[council] CCWG Ig and NetMundial statements

Avri Doria avri at acm.org
Wed Mar 5 07:35:55 UTC 2014


Hi,

I am an observer in this group and see that it is working on a statement.

Isn't this a statement that the various contributing SO/AC need to 
review before it gets sent in? Or are we comfortable with just letting 
them do their own thing and submit something that is in some sense in 
our name as a CCWG, but not vetted.

The group process troubles me as it wasn't even able to complete a 
charter before starting to craft statements and has a unbalanced 
membership.  In fact it is much more a GNSO group, though following no 
specific or guidelines, than a cross community one at this point as 
there has not been wide cross community buy-in yet.

Of course I have no issue with a bunch of people signing their own names 
to anything they wish, but I would be against a group sending something 
out in the name of the cross community that had never even reviewed the 
WG's efforts.

I do believe in the eventual utility of this group, but I would like to 
see it organized on a firm ross community footing before it starts 
making declarations to the world.

avri



More information about the council mailing list