Marilyn Cade <marilynscade at hotmail.com<mailto:marilynscade at hotmail.com>>, Sam Lanfranco <sam at lanfranco.net<mailto:sam at lanfranco.net>>, Phil Corwin <psc at vlaw-dc.com<mailto:psc at vlaw-dc.com>>, Ken Stubbs <kstubbs at afilias.info<mailto:kstubbs at afilias.info>>, Paul Rosenzweig <paul.rosenzweig at redbranchconsulting.com<mailto:paul.rosenzweig at redbranchconsulting.com>>, "cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>" <cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>>, 'CCWG-Accountability' <accountability-cross-community at icann.org<mailto:accountability-cross-community at icann.org>>
Cc: "icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>" <icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>>, Executive Team <executive-team at icann.org<mailto:executive-team at icann.org>>, COMMS Team <commsteam at icann.org<mailto:commsteam at icann.org>>, "community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>" <community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>>, Finance Staff <finance-staff at icann.org<mailto:finance-staff at icann.org>>
Subject: RE: [CCWG-ACCT] [community-finance] IANA Stewardship Transition - Project Expenses - FY16 Q3 update
Xavier,
Thank you for the response. I appreciate that this is more disclosure than ICANN has provided previously.
But I remain concerned over the lack of transparency. You said that “ICANN enters into confidentiality obligations as a result of bilateral negotiations with vendors.” I have several follow-up questions:
• Would this confidentiality obligation prevent disclosure through the DIDP process?
• Would this confidentiality obligation prevent individual Directors from obtaining this information through their Right of Inspection?
• Would this confidentiality obligation prevent an individual Decisional Participant from obtaining this information if they requested it under their right of inspection of ICANN accounting books and records pursuant to the provisions of Section 6333 of the CCC?
• Would this confidentiality obligation prevent the Empowered Community from obtaining the information through its right to launch a third-party, independent investigation if three Decisional Participants determine that there is a credible allegation that ICANN has committed fraud or that there has been a gross mismanagement of ICANN’s resources?
Finally, I did not see where you clarified whether ICANN engaged other vendors to perform similar tasks in non-US countries.
Best,
Brett
________________________________
Brett Schaefer
Jay Kingham Senior Research Fellow in International Regulatory Affairs
Margaret Thatcher Center for Freedom Davis Institute for National Security and Foreign Policy
The Heritage Foundation
214 Massachusetts Avenue, NE
Washington, DC 20002
202-608-6097
heritage.org<http://heritage.org/>
From: Xavier J. Calvez [mailto:xavier.calvez at icann.org]
Sent: Friday, August 05, 2016 4:52 PM
To: Schaefer, Brett; Zakir Syed; Marilyn Cade; Sam Lanfranco; Phil Corwin; Ken Stubbs; Paul Rosenzweig; cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>; 'CCWG-Accountability'
Cc: icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>; Executive Team; COMMS Team; community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>; 'Finance Staff'
Subject: Re: [CCWG-ACCT] [community-finance] IANA Stewardship Transition - Project Expenses - FY16 Q3 update
All,
I have taken several days to review the various inputs and questions you have provided in this email chain, and have involved several ICANN staff members on this topic. Here is [finally!] a response.
While ICANN is required under law to report in its form 990 on the identity and amounts paid to its five highest paid independent contractors, we exceed this requirement by reporting on amounts paid to all contractors to which ICANN pays over US$1,000,000 within a fiscal year. See, for example, ICANN’s Form 990 for FY15, at https://www.icann.org/en/system/files/files/fy-2015-form-990-10may16-en.pdf<https://www.icann.org/en/system/files/files/fy-2015-form-990-10may16-en.pdf>, pages 67-73. None of the vendors in the “Education/engagement” category reach the US$1,000,000 limit, therefore the issue of disclosure of the specific amounts of their work has not been triggered under ICANN’s expansive reporting practices. The reporting on lobbying expenditures, as has been previously discussed, is completed through ICANN’s Form 990 filing, as well as through the forms available at http://disclosures.house.gov/ld/ldsearch.aspx<http://disclosures.house.gov/ld/ldsearch.aspx>, which each identify both the specific issues covered in the lobbying activity as well as the House of the U.S. Congress or Federal Agency to which the activity was directed.
ICANN’s general vendor contracts (which are separate from the publicly available registry and registrar contracts) are commercial contracts containing commitments between two contracting entities. Many of these contracts contain confidentiality clauses, including those requested by vendors. This is normal throughout commercial contracting practice. For example, some vendors have propriety forms for their contracts that they do not want to release; some are subject to “MFN” clauses, which could require them to offer terms or services to other customers that are equal to more favorable clauses offered to other customers; some have confidential pricing schedules; some have propriety information included within the description of how they will deliver services; etc. ICANN’s ability to enter into these normal commercial contracts allows ICANN to obtain the best services needed at the best prices it can negotiate.
I hope this helps clarify the context under which confidentiality clauses may exist in ICANN’s contract, and that ICANN does not “require” confidentiality from the vendors, as some of you have inquired about.
ICANN has introduced an innovation into its contracting work in recent years: ICANN has imposed a requirement on all its contractors to fill out conflict of interest statements, which require both the contractor and ICANN to carefully consider the impact of other relationships as it may the work performed by ICANN. ICANN takes the issue of conflicts seriously, and expects its vendors to do the same. Most new contracts that ICANN enters into now contain such conflict of interest statements.
In light of the various questions or comments that arose from several of you, we have reviewed specifically the contracts with the vendors that are listed in the category of “Education/Engagement”, subject to Brett’s original request for information.
For the 7 contracts supporting the “education/engagement” services that ICANN has received, please find below the information that can be shared without challenging the contractual terms:
• Albright Stonebridge Group LLC – engagement and education support to raise awareness of, increase understanding of and increase participation in the IANA Stewardship Transition with stakeholders.
• Edelman·- public relations and communications support to raise awareness of, increase understanding of and increase participation in the IANA Stewardship Transition
• Interface Media – video content project in support of IANA Stewardship Transition
• Rice Hadley Gates LLC - engagement and education support to raise awareness of, increase understanding of and increase participation in the IANA Stewardship Transition with stakeholders.
• Summit Strategies International LLC - engagement and education support to raise awareness of, increase understanding of and increase participation in the IANA Stewardship Transition with US stakeholders.
• WBC Global - engagement and education support to raise awareness of, increase understanding of and increase participation in the IANA Stewardship Transition with US stakeholders.
• Wiley Rein LLP: strategic advice on global Internet Governance issues in the context of the IANA Stewardship Transition.
ICANN enters into confidentiality obligations as a result of bilateral negotiations with vendors - either using ICANN templates or vendor supplied templates. The confidentiality provisions in these 7 contracts were in many instances vendor supplied forms and do not allow, either explicitly or implicitly, for ICANN to disclose publicly the value of the services rendered, or, in several cases, any information pertaining to the contract without mutual agreement. This is consistent with common business and procurement practices, notably for professional services where services and financial terms are highly customized to each customer and project and are viewed by the service providers as competitive information.
Regarding lobbying expenses disclosure, lobbying is a well-defined activity in the US, and ICANN complies with all defined disclosure requirements, which those of you who are lobbyists themselves know well. None of the groups above were engaged in lobbying on behalf of ICANN. Again, refer to the blog posted in October 2015 on this topic (which I had included in my previous answers to the recurring questions on lobbying) referenced below. In addition, Brett has shared below the information that is disclosed by the lobbying firms that ICANN has engaged, retrieved from the link I shared in my previous email.
ICANN does not have other lobbying activities, corresponding to the established definition of such activities.
https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/lobbying-disclosures-contributions-2015-11-18-en<https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/lobbying-disclosures-contributions-2015-11-18-en>.
Though this is not fully reflecting the approaches that some of you had suggested, I hope this is helpful. While there is not much else that can be done at this stage in these specific items, we are thankful for your input and comments on this topic, as this has been a helpful exchange to set directions on future ICANN transparency enhancements, whether as part of WS2 or otherwise.
Thank you.
Best,
Xavier
Xavier Calvez
ICANN
CFO
12025 Waterfront Drive, Suite 300
Los Angeles, CA 90094
Office : +1 (310) 301 5838
Mobile : +1 (805) 312 0052
Fax : +1 (310) 957-2348
From: "Schaefer, Brett" <Brett.Schaefer at heritage.org<mailto:Brett.Schaefer at heritage.org>>
Date: Wednesday, August 3, 2016 at 11:43 AM
To: Xavier Calvez <xavier.calvez at icann.org<mailto:xavier.calvez at icann.org>>, Zakir Syed <zakirbinrehman at yahoo.com<mailto:zakirbinrehman at yahoo.com>>, Marilyn Cade <marilynscade at hotmail.com<mailto:marilynscade at hotmail.com>>, Sam Lanfranco <sam at lanfranco.net<mailto:sam at lanfranco.net>>, Phil Corwin <psc at vlaw-dc.com<mailto:psc at vlaw-dc.com>>, Ken Stubbs <kstubbs at afilias.info<mailto:kstubbs at afilias.info>>, Paul Rosenzweig <paul.rosenzweig at redbranchconsulting.com<mailto:paul.rosenzweig at redbranchconsulting.com>>
Cc: "cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>" <cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>>, 'CCWG-Accountability' <accountability-cross-community at icann.org<mailto:accountability-cross-community at icann.org>>, "icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>" <icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>>, Executive Team <executive-team at icann.org<mailto:executive-team at icann.org>>, COMMS Team <commsteam at icann.org<mailto:commsteam at icann.org>>, "community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>" <community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>>, Finance Staff <finance-staff at icann.org<mailto:finance-staff at icann.org>>
Subject: RE: [CCWG-ACCT] [community-finance] IANA Stewardship Transition - Project Expenses - FY16 Q3 update
Thank you, I look forward to seeing the information.
________________________________
Brett Schaefer
Jay Kingham Senior Research Fellow in International Regulatory Affairs
Margaret Thatcher Center for Freedom Davis Institute for National Security and Foreign Policy
The Heritage Foundation
214 Massachusetts Avenue, NE
Washington, DC 20002
202-608-6097
heritage.org<http://heritage.org/>
From: Xavier J. Calvez [mailto:xavier.calvez at icann.org]
Sent: Wednesday, August 03, 2016 2:40 PM
To: Schaefer, Brett; Zakir Syed; Marilyn Cade; Sam Lanfranco; Phil Corwin; Ken Stubbs; Paul Rosenzweig
Cc: cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>; 'CCWG-Accountability'; icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>; Executive Team; COMMS Team; community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>; 'Finance Staff'
Subject: Re: [CCWG-ACCT] [community-finance] IANA Stewardship Transition - Project Expenses - FY16 Q3 update
Brett,
Thank you for following. I apologize for the delay in responding. I am close and hope to send an email response by the end of tomorrow, if not earlier. As you all know, we are working hard on the IANA stewardship transition implementation plan and have many critical deliverables with due dates every week, which consume a lot of our time.
This is not to say that this topic is not fundamentally important, it is, but there are simply other urgent and important activities that we are attending to at the same time.
Thank you.
Best,
Xavier
Xavier Calvez
ICANN
CFO
12025 Waterfront Drive, Suite 300
Los Angeles, CA 90094
Office : +1 (310) 301 5838
Mobile : +1 (805) 312 0052
Fax : +1 (310) 957-2348
From: "Schaefer, Brett" <Brett.Schaefer at heritage.org<mailto:Brett.Schaefer at heritage.org>>
Date: Wednesday, August 3, 2016 at 10:40 AM
To: "Schaefer, Brett" <Brett.Schaefer at heritage.org<mailto:Brett.Schaefer at heritage.org>>, Zakir Syed <zakirbinrehman at yahoo.com<mailto:zakirbinrehman at yahoo.com>>, Marilyn Cade <marilynscade at hotmail.com<mailto:marilynscade at hotmail.com>>, Sam Lanfranco <sam at lanfranco.net<mailto:sam at lanfranco.net>>, Phil Corwin <psc at vlaw-dc.com<mailto:psc at vlaw-dc.com>>, Ken Stubbs <kstubbs at afilias.info<mailto:kstubbs at afilias.info>>, Paul Rosenzweig <paul.rosenzweig at redbranchconsulting.com<mailto:paul.rosenzweig at redbranchconsulting.com>>, Xavier Calvez <xavier.calvez at icann.org<mailto:xavier.calvez at icann.org>>
Cc: "cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>" <cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>>, 'CCWG-Accountability' <accountability-cross-community at icann.org<mailto:accountability-cross-community at icann.org>>, "icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>" <icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>>, Executive Team <executive-team at icann.org<mailto:executive-team at icann.org>>, COMMS Team <commsteam at icann.org<mailto:commsteam at icann.org>>, "community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>" <community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>>, Finance Staff <finance-staff at icann.org<mailto:finance-staff at icann.org>>
Subject: RE: [CCWG-ACCT] [community-finance] IANA Stewardship Transition - Project Expenses - FY16 Q3 update
Xavier,
I hope you are back in the office and recovered. I believe you said you would be providing this information when you returned?
Thanks,
Brett
________________________________
Brett Schaefer
Jay Kingham Senior Research Fellow in International Regulatory Affairs
Margaret Thatcher Center for Freedom Davis Institute for National Security and Foreign Policy
The Heritage Foundation
214 Massachusetts Avenue, NE
Washington, DC 20002
202-608-6097
heritage.org<http://heritage.org/>
From: accountability-cross-community-bounces at icann.org<mailto:accountability-cross-community-bounces at icann.org> [mailto:accountability-cross-community-bounces at icann.org] On Behalf Of Schaefer, Brett
Sent: Monday, July 25, 2016 2:29 PM
To: Zakir Syed; Marilyn Cade; Sam Lanfranco; Phil Corwin; Ken Stubbs; Paul Rosenzweig; 'Xavier J. Calvez'
Cc: cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>; 'CCWG-Accountability'; icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>; 'Executive Team'; 'COMMS Team'; community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>; 'Finance Staff'
Subject: Re: [CCWG-ACCT] [community-finance] IANA Stewardship Transition - Project Expenses - FY16 Q3 update
Xavier,
Are you planning to answer the questions raised in this thread?
Thanks,
Brett
________________________________
Brett Schaefer
Jay Kingham Senior Research Fellow in International Regulatory Affairs
Margaret Thatcher Center for Freedom Davis Institute for National Security and Foreign Policy
The Heritage Foundation
214 Massachusetts Avenue, NE
Washington, DC 20002
202-608-6097
heritage.org<http://heritage.org/>
From: Zakir Syed [mailto:zakirbinrehman at yahoo.com]
Sent: Friday, July 22, 2016 4:07 PM
To: Marilyn Cade; Sam Lanfranco; Phil Corwin; Ken Stubbs; Paul Rosenzweig; Schaefer, Brett; 'Xavier J. Calvez'
Cc: cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>; 'CCWG-Accountability'; icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>; 'Executive Team'; 'COMMS Team'; community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>; 'Finance Staff'
Subject: Re: [CCWG-ACCT] [community-finance] IANA Stewardship Transition - Project Expenses - FY16 Q3 update
This is very useful discussion particularly on this very list. Any idea, how are the consultants/contractors hired by ICANN?. If this is through an RFP/competitive bid thn may be the RFP will have the detail/requirement what is required which in other words will mean what the consultants do. Not?
Zakir
________________________________
From: Marilyn Cade <marilynscade at hotmail.com<mailto:marilynscade at hotmail.com>>
To: Sam Lanfranco <sam at lanfranco.net<mailto:sam at lanfranco.net>>; Phil Corwin <psc at vlaw-dc.com<mailto:psc at vlaw-dc.com>>; Ken Stubbs <kstubbs at afilias.info<mailto:kstubbs at afilias.info>>; Paul Rosenzweig <paul.rosenzweig at redbranchconsulting.com<mailto:paul.rosenzweig at redbranchconsulting.com>>; "'Schaefer, Brett'" <brett.schaefer at heritage.org<mailto:brett.schaefer at heritage.org>>; 'Xavier J. Calvez' <xavier.calvez at icann.org<mailto:xavier.calvez at icann.org>>
Cc: "cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>" <cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>>; 'CCWG-Accountability' <accountability-cross-community at icann.org<mailto:accountability-cross-community at icann.org>>; "icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>" <icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>>; 'Executive Team' <executive-team at icann.org<mailto:executive-team at icann.org>>; 'COMMS Team' <commsteam at icann.org<mailto:commsteam at icann.org>>; "community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>" <community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>>; 'Finance Staff' <finance-staff at icann.org<mailto:finance-staff at icann.org>>
Sent: Thursday, July 21, 2016 2:27 AM
Subject: Re: [CCWG-ACCT] [community-finance] IANA Stewardship Transition - Project Expenses - FY16 Q3 update
I'd like to stick to the topic we are discussing which is disclosure about 'advisors', and lobbyists, and not venture until the gTLDs contracts. I fear that would become a bog that is too unbounded, with some questioning the marketing plans of different gTLDs, like give aways, etc.
So, I ask that as this is the CCWG-ACCT, and the topic is about the amounts paid for consultants specifically working on the IANA transition -- and who they are -- and that they have only ICANN as a client, not also members of ICANN's community on directly related subjects -- we stick to that discussion.
All law firms in the US 'clear' conflicts before accepting a new client, and all corporations 'clear' their consultants. While this may be confidential in both these cases, I do agree that a public interest NGO, which is what ICANN is, can best serve itself, and the interest of the broader ICANN community by as much transparency as possible. BUT let's keep it high level and civil in our request for facts and figures.
As I like to say: Facts are our friends.
Of course, some issues have to be kept confidential.
Who the consultants are has been published, what they were paid would add to the transparency. What they do, at a high level, should be published as well. I will say again that I think that the work is probably much needed. I spend a lot of time -- without being paid -- explaining ICANN as I do my other IG work and it is is a worthwhile task and an important one if we are to demystify ICANN to RoW [Rest of World].
I am sure it is all above board, but it has now taken on a sort of taint of 'why not tell'.
Let's keep this high level and not make it a hunt for the details, but just get the high level facts, and make that a standard.
Will help us all.
M
________________________________
Subject: Re: [CCWG-ACCT] [community-finance] IANA Stewardship Transition - Project Expenses - FY16 Q3 update
To: psc at vlaw-dc.com<mailto:psc at vlaw-dc.com>; kstubbs at afilias.info<mailto:kstubbs at afilias.info>; paul.rosenzweig at redbranchconsulting.com<mailto:paul.rosenzweig at redbranchconsulting.com>; marilynscade at hotmail.com<mailto:marilynscade at hotmail.com>; brett.schaefer at heritage.org<mailto:brett.schaefer at heritage.org>; xavier.calvez at icann.org<mailto:xavier.calvez at icann.org>
CC: cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>; accountability-cross-community at icann.org<mailto:accountability-cross-community at icann.org>; icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>; executive-team at icann.org<mailto:executive-team at icann.org>; commsteam at icann.org<mailto:commsteam at icann.org>; community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>; finance-staff at icann.org<mailto:finance-staff at icann.org>
From: sam at lanfranco.net<mailto:sam at lanfranco.net>
Date: Wed, 20 Jul 2016 12:23:12 -0400
As the non-lawyer economist here I would like to observe that the discussion has honed in on a specific enough question, one that has an ICANN definitive answer, and that it should be put both to the Board and the new CEO for a an answer and clarification. I previously worried that the ICANN DNS contract with .sucks seemed to verge on ICANN exposing itself to the RICO act in the U.S., given the .sucks marketing plan. Maybe I am overly cautious but as a not-for-profit corporation operating in the public interest ICANN is more than obliged to provide clarity here. Silence won't do.
Sam Lanfranco, NPOC/CSIH
On 7/20/2016 12:06 PM, Phil Corwin wrote:
If the contract non-disclosure clause indeed violates IRS disclosure requirements then how could ICANN legal agree to it?
Philip S. Corwin, Founding Principal
Virtualaw LLC
1155 F Street, NW
Suite 1050
Washington, DC 20004
202-559-8597/Direct
202-559-8750/Fax
202-255-6172/Cell
Twitter: @VlawDC
"Luck is the residue of design" -- Branch Rickey
From: Ken Stubbs [mailto:kstubbs at afilias.info]
Sent: Wednesday, July 20, 2016 11:37 AM
To: Paul Rosenzweig; 'Marilyn Cade'; Phil Corwin; 'Schaefer, Brett'; 'Xavier J. Calvez'
Cc: cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>; 'CCWG-Accountability'; icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>; 'Executive Team'; 'COMMS Team'; community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>; 'Finance Staff'
Subject: Re: [community-finance] [CCWG-ACCT] IANA Stewardship Transition - Project Expenses - FY16 Q3 update
I believe Lori is correct here. IRS requirements on disclosures are
usually quite specific here
Ken Stubbs
On 7/20/16 10:32, Lori Schulman wrote:
I don’t believe that 501©3 orgs can consider any consulting fees confidential as the top fees are required to be reported on the 990.
Lori
Lori S. Schulman
Senior Director, Internet Policy
International Trademark Association (INTA)
+1-202-704-0408, Skype: lsschulman
From: accountability-cross-community-bounces at icann.org<mailto:accountability-cross-community-bounces at icann.org> [mailto:accountability-cross-community-bounces at icann.org] On Behalf Of Paul Rosenzweig
Sent: Wednesday, July 20, 2016 10:16 AM
To: 'Marilyn Cade' <marilynscade at hotmail.com><mailto:marilynscade at hotmail.com>; 'Phil Corwin' <psc at vlaw-dc.com><mailto:psc at vlaw-dc.com>; 'Schaefer, Brett' <brett.schaefer at heritage.org><mailto:brett.schaefer at heritage.org>; 'Xavier J. Calvez' <xavier.calvez at icann.org><mailto:xavier.calvez at icann.org>
Cc: cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>; 'CCWG-Accountability' <accountability-cross-community at icann.org><mailto:accountability-cross-community at icann.org>; icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>; 'Executive Team' <executive-team at icann.org><mailto:executive-team at icann.org>; 'COMMS Team' <commsteam at icann.org><mailto:commsteam at icann.org>; community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>; 'Finance Staff' <finance-staff at icann.org><mailto:finance-staff at icann.org>
Subject: Re: [CCWG-ACCT] IANA Stewardship Transition - Project Expenses - FY16 Q3 update
I agree completely with Marilyn and Phil. I have been on both sides of non-disclosure agreements – both ones requested by me and ones requested by my clients. Typically, a client (in the position of ICANN) may request that a consultant sign an NDA so as to protect the confidentiality of its efforts or its intellectual property. Sometimes a consultant might have a proprietary methodology or process that they are using on behalf of the client that they wish to protect.
Neither circumstance applies here that I can see. And in no case that I am aware of has a client ever asked me to keep confidential my fee … I don’t broadcast them, but I’m in the private sector. For ICANN, which is an NGO acting in the global public interest, I cannot see any reason at all why ICANN would want or agree to a confidentiality arrangement as to the size of the fee paid.
Xavier – can you tell us what the rationale is? I may be missing something …..
Thanks
Paul
Paul Rosenzweig
paul.rosenzweig at redbranchconsulting.com<mailto:paul.rosenzweig at redbranchconsulting.com>
O: +1 (202) 547-0660
M: +1 (202) 329-9650
VOIP: +1 (202) 738-1739
www.redbranchconsulting.com<http://www.redbranchconsulting.com/>
My PGP Key: http://redbranchconsulting.com/who-we-are/public-pgp-key/<http://redbranchconsulting.com/who-we-are/public-pgp-key/>
From: accountability-cross-community-bounces at icann.org<mailto:accountability-cross-community-bounces at icann.org> [mailto:accountability-cross-community-bounces at icann.org] On Behalf Of Marilyn Cade
Sent: Wednesday, July 20, 2016 9:05 AM
To: Phil Corwin <psc at vlaw-dc.com<mailto:psc at vlaw-dc.com>>; Schaefer, Brett <brett.schaefer at heritage.org<mailto:brett.schaefer at heritage.org>>; Xavier J. Calvez <xavier.calvez at icann.org<mailto:xavier.calvez at icann.org>>
Cc: cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>; CCWG-Accountability <accountability-cross-community at icann.org<mailto:accountability-cross-community at icann.org>>; icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>; Executive Team <executive-team at icann.org<mailto:executive-team at icann.org>>; COMMS Team <commsteam at icann.org<mailto:commsteam at icann.org>>; community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>; Finance Staff <finance-staff at icann.org<mailto:finance-staff at icann.org>>
Subject: Re: [CCWG-ACCT] IANA Stewardship Transition - Project Expenses - FY16 Q3 update
I support Phil's clarifying explanation.
I also think that anyone who is in this category, should have to declare if they re also representing companies in a SO/AC.
Or advising governments.
In the BC, we do not allow an ICANN consultant to be a BC member, regardless of the amount, but if someone is a backdoor advisor to ICANN and also a group of entities, in a SO/AC, that would not be so obvious, but I think that for integrity sake, of course, any such entity would recuse themselves from advising companies, while also advising ICANN.
And I would expect ICANN to disqualify such entities as their consultants.
Thanks, Phil, for this useful clarification.
M
________________________________
From: psc at vlaw-dc.com<mailto:psc at vlaw-dc.com>
To: Brett.Schaefer at heritage.org<mailto:Brett.Schaefer at heritage.org>; xavier.calvez at icann.org<mailto:xavier.calvez at icann.org>
Date: Wed, 20 Jul 2016 00:48:08 +0000
CC: cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>; accountability-cross-community at icann.org<mailto:accountability-cross-community at icann.org>; icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>; executive-team at icann.org<mailto:executive-team at icann.org>; commsteam at icann.org<mailto:commsteam at icann.org>; community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>; finance-staff at icann.org<mailto:finance-staff at icann.org>
Subject: Re: [CCWG-ACCT] IANA Stewardship Transition - Project Expenses - FY16 Q3 update
In the U.S. much of what used to be done by registered lobbyists is now performed by “strategic advisors” who walk right up to the line of what constitutes lobbying (and maybe a few inches over), and nonetheless facilitate door opening to key members of Congress and the Executive branch, and who “educate” rather than “lobby” members of both branches of government. So while the seven firms may not be engaged in what is considered lobbying under current U.S. law, they are still likely engaged in helping to assure officials outcomes desired by ICANN corporate.
It is for that reason – as well as for the exercise of effective oversight over ICANN budgeting and expenditures – that the community should have more data on this. If ICANN is prohibited by its contracts with these firms from disclosing its expenditures that is unfortunate – and in the future I would hope that ICANN would tell any firms being considered for such duties that its own transparency obligations to the community preclude it from agreeing to such restrictions (I’d wager that the majority of the firms would waive confidentiality rather than lose the contract).
At a minimum, ICANN should disclose the aggregate amounts spent with these seven firms since they were engaged – surely their contracts don’t bar such aggregate reporting.
Philip S. Corwin, Founding Principal
Virtualaw LLC
1155 F Street, NW
Suite 1050
Washington, DC 20004
202-559-8597/Direct
202-559-8750/Fax
202-255-6172/Cell
Twitter: @VlawDC
"Luck is the residue of design" -- Branch Rickey
From: accountability-cross-community-bounces at icann.org<mailto:accountability-cross-community-bounces at icann.org> [mailto:accountability-cross-community-bounces at icann.org] On Behalf Of Schaefer, Brett
Sent: Tuesday, July 19, 2016 1:04 PM
To: Xavier J. Calvez
Cc: cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>; CCWG-Accountability; icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>; Executive Team; COMMS Team; community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>; Finance Staff
Subject: Re: [CCWG-ACCT] IANA Stewardship Transition - Project Expenses - FY16 Q3 update
Xavier,
Are you saying that ICANN’s contracts for Education/Engagement/Advice with (1) Albright Stonebridge Group LLC, (2) Edelman, (3) Interface Media, (4) Rice Hadley Gates LLC, (5) Summit Strategies International LLC, (6) WBC Global, and (7) Wiley Rein LLP each contain confidentiality provisions that prohibit ICANN from disclosing the specific amount paid to each of these individual vendors?
Does this only apply to the CCWG and the public or does it also apply to other parts of the ICANN community, specifically the Supporting Organizations and Advisory Committees?
Thank you for the link on lobbying disclosures. For those who are interested, here are ICANN’s lobbying expenditures based on the disclosure website of the U.S. Congress.
[cid:image001.png at 01D201FB.C2778EC0]
I do have a couple of additional questions. Would this source capture lobbying exclusively directed toward the US Executive Branch? Has ICANN spent any funds during this period lobbying governments other than the US?
Thank you,
Brett
________________________________
Brett Schaefer
Jay Kingham Senior Research Fellow in International Regulatory Affairs
Margaret Thatcher Center for Freedom Davis Institute for National Security and Foreign Policy
The Heritage Foundation
214 Massachusetts Avenue, NE
Washington, DC 20002
202-608-6097
heritage.org<http://heritage.org/>
From: Xavier J. Calvez [mailto:xavier.calvez at icann.org]
Sent: Monday, July 18, 2016 6:30 PM
To: Schaefer, Brett
Cc: community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>; cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>; CCWG-Accountability; Executive Team; COMMS Team; icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>; Finance Staff
Subject: Re: [CCWG-ACCT] IANA Stewardship Transition - Project Expenses - FY16 Q3 update
Brett,
Yes, the information I provided in my latest email had been included in some previous communication. I just wanted to make sure you had a clear visibility on this information, which provides for (i) categories of expenses, (ii) the individual names of the vendors grouped for each category, and (iii) the total value of the expenses for each category.
With respect to the contractual obligations of confidentiality in commercial contracts, ICANN is subject to them, like all business organizations. That said, we disclose what we can consistent with standard business confidentiality provisions in vendor contracts. We cannot disclose the specific amount of spend with each vendor but we were able to disclose the names of the service providers engaged.
Regarding the lobbying expenses, as you are aware, both organizations that hire lobbyists and firms that lobby on behalf of organizations are required under U.S. federal law to file lobbying disclosure reports. In addition to ICANN’s quarterly lobbying disclosures posted on our website, you can find the amounts ICANN has paid to individual outside lobbying firms at http://disclosures.house.gov/ld/ldsearch.aspx<http://disclosures.house.gov/ld/ldsearch.aspx>.
I hope this helps and clarifies.
Thank you.
Best,
Xavier
Xavier Calvez
ICANN
CFO
12025 Waterfront Drive, Suite 300
Los Angeles, CA 90094
Office : +1 (310) 301 5838
Mobile : +1 (805) 312 0052
Fax : +1 (310) 957-2348
From: "Schaefer, Brett" <Brett.Schaefer at heritage.org<mailto:Brett.Schaefer at heritage.org>>
Date: Thursday, July 14, 2016 at 7:07 AM
To: Xavier Calvez <xavier.calvez at icann.org<mailto:xavier.calvez at icann.org>>
Cc: "community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>" <community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>>, "cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>" <cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>>, CCWG-Accountability <accountability-cross-community at icann.org<mailto:accountability-cross-community at icann.org>>, Executive Team <executive-team at icann.org<mailto:executive-team at icann.org>>, COMMS Team <commsteam at icann.org<mailto:commsteam at icann.org>>, "icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>" <icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>>, Finance Staff <finance-staff at icann.org<mailto:finance-staff at icann.org>>
Subject: Re: [CCWG-ACCT] IANA Stewardship Transition - Project Expenses - FY16 Q3 update
Xavier,
This is pretty much the same information that was provided before. I am asking for a breakdown of how much was paid to each vender in the lobbying category (Akin Gump, etc.) and the education/engagement/advice category (Albright Stoneridge, etc.).
Thank you,
Brett
On Jul 13, 2016, at 8:13 PM, Xavier J. Calvez <xavier.calvez at icann.org<mailto:xavier.calvez at icann.org>> wrote:
Dear Brett,
In response to your question listed below on 22 June: the detailed information provided on Other professional fees (other than legal fees, detailed in a separate section of the “Transition project cost” expense webpage, on the IANA Stewardship Transition webpage) can be found in the section called “Professional Services – Expenses Breakdown”. Within this section, you will find a link to a document that provides the list of Professional Services (other than legal fees) incurred, by category, with the names of the vendors, and the total amount of expenditures for the category.
This link is copied below and was provided in my first answer to your question. I have also attached the file to which this link refers in case the link would not work for you.
https://www.icann.org/en/system/files/files/iana-stewardship-expenses-professional-vendor-01jun16-en.pdf<https://www.icann.org/en/system/files/files/iana-stewardship-expenses-professional-vendor-01jun16-en.pdf>
If this not addressing your question, please let me know.
Thank you.
Best,
Xavier
Xavier Calvez
ICANN
CFO
12025 Waterfront Drive, Suite 300
Los Angeles, CA 90094
Office : +1 (310) 301 5838
Mobile : +1 (805) 312 0052
Fax : +1 (310) 957-2348
________________________________
Brett Schaefer
Jay Kingham Senior Research Fellow in International Regulatory Affairs
Margaret Thatcher Center for Freedom Davis Institute for National Security and Foreign Policy
The Heritage Foundation
214 Massachusetts Avenue, NE
Washington, DC 20002
202-608-6097
heritage.org<http://heritage.org/>
From: Xavier Calvez <xavier.calvez at icann.org<mailto:xavier.calvez at icann.org>>
Date: Tuesday, July 12, 2016 at 9:45 AM
To: "Schaefer, Brett" <Brett.Schaefer at heritage.org<mailto:Brett.Schaefer at heritage.org>>, "community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>" <community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>>, "cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>" <cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>>, CCWG-Accountability <accountability-cross-community at icann.org<mailto:accountability-cross-community at icann.org>>
Cc: Executive Team <executive-team at icann.org<mailto:executive-team at icann.org>>, COMMS Team <commsteam at icann.org<mailto:commsteam at icann.org>>, "icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>" <icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>>, Finance Staff <finance-staff at icann.org<mailto:finance-staff at icann.org>>
Subject: Re: [CCWG-ACCT] IANA Stewardship Transition - Project Expenses - FY16 Q3 update
Brett,
Thank you for following up.
I will make sure to respond no later than the end of this week.
Thank you.
Best,
Xavier
Xavier Calvez
ICANN
CFO
12025 Waterfront Drive, Suite 300
Los Angeles, CA 90094
Office : +1 (310) 301 5838
Mobile : +1 (805) 312 0052
Fax : +1 (310) 957-2348
From: "Schaefer, Brett" <Brett.Schaefer at heritage.org<mailto:Brett.Schaefer at heritage.org>>
Date: Tuesday, July 12, 2016 at 11:38 AM
To: Xavier Calvez <xavier.calvez at icann.org<mailto:xavier.calvez at icann.org>>, "community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>" <community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>>, "cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>" <cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>>, CCWG-Accountability <accountability-cross-community at icann.org<mailto:accountability-cross-community at icann.org>>
Cc: Executive Team <executive-team at icann.org<mailto:executive-team at icann.org>>, COMMS Team <commsteam at icann.org<mailto:commsteam at icann.org>>, "icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>" <icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>>, Finance Staff <finance-staff at icann.org<mailto:finance-staff at icann.org>>
Subject: RE: [CCWG-ACCT] IANA Stewardship Transition - Project Expenses - FY16 Q3 update
Xavier,
Thanks for promising to get this information to me in Helsinki. Do you have an estimate for when it will be provided?
Thanks,
Brett
________________________________
Brett Schaefer
Jay Kingham Senior Research Fellow in International Regulatory Affairs
Margaret Thatcher Center for Freedom Davis Institute for National Security and Foreign Policy
The Heritage Foundation
214 Massachusetts Avenue, NE
Washington, DC 20002
202-608-6097
heritage.org<http://heritage.org/>
From: Schaefer, Brett
Sent: Wednesday, June 22, 2016 2:39 PM
To: 'Xavier J. Calvez'; community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>; cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>; CCWG-Accountability
Cc: Executive Team; COMMS Team; icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>; Finance Staff
Subject: RE: [CCWG-ACCT] IANA Stewardship Transition - Project Expenses - FY16 Q3 update
Xavier,
I appreciate the detailed breakdown on the legal fees That is indeed what I was looking for though I would think it useful to have the totals provided in the summary document.
However, I did not see similar information for lobbying or education/ engagement/advice in the links provided. In fact, the only specific information that I saw listed is for Jamie Hedlund at $200,000. No information on other individual firms or vendors is listed at all – only the top line budget expenditure in the summary document link originally sent around.
Could you provide that information?
Thanks,
Brett
From: Xavier J. Calvez [mailto:xavier.calvez at icann.org]
Sent: Wednesday, June 22, 2016 10:43 AM
To: Schaefer, Brett; community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>; cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>; CCWG-Accountability
Cc: Executive Team; COMMS Team; icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>; Finance Staff
Subject: Re: [CCWG-ACCT] IANA Stewardship Transition - Project Expenses - FY16 Q3 update
Dear all,
It appears that the first link in my email further below (detail of legal fees by firm) does not resolve correctly. Please use the below instead.
https://www.icann.org/en/system/files/files/iana-stewardship-expenses-legal-firm-fy16-01jun16-en.pdf<https://www.icann.org/en/system/files/files/iana-stewardship-expenses-legal-firm-fy16-01jun16-en.pdf>
Thank you.
Best,
Xavier
Xavier Calvez
ICANN
CFO
12025 Waterfront Drive, Suite 300
Los Angeles, CA 90094
Office : +1 (310) 301 5838
Mobile : +1 (805) 312 0052
Fax : +1 (310) 957-2348
From: Xavier Calvez <xavier.calvez at icann.org<mailto:xavier.calvez at icann.org>>
Date: Wednesday, June 22, 2016 at 1:01 PM
To: "Schaefer, Brett" <Brett.Schaefer at heritage.org<mailto:Brett.Schaefer at heritage.org>>, "community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>" <community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>>, "cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>" <cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>>, CCWG-Accountability <accountability-cross-community at icann.org<mailto:accountability-cross-community at icann.org>>
Cc: Executive Team <executive-team at icann.org<mailto:executive-team at icann.org>>, COMMS Team <commsteam at icann.org<mailto:commsteam at icann.org>>, "icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>" <icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>>, Finance Staff <finance-staff at icann.org<mailto:finance-staff at icann.org>>
Subject: Re: [CCWG-ACCT] IANA Stewardship Transition - Project Expenses - FY16 Q3 update
Dear Brett,
Thank you for your interest and question.
We currently publish the list of all vendors from whom ICANN obtain services in relation to the IANA Stewardship transition. The $$ value of the services received is aggregated by category of expenses, which you mention below (US Government affairs, Education/engagement/advice,…). This presentation is driven by 2 factors: providing clarity as to the type of services received, and abiding by the contractual obligation of confidentiality in force with each of the vendors (resulting from standard business sensitive information).
We do publish however the detail of the legal advice, by firm and by working group, on this same page (see for example the link to the report of fees by firm: https://www.icann.org/en/system/files/files/iana-stewardship-expenses-legal-firm-fy16-01jun16-en.pdf)<https://www.icann.org/en/system/files/files/iana-stewardship-expenses-legal-firm-fy16-01jun16-en.pdf%29>.
You will also find more information relative to ICANN’s lobbying in the following blog published a few months ago. In this blog, you will also find links to the disclosure reports that ICANN makes on lobbying activities.
https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/lobbying-disclosures-contributions-2015-11-18-en<https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/lobbying-disclosures-contributions-2015-11-18-en>.
Lastly, further information on lobbying appears in ICANN’s form 990 (Schedule C, Part II-B. On page 33/73 of the FY15 form 990 published at the following link):
https://www.icann.org/en/system/files/files/fy-2015-form-990-10may16-en.pdf<https://www.icann.org/en/system/files/files/fy-2015-form-990-10may16-en.pdf>
I hope this helps. Please let me know if you have further questions.
Thank you.
Best,
Xavier
Xavier Calvez
ICANN
CFO
12025 Waterfront Drive, Suite 300
Los Angeles, CA 90094
Office : +1 (310) 301 5838
Mobile : +1 (805) 312 0052
Fax : +1 (310) 957-2348
From: "Schaefer, Brett" <Brett.Schaefer at heritage.org<mailto:Brett.Schaefer at heritage.org>>
Date: Tuesday, June 21, 2016 at 9:54 PM
To: Xavier Calvez <xavier.calvez at icann.org<mailto:xavier.calvez at icann.org>>, "community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>" <community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>>, "cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>" <cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>>, CCWG-Accountability <accountability-cross-community at icann.org<mailto:accountability-cross-community at icann.org>>
Cc: Executive Team <executive-team at icann.org<mailto:executive-team at icann.org>>, COMMS Team <commsteam at icann.org<mailto:commsteam at icann.org>>, "icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>" <icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>>, Finance Staff <finance-staff at icann.org<mailto:finance-staff at icann.org>>
Subject: RE: [CCWG-ACCT] IANA Stewardship Transition - Project Expenses - FY16 Q3 update
Xavier,
Thank you. Could you please provide a more detailed breakdown of legal advice, US government affairs, and educations/engagement/advice? In each category, there are multiple firms/vendors listed (https://www.icann.org/en/system/files/files/iana-stewardship-expenses-professional-vendor-01jun16-en.pdf<https://www.icann.org/en/system/files/files/iana-stewardship-expenses-professional-vendor-01jun16-en.pdf>). I would appreciate the amount provided to each individual vendor. If it is provided somewhere, I would appreciate you letting me know where to find it.
Much appreciated,
Brett
________________________________
Brett Schaefer
Jay Kingham Senior Research Fellow in International Regulatory Affairs
Margaret Thatcher Center for Freedom Davis Institute for National Security and Foreign Policy
The Heritage Foundation
214 Massachusetts Avenue, NE
Washington, DC 20002
202-608-6097
heritage.org<http://heritage.org/>
From: accountability-cross-community-bounces at icann.org<mailto:accountability-cross-community-bounces at icann.org> [mailto:accountability-cross-community-bounces at icann.org] On Behalf Of Xavier J. Calvez
Sent: Saturday, June 18, 2016 12:10 AM
To: community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>; cwg-stewardship at icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship at icann.org>; CCWG-Accountability
Cc: Executive Team; COMMS Team; icann-board at icann.org<mailto:icann-board at icann.org>; Finance Staff
Subject: [CCWG-ACCT] IANA Stewardship Transition - Project Expenses - FY16 Q3 update
Dear all,
You find at the link below the updated project’s expenses as of FY16 Q3 (from July 2014 to March 2016). As indicated a few months ago, we have added new detailed information on the staff support with the individual positions, names and percentages of effort over the period.
https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/iana-stewardship-project-costs<https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/iana-stewardship-project-costs>
Thank you.
Best,
Xavier
Xavier Calvez
ICANN
CFO
12025 Waterfront Drive, Suite 300
Los Angeles, CA 90094
Office : +1 (310) 301 5838
Mobile : +1 (805) 312 0052
Fax : +1 (310) 957-2348
<iana-stewardship-expenses-professional-vendor-01jun16-en.pdf>
_______________________________________________ Accountability-Cross-Community mailing list Accountability-Cross-Community at icann.org<mailto:Accountability-Cross-Community at icann.org> https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/accountability-cross-community<https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/accountability-cross-community>
_______________________________________________
community-finance mailing list
community-finance at icann.org<mailto:community-finance at icann.org>
https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/community-finance<https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/community-finance>
_______________________________________________
Accountability-Cross-Community mailing list
Accountability-Cross-Community at icann.org<mailto:Accountability-Cross-Community at icann.org>
https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/accountability-cross-community<https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/accountability-cross-community>
--
------------------------------------------------
"It is a disgrace to be rich and honoured
in an unjust state" -Confucius
邦有道，贫且贱焉，耻也。邦无道，富且贵焉，耻也
------------------------------------------------
Dr Sam Lanfranco (Prof Emeritus & Senior Scholar)
Econ, York U., Toronto, Ontario, CANADA - M3J 1P3
email: Lanfran at Yorku.ca<mailto:Lanfran at Yorku.ca> Skype: slanfranco
blog: http://samlanfranco.blogspot.com<http://samlanfranco.blogspot.com/>
Phone: +1 613-476-0429 cell: +1 416-816-2852
_______________________________________________
Accountability-Cross-Community mailing list
Accountability-Cross-Community at icann.org<mailto:Accountability-Cross-Community at icann.org>
https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/accountability-cross-community<https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/accountability-cross-community>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mm.icann.org/pipermail/accountability-cross-community/attachments/20160829/8b412c49/attachment-0001.html>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: image001.png
Type: image/png
Size: 90454 bytes
Desc: image001.png
URL: <http://mm.icann.org/pipermail/accountability-cross-community/attachments/20160829/8b412c49/image001-0001.png>
More information about the Accountability-Cross-Community
mailing list