[Comments-rss-governance-23may19] Comments on Evolving the Governance of the Root Server System

[IAB Chair]

The IAB thanks ICANN and the Root Server Operators for the opportunity 
to comment on this draft governance model.  The IAB believes that it 
would be able to perform those duties discussed in the model, which we 
understand to be:


  * Appointing two representatives to the Governance Working Group
  * Reviewing  the work of the Governance Working Group.
  * Coordinating with the Root Server System Governance Board
  * Appointing a member of Root Server System Standing Committee.


We do note two areas where the drafters may wish to consider providing 
more detail.  The first is the work of the secretariat in facilitating 
liaisons.  The text currently says, in part:

  * Coordinating and providing transparency to the operationalization of
    appropriate standards (e.g., RSSAC publications and IETF RFCs).
  * Assuming new coordination roles that could be defined in the future


The IAB believes that a description of which coordination roles would be 
under the Secretariat would be useful, as the RGB and IAB will evidently 
also coordinate with each other directly. Similarly, clarification of 
whether the coordination envisioned for the deployment of standards will 
include contributions to the relevant IETF working groups would be useful.

As a second point, the text on the work of the Root Server Operator 
Review Panel contains no direct references to the appeal path of any 
decisions it takes.  The IAB understands the text to imply that the 
ICANN Board's approval is the first confirmation of RRP decisions and 
that further appeals take the form of reconsideration requests as set 
out in Article 4 of the ICANN Bylaws.  If that is the case, explicit 
statements in this document may make the document more comprehensible to 
a broad audience.  If it is not the case, the IAB would welcome other 
clarifications of this point.

regards,

Ted Hardie
for the IAB
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mm.icann.org/pipermail/comments-rss-governance-23may19/attachments/20190712/8794062c/attachment.html>