[Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg] Statement in Support of Transactional Distinction
Stephanie Perrin
stephanie.perrin at mail.utoronto.ca
Thu Apr 30 21:15:58 UTC 2015
Thanks very much Graeme, I think it would be great to do this. DIfferent
time zones also makes these deadlines hairy....I am now suffering in
Holly's timezone so I feel the pain of our trans-pacific partners on
this working group.
Thanks for your patience, Vice Chairs!
Stephanie Perrin
On 2015-05-01 3:51, Graeme Bunton wrote:
> Hello All.
>
> We're getting pretty heated here and it's not helping us in our
> collective goal.
>
> First, please, let's all take some time to let this cool down.
>
> Second, Steve, Staff and I will review where we're at and the
> discussions today to see if we find a way to move forward.
>
> We'll start a new thread on the collection of statements and section
> 1.3.3 after we've had that conversation.
>
> Thanks
>
> Graeme
>
> On 2015-04-30 2:42 PM, Kiran Malancharuvil wrote:
>> Ombudsman.
>>
>> Kiran Malancharuvil
>> Internet Policy Counselor
>> MarkMonitor
>> 415-419-9138 (m)
>>
>> Sent from my mobile, please excuse any typos.
>>
>>> On Apr 30, 2015, at 11:41 AM, Jennifer Gore Standiford
>>> <JStandiford at web.com> wrote:
>>>
>>> James,
>>> Thank you for your response and I fully concur.
>>>
>>> Kiran,
>>> I am personally offended by your comments below re. " obstructionist
>>> bullshit" and 'wasting my time". I like to think you would be
>>> willing guide newcomers in a more positive approach re. acceptable
>>> forms of communication i.e. onlist vs offlist.
>>>
>>> Thank you,
>>> Jennifer Standiford
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> -----Original Message-----
>>> From: gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg-bounces at icann.org
>>> [mailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg-bounces at icann.org] On Behalf Of James Gannon
>>> Sent: Thursday, April 30, 2015 2:29 PM
>>> To: Kiran Malancharuvil
>>> Cc: gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org
>>> Subject: Re: [Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg] Statement in Support of
>>> Transactional Distinction
>>>
>>> I hope that we can agree that a desire to present a balanced
>>> viewpoint of the deliberations of a PDP is certainly not
>>> 'obstructionist bullshit', we may differ on what that viewpoint is
>>> but surely we are all working to a common goal here? Or am I naive
>>> in my approach to this? We are all supposed to be working for the
>>> best interest of Internet users according to
>>> https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/expected-standards-2012-05-15-en
>>> it even specifically calls it out:
>>>
>>>> Act in a reasonable, objective and informed manner when
>>>> participating in policy development and decision-making processes.
>>>> This includes regularly attending all scheduled meetings and
>>>> exercising independent judgment >based solely on what is in the
>>>> overall best interest of Internet users and the stability and
>>>> security of the Internet's system of unique identifiers,
>>>> irrespective of personal interests and the interests of the entity
>>>> to which an >individual might owe their appointment.
>>>> Listen to the views of all stakeholders when considering policy
>>>> issues. ICANN is a unique multi-stakeholder environment. Those who
>>>> take part in the ICANN process must acknowledge the importance of
>>>> all stakeholders and >seek to understand their points of view.
>>>> Work to build consensus with other stakeholders in order to find
>>>> solutions to the issues that fall within the areas of ICANN's
>>>> responsibility. The ICANN model is based on a bottom-up, consensus
>>>> driven approach to policy >development. Those who take part in the
>>>> ICANN process must take responsibility for ensuring the success of
>>>> the model by trying to build consensus with other participants.
>>> This is my first PDP, as I am still a newcomer to ICANN, so maybe I
>>> have not gotten weary in my approach to these things but I stand by
>>> my conviction that we are all here for the common good and feel that
>>> we should be attempting to work with each other and not against each
>>> other. And I hope I'm not the only one who thinks that.
>>>
>>> I'm done for today.
>>>
>>> -James
>>>
>>> -----Original Message-----
>>> From: Kiran Malancharuvil [mailto:Kiran.Malancharuvil at markmonitor.com]
>>> Sent: Thursday, April 30, 2015 6:49 PM
>>> To: James Gannon
>>> Subject: Re: [Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg] Statement in Support of
>>> Transactional Distinction
>>>
>>> Please don't clutter my inbox with private messages that have no
>>> value in advancing the goal of including a fair representation of
>>> all viewpoints. If you have something to say, say it on the list.
>>>
>>> I don't have time for this obstructionist bullshit, and I have no
>>> desire to keep it civil when you and others are wasting my time.
>>>
>>> K
>>>
>>> Kiran Malancharuvil
>>> Internet Policy Counselor
>>> MarkMonitor
>>> 415-419-9138 (m)
>>>
>>> Sent from my mobile, please excuse any typos.
>>>
>>>> On Apr 30, 2015, at 10:46 AM, James Gannon
>>>> <james at cyberinvasion.net> wrote:
>>>>
>>>> Kiran I have no issue with you including a statement, or interest
>>>> in 'silencing' your right to do so, I just ask that it be clear
>>>> that it's a statement of an individual not of the WG.
>>>> Let's keep things civil and try and work together to get this over
>>>> the hill.
>>>>
>>>> -James
>>>>
>>>> -----Original Message-----
>>>> From: Kiran Malancharuvil [mailto:Kiran.Malancharuvil at markmonitor.com]
>>>> Sent: Thursday, April 30, 2015 6:44 PM
>>>> To: James Gannon
>>>> Subject: Re: [Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg] Statement in Support of
>>>> Transactional Distinction
>>>>
>>>> Apologies for your intent? To silence opposition? Yeah... No thanks.
>>>>
>>>> K
>>>>
>>>> Kiran Malancharuvil
>>>> Internet Policy Counselor
>>>> MarkMonitor
>>>> 415-419-9138 (m)
>>>>
>>>> Sent from my mobile, please excuse any typos.
>>>>
>>>>> On Apr 30, 2015, at 10:42 AM, James Gannon
>>>>> <james at cyberinvasion.net> wrote:
>>>>>
>>>>> Sent a clarification there just missed a word, my mistake, the
>>>>> intent of the message stands.
>>>>>
>>>>> Thanks and apologies
>>>>>
>>>>> -James
>>>>>
>>>>> -----Original Message-----
>>>>> From: Kiran Malancharuvil
>>>>> [mailto:Kiran.Malancharuvil at markmonitor.com]
>>>>> Sent: Thursday, April 30, 2015 6:41 PM
>>>>> To: James Gannon
>>>>> Cc: Metalitz, Steven; mary.wong at icann.org;
>>>>> gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org
>>>>> Subject: Re: [Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg] Statement in Support of
>>>>> Transactional
>>>>> Distinction
>>>>>
>>>>> Any single member of the wg can submit. There is not (and was not)
>>>>> time to solicit formal approval from an SG. Also, membership in an
>>>>> SG/AC/C is not a prerequisite to participation in a wg.
>>>>>
>>>>> K
>>>>>
>>>>> Kiran Malancharuvil
>>>>> Internet Policy Counselor
>>>>> MarkMonitor
>>>>> 415-419-9138 (m)
>>>>>
>>>>> Sent from my mobile, please excuse any typos.
>>>>>
>>>>> On Apr 30, 2015, at 10:39 AM, James Gannon
>>>>> <james at cyberinvasion.net<mailto:james at cyberinvasion.net>> wrote:
>>>>>
>>>>> Sorry but my understanding is that accompanying statements should
>>>>> be on behalf of a group (Be it AC/SO/Constituency) and not deem to
>>>>> speak on behalf of the group.
>>>>> This statement will be highly confusing to the public as it makes
>>>>> it appear that the PPSAI WG endorses its contents.
>>>>>
>>>>> -James
>>>>>
>>>>> From:
>>>>> gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg-bounces at icann.org<mailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg-bounces at i
>>>>>
>>>>> cann.org> [mailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg-bounces at icann.org] On Behalf Of
>>>>> Kiran Malancharuvil
>>>>> Sent: Thursday, April 30, 2015 6:10 PM
>>>>> To: Metalitz, Steven; mary.wong at icann.org<mailto:mary.wong at icann.org>
>>>>> Cc: gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org<mailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org>
>>>>> Subject: [Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg] Statement in Support of Transactional
>>>>> Distinction
>>>>>
>>>>> Please include the attached statement in support of the
>>>>> transactional distinction. It was prepared by a number of the
>>>>> proponents of this provision.
>>>>>
>>>>> Thank you.
>>>>>
>>>>> Best,
>>>>>
>>>>> Kiran
>>>>>
>>>>> From: Metalitz, Steven [mailto:met at msk.com]
>>>>> Sent: Thursday, April 30, 2015 9:28 AM
>>>>> To: Kiran Malancharuvil
>>>>> Cc: Graeme Bunton;
>>>>> gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org<mailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org>
>>>>> Subject: RE: [Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg] PPSAI Comment Period and Section
>>>>> 1.3.3
>>>>>
>>>>> Kiran,
>>>>>
>>>>> Of course you (and any other member of the WG) can submit a
>>>>> separate statement today and can include in it whatever you wish.
>>>>> We have asked that statements be limited to 1-2 pages if at all
>>>>> possible.
>>>>>
>>>>> Steve
>>>>>
>>>>> From: Kiran Malancharuvil
>>>>> [mailto:Kiran.Malancharuvil at markmonitor.com]
>>>>> Sent: Thursday, April 30, 2015 12:26 PM
>>>>> To: Metalitz, Steven
>>>>> Cc: Graeme Bunton;
>>>>> gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org<mailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org>
>>>>> Subject: Re: [Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg] PPSAI Comment Period and Section
>>>>> 1.3.3
>>>>>
>>>>> Steve,
>>>>>
>>>>> I'm not sure I understand what is being proposed here.
>>>>>
>>>>> Are we still able to submit our statement (the deadline is today)?
>>>>> Are we allowed to link to the white paper in our statement?
>>>>>
>>>>> What links are to be provided? Just a link to the mailing list
>>>>> archive and call transcripts? That would not be appropriate.
>>>>> Asking folks to sort through the emails/calls looking for relevant
>>>>> information means that it will be essentially buried and
>>>>> inaccessible.
>>>>>
>>>>> K
>>>>>
>>>>> Kiran Malancharuvil
>>>>> Internet Policy Counselor
>>>>> MarkMonitor
>>>>> 415-419-9138 (m)
>>>>>
>>>>> Sent from my mobile, please excuse any typos.
>>>>>
>>>>> On Apr 30, 2015, at 8:38 AM, Metalitz, Steven
>>>>> <met at msk.com<mailto:met at msk.com<mailto:met at msk.com%3cmailto:met at msk.com>>>
>>>>> wrote:
>>>>>
>>>>> Graeme and I have asked staff to insert a footnote in this
>>>>> section, providing links to the extensive discussions of the topic
>>>>> in WG meetings (telephonic and face to face) and on the mailing
>>>>> list, as background for the public.
>>>>>
>>>>> Steve
>>>>>
>>>>> From:
>>>>> gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg-bounces at icann.org<mailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg-bounces at i
>>>>>
>>>>> cann.org<mailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg-bounces at icann.org%3cmailto:gnso-ppsa
>>>>>
>>>>> i-pdp-wg-bounces at icann.org>>
>>>>> [mailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg-bounces at icann.org] On Behalf Of Graeme
>>>>> Bunton
>>>>> Sent: Thursday, April 30, 2015 11:14 AM
>>>>> To:
>>>>> gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org<mailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org<mailto:
>>>>>
>>>>> gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org%3cmailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org>>
>>>>> Subject: Re: [Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg] PPSAI Comment Period and Section
>>>>> 1.3.3
>>>>>
>>>>> Steve, myself and staff are discussing how to proceed while
>>>>> ensuring that balance is maintained.
>>>>> Thank you all for your contributions.
>>>>>
>>>>> Graeme
>>>>>> On 2015-04-30 11:02 AM, Stephanie Perrin wrote:
>>>>>> So let me get this very very clear, as i am new to the process.
>>>>>> 1. The research report you offered was sent to the list.
>>>>>> 2. It has never been part of the record.
>>>>>> 3. You wish to see it added now, April 30th, 23:58 KST.
>>>>>> 4, You are telling me I could have done the same thing.
>>>>>> 5. I have Exactly how much time to submit a minority report in order
>>>>>> to comply with the deadline of April 30th?
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Thanks for the clarifications.
>>>>>> Stephanie
>>>>>>
>>>>>>> On 2015-04-30 23:52, Kiran Malancharuvil wrote:
>>>>>>> Stephanie,
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> You had ample opportunity to prepare and present a white paper of
>>>>>>> your own.
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> It was not unsolicited, as at any time, members of the group are
>>>>>>> welcome and encouraged to present their views on the matter under
>>>>>>> discussion.
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> Are you really saying that a well researched policy position and a
>>>>>>> presentation of that research is NOT meant to be a part of the PDP
>>>>>>> process? I really do not think that it the case.
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> I know that you object to the position that the white paper
>>>>>>> explains, but unless there is a concrete prohibition on linking to
>>>>>>> it (staff?) it needs to be included, as we have every right to
>>>>>>> present the complex legal argument behind our position.
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> Kiran Malancharuvil
>>>>>>> Internet Policy Counselor
>>>>>>> MarkMonitor
>>>>>>> 415-419-9138 (m)
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> Sent from my mobile, please excuse any typos.
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> On Apr 30, 2015, at 7:45 AM, Stephanie Perrin
>>>>>>>> <stephanie.perrin at mail.utoronto.ca<mailto:stephanie.perrin at mail.utoronto.ca<mailto:stephanie.perrin at mail.utoronto.ca%3cmailto:stephanie.perrin at mail.utoronto.ca>>>
>>>>>>>> wrote:
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> With great respect to Kiran and to the law firm that compiled the
>>>>>>>> "white paper", I objected at the time and there was no indication
>>>>>>>> that we accepted the white paper in our discussions, other than to
>>>>>>>> say thanks. I would object strenuously to it being included. That
>>>>>>>> was a totally unsolicited contribution from parties wishing to
>>>>>>>> advance their case. You cannot attach that paper, without giving
>>>>>>>> those on the other side an opportunity to counter it with another
>>>>>>>> white paper. Frankly, the PDP process is not supposed to be about
>>>>>>>> dualling unsolicited white papers. IF we need to have research
>>>>>>>> done, we have to agree on what needs to be done if it is to be
>>>>>>>> attached to the official call for comments. I don't wish to be
>>>>>>>> ungracious, but the paper should not be added.
>>>>>>>> Stephanie Perrin
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> On 2015-04-30 23:34, Kiran Malancharuvil wrote:
>>>>>>>>> It is a recommendation for a policy/best practice from a portion
>>>>>>>>> of the group.
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> K
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> Kiran Malancharuvil
>>>>>>>>> Internet Policy Counselor
>>>>>>>>> MarkMonitor
>>>>>>>>> 415-419-9138 (m)
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> Sent from my mobile, please excuse any typos.
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>> On Apr 30, 2015, at 7:33 AM, James Gannon
>>>>>>>>>> <james at cyberinvasion.net<mailto:james at cyberinvasion.net<mailto:james at cyberinvasion.net%3cmailto:james at cyberinvasion.net>>>
>>>>>>>>>> wrote:
>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>> Unless we are suggesting that the whitepaper is consensus policy
>>>>>>>>>> or best practice it does not fall under that category. We are
>>>>>>>>>> presenting our policy recommendation already, which is the work
>>>>>>>>>> product of the group
>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>> -James
>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>> -----Original Message-----
>>>>>>>>>> From: Kiran Malancharuvil
>>>>>>>>>> [mailto:Kiran.Malancharuvil at markmonitor.com]
>>>>>>>>>> Sent: Thursday, April 30, 2015 3:31 PM
>>>>>>>>>> To: James Gannon
>>>>>>>>>> Cc: Mary Wong; PPSAI
>>>>>>>>>> Subject: Re: [Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg] PPSAI Comment Period and
>>>>>>>>>> Section
>>>>>>>>>> 1.3.3
>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>> Recommendations for policies, guidelines, best practices.
>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>> Kiran Malancharuvil
>>>>>>>>>> Internet Policy Counselor
>>>>>>>>>> MarkMonitor
>>>>>>>>>> 415-419-9138 (m)
>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>> Sent from my mobile, please excuse any typos.
>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> On Apr 30, 2015, at 7:29 AM, James Gannon
>>>>>>>>>>> <james at cyberinvasion.net<mailto:james at cyberinvasion.net<mailto:james at cyberinvasion.net%3cmailto:james at cyberinvasion.net>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> wrote:
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Quoting from the PDP Manual, there seems to be strong
>>>>>>>>>>> guidelines
>>>>>>>>>>> of what goes out with the Initial Report:
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>> After collection and review of information, the PDP Team and
>>>>>>>>>>>> Staff are responsible for producing an Initial Report. The
>>>>>>>>>>>> Initial Report should include the following elements:
>>>>>>>>>>>> * Compilation of Stakeholder Group and Constituency Statements
>>>>>>>>>>>> * Compilation of any statements received from any ICANN
>>>>>>>>>>>> Supporting Organization or Advisory Committee
>>>>>>>>>>>> * Recommendations for policies, guidelines, best practices or
>>>>>>>>>>>> other proposals to address the issue
>>>>>>>>>>>> * Statement of level of consensus for the recommendations
>>>>>>>>>>>> presented in the Initial Report
>>>>>>>>>>>> * Information regarding the members of the PDP Team, such as
>>>>>>>>>>>> the attendance records, Statements of Interest, etc.
>>>>>>>>>>>> * A statement on the WG discussion concerning impact of the
>>>>>>>>>>>> proposed recommendations, could consider areas such as
>>>>>>>>>>>> economic, competition, operations, privacy and other rights,
>>>>>>>>>>>> scalability and feasibility
>>>>>>>>>>> I don't see where in that framework the whitepaper would sit. I
>>>>>>>>>>> would welcome others thoughts on this.
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> -James
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> -----Original Message-----
>>>>>>>>>>> From:
>>>>>>>>>>> gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg-bounces at icann.org<mailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg-bou
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> n
>>>>>>>>>>> ces at icann.org<mailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg-bounces at icann.org%3cmailt
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> o :gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg-bounces at icann.org>>
>>>>>>>>>>> [mailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg-bounces at icann.org] On Behalf Of Kiran
>>>>>>>>>>> Malancharuvil
>>>>>>>>>>> Sent: Thursday, April 30, 2015 3:09 PM
>>>>>>>>>>> To: Mary Wong
>>>>>>>>>>> Cc: PPSAI
>>>>>>>>>>> Subject: Re: [Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg] PPSAI Comment Period and
>>>>>>>>>>> Section
>>>>>>>>>>> 1.3.3
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Mary,
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Since one side of this issue prepared a lengthy legal review to
>>>>>>>>>>> address this question, I would request that that white paper be
>>>>>>>>>>> included in the reference materials for the public comment.
>>>>>>>>>>> Since public comment is meant to "resolve" this issue,
>>>>>>>>>>> commenters need all of the information.
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> It's not just down to feasibility of self-declaration at
>>>>>>>>>>> registration (which frankly, many of us see as a cop out since
>>>>>>>>>>> it's already done in some TLDs), but also legality.
>>>>>>>>>>> Not trying to re-open the debate, but please, let's make sure
>>>>>>>>>>> the community understands the various points and the
>>>>>>>>>>> background.
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> K
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Kiran Malancharuvil
>>>>>>>>>>> Internet Policy Counselor
>>>>>>>>>>> MarkMonitor
>>>>>>>>>>> 415-419-9138 (m)
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Sent from my mobile, please excuse any typos.
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> On Apr 30, 2015, at 6:58 AM, Mary Wong
>>>>>>>>>>> <mary.wong at icann.org<mailto:mary.wong at icann.org<mailto:mary.wong at icann.org%3cmailto:mary.wong at icann.org<mailto:mary.wong at icann.org%3cmailto:mary.wong at icann.org%3cmailto:mary.wong at icann.org%3cmailto:mary.wong at icann.org>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> wrote:
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> To add to Stephanie's note that this specific issue - whether
>>>>>>>>>>> registrants of domain names actively used for commercial
>>>>>>>>>>> transactions ought to be disallowed from using P/P services -
>>>>>>>>>>> had been discussed at some length by the WG:
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Please note that this part of the Initial Report draws heavily
>>>>>>>>>>> on the detailed WG template for Charter Category C that was the
>>>>>>>>>>> basis for the WG's deliberations on this topic. That template
>>>>>>>>>>> contains lengthy descriptions of what had previously been
>>>>>>>>>>> termed
>>>>>>>>>>> the majority and minority positions on the WG's answer to this
>>>>>>>>>>> specific issue. As part of the WG's deliberations - which took
>>>>>>>>>>> place primarily between April and June 2014 - the more specific
>>>>>>>>>>> formulation of "transactional" to describe the sort of
>>>>>>>>>>> commercial (i.e. Involving financial transactions) activities
>>>>>>>>>>> that were being discussed was included in the language. All the
>>>>>>>>>>> templates and suggested formulations discussed by the WG are
>>>>>>>>>>> recorded and published on the WG wiki.
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> The WG ultimately agreed to retain the two positions in the
>>>>>>>>>>> Initial Report and to revisit the question during its review of
>>>>>>>>>>> the public comments received. As noted previously, the WG's
>>>>>>>>>>> views were presented to the community in London in June 2014
>>>>>>>>>>> and
>>>>>>>>>>> again in Los Angeles in October 2014.
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Therefore, the three questions in Section 1.3.3 of the
>>>>>>>>>>> Executive
>>>>>>>>>>> Summary only go toward soliciting community input on this
>>>>>>>>>>> single
>>>>>>>>>>> issue. They were not intended to represent a view of any "side"
>>>>>>>>>>> in the WG with regard to this matter. If the WG prefers, we can
>>>>>>>>>>> add a sentence to clarify and specify the reason for the
>>>>>>>>>>> questions in Section 1.3.3. Fundamentally, the idea is that
>>>>>>>>>>> public comments will facilitate the WG's eventual resolution of
>>>>>>>>>>> this issue as part of its preparation of the Final Report.
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> We hope this reminder of the background is of assistance.
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Cheers
>>>>>>>>>>> Mary
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Mary Wong
>>>>>>>>>>> Senior Policy Director
>>>>>>>>>>> Internet Corporation for Assigned Names & Numbers (ICANN)
>>>>>>>>>>> Telephone: +1 603 574 4892
>>>>>>>>>>> Email:
>>>>>>>>>>> mary.wong at icann.org<mailto:mary.wong at icann.org<mailto:mary.wong@
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> i
>>>>>>>>>>> cann.org%3cmailto:mary.wong at icann.org<mailto:mary.wong at icann.org
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> %
>>>>>>>>>>> 3cmailto:mary.wong at icann.org%3cmailto:mary.wong at icann.org%3cmail
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> t
>>>>>>>>>>> o:mary.wong at icann.org>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> From: Stephanie Perrin
>>>>>>>>>>> <stephanie.perrin at mail.utoronto.ca<mailto:stephanie.perrin at mail.
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> u
>>>>>>>>>>> toronto.ca<mailto:stephanie.perrin at mail.utoronto.ca%3cmailto:ste
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> p
>>>>>>>>>>> hanie.perrin at mail.utoronto.ca<mailto:stephanie.perrin at mail.utoro
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> n
>>>>>>>>>>> to.ca%3cmailto:stephanie.perrin at mail.utoronto.ca%3cmailto:stepha
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> n
>>>>>>>>>>> ie.perrin at mail.utoronto.ca%3cmailto:stephanie.perrin at mail.utoron
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> t
>>>>>>>>>>> o.ca>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Date: Thursday, April 30, 2015 at 09:20
>>>>>>>>>>> To:
>>>>>>>>>>> "gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org<mailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org><mailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org%3cmailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org%3e><mailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org%3cmailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org%3e%3cmailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org%3cmailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org%3e%3e>"
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> <gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org<mailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org<
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> m
>>>>>>>>>>> ailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org%3cmailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at ica
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> n
>>>>>>>>>>> n.org<mailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org%3cmailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> -
>>>>>>>>>>> wg at icann.org%3cmailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org%3cmailto:gnso-
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> p psai-pdp-wg at icann.org>>>>, James Gannon
>>>>>>>>>>> <james at cyberinvasion.net<mailto:james at cyberinvasion.net<mailto:j
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> a
>>>>>>>>>>> mes at cyberinvasion.net%3cmailto:james at cyberinvasion.net<mailto:ja
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> m
>>>>>>>>>>> es at cyberinvasion.net%3cmailto:james at cyberinvasion.net%3cmailto:j
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> a mes at cyberinvasion.net%3cmailto:james at cyberinvasion.net>>>>,
>>>>>>>>>>> Michele Blacknight
>>>>>>>>>>> <michele at blacknight.com<mailto:michele at blacknight.com<mailto:mic
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> h
>>>>>>>>>>> ele at blacknight.com%3cmailto:michele at blacknight.com<mailto:michel
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> e
>>>>>>>>>>> @blacknight.com%3cmailto:michele at blacknight.com%3cmailto:michele
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> @ blacknight.com%3cmailto:michele at blacknight.com>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Subject: Re: [Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg] PPSAI Comment Period and
>>>>>>>>>>> Section
>>>>>>>>>>> 1.3.3
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> James, prior to you joining the group, we had discussed this at
>>>>>>>>>>> some length. IN fact, I really thought that the many reasons
>>>>>>>>>>> why
>>>>>>>>>>> sorting out the purpose of a registration is problematic had
>>>>>>>>>>> buried this debate, but apparently not. Some of the issues
>>>>>>>>>>> raised, according to my recollection were the following:
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> * names are registered prior to decisions about content
>>>>>>>>>>> * content changes over time
>>>>>>>>>>> * most countries regulate e-commerce in some fashion, so that
>>>>>>>>>>> website commercial activity does not have to be regulated by
>>>>>>>>>>> ICANN
>>>>>>>>>>> * ICANN should not be in the business of regulating content in
>>>>>>>>>>> the first place (and sorting out who is extracting a material
>>>>>>>>>>> consideration from a website in order to deny them the ability
>>>>>>>>>>> to use a proxy registration is certainly a form of regulation)
>>>>>>>>>>> * definitions of commercial activity vary widely around the
>>>>>>>>>>> world
>>>>>>>>>>> * bad actors will not declare, registrars cannot police this
>>>>>>>>>>> matter
>>>>>>>>>>> * criminal prosecution is not dependent on WHOIS information
>>>>>>>>>>> * if this is really about the ability to detect market
>>>>>>>>>>> information, ICANN should not be in the business of making
>>>>>>>>>>> registrant information available for market purposes, it
>>>>>>>>>>> does it
>>>>>>>>>>> for security and stability.
>>>>>>>>>>> * contactability remains, regardless of which registrant info
>>>>>>>>>>> appears in WHOIS
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> I am planning to reformulate these into questions to match the
>>>>>>>>>>> questions on the other side, suggestions welcome.
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Stephanie Perrin
>>>>>>>>>>> On 2015-04-30 16:24, James Gannon wrote:
>>>>>>>>>>> I don't see this as asking providers to enforce anything
>>>>>>>>>>> similar
>>>>>>>>>>> to other questions when registering a domain, it's a
>>>>>>>>>>> self-reported assessment. All it does is add an additional
>>>>>>>>>>> branch to the decision tree for eligibility, which will already
>>>>>>>>>>> be there to determine eligibility due to the other reasons
>>>>>>>>>>> listed below.
>>>>>>>>>>> The registrant is asked will you be processing financial
>>>>>>>>>>> transactions.
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> * Yes-->Will you be using a 3rd party>No>Not eligible for P/P.
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> * Yes-->Will you be using a 3rd party>Yes>Eligible for P/P.
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> I'm not asking registrars to enforce law but to see if a more
>>>>>>>>>>> finely grained eligibility process can be enacted. Or at least
>>>>>>>>>>> is there is public support for more granularity.
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> -James
>>>>>>>>>>> From: Michele Neylon - Blacknight
>>>>>>>>>>> [mailto:michele at blacknight.com]
>>>>>>>>>>> Sent: Thursday, April 30, 2015 8:17 AM
>>>>>>>>>>> To: James Gannon; Graeme Bunton; PPSAI
>>>>>>>>>>> Subject: Re: [Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg] PPSAI Comment Period and
>>>>>>>>>>> Section
>>>>>>>>>>> 1.3.3
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> James
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> As a registrar or PP service provider how am I meant to
>>>>>>>>>>> assess this?
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> It doesn't scale
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Seriously.
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> If, for example, there is an Irish operated website that is not
>>>>>>>>>>> complying with Irish law then it would be up to the ODCE
>>>>>>>>>>> (http://www.odce.ie/<https://protect-us.mimecast.com/r/IqfLPS2xh
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> m
>>>>>>>>>>> x-5GDCPCM4mLmlw-jOPQHGmhpzAjWDKActStEmX7ndjfqnEIgUMkdhXCAGe_aALV
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> o
>>>>>>>>>>> 69T0irIiCOftGW0RRkFeeJXP_SQ_bxxN5c9ZWrJzjnfSpDUeI4UjuT2dsrtgXox-
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> J
>>>>>>>>>>> siUyGsBvbDhSHcf2gH3gqSI2YwvUnORJuOhanPP2uCSQp3bey2BqQKbirhovyP6h
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> D
>>>>>>>>>>> iunUi2Ilg><https://protect-us.mimecast.com/r/IqfLPS2xhmx-5GDCPCM
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> iunUi2Ilg>4
>>>>>>>>>>> mLmlw-jOPQHGmhpzAjWDKActStEmX7ndjfqnEIgUMkdhXCAGe_aALVo69T0irIiC
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> O
>>>>>>>>>>> ftGW0RRkFeeJXP_SQ_bxxN5c9ZWrJzjnfSpDUeI4UjuT2dsrtgXox-JsiUyGsBvb
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> D
>>>>>>>>>>> hSHcf2gH3gqSI2YwvUnORJuOhanPP2uCSQp3bey2BqQKbirhovyP6hDiunUi2Ilg
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> <
>>>>>>>>>>> https://protect-us.mimecast.com/r/4lNzdG4V_LBmiovLA6p9BZsfLgWW8I
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Z
>>>>>>>>>>> SZ8mzFYFSEGMRVcYO2zG2wkLeacYjtsSRf_sSF--BDXNIv1JkaSjK7YDkV7Wh91A
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> M
>>>>>>>>>>> XWzAHM8Zc7w5foIbeKPzTB9Jb3n8Rk3oYWdB4A_Jt2ltxZR7APcRWG0IyDnycx5V
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> o
>>>>>>>>>>> J08erpju3GxLxy1dILiNWX72a25S9Yyrm1Fh6eWqHxtrhsqZmkrRym4-JZgjGuT2
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 5
>>>>>>>>>>> ptP-Tf0ChXEp9Oy2VafY---UlWYnIhutuM8Qeql3uCVIJEvhilzgK06gmUWfWZUI
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 4
>>>>>>>>>>> 09JAcmXc-w5egvrI21Srqo5zbQdnsPIl2yRBRiJy4YZ-h-c7WM_Y0EMYghq1BrKe
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> M
>>>>>>>>>>> dTU94YwRb9V0rLPfV6BN36pbf5NyooXX3sVlMzjnI4nh6u0IpcQrhd1oL7F3QAsO
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 8
>>>>>>>>>>> MVGCWywmASjHPWQatBHt4UH0ihcq6sfPIxUCQHG8ffuWeD1uJ8KMuVubzQxqF8Kn
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> v
>>>>>>>>>>> hpmA_Th65ShbIpsv0BqAqVZ9ZNvoP627Jn5avKDQthQYCUxg>>) to enforce
>>>>>>>>>>> whatever needs enforcing, as it would be up to the DPA to
>>>>>>>>>>> enforce any issues around data privacy etc., etc.,
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Attempting to force registrars and PP providers to make these
>>>>>>>>>>> kind of evaluations is not going to work.
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Issues like PCI-DSS compliance are matters that should be dealt
>>>>>>>>>>> with by the DPA and the banks.
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Forcing registrars and PP providers to start getting
>>>>>>>>>>> involved in
>>>>>>>>>>> that kind of assessment isn't viable
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Regards
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Michele
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> --
>>>>>>>>>>> Mr Michele Neylon
>>>>>>>>>>> Blacknight Solutions
>>>>>>>>>>> Hosting, Colocation & Domains
>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.blacknight.host/<https://protect-us.mimecast.com/r/r0
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Q
>>>>>>>>>>> iXaZk72F7OmWKc9_pO3HAiIAvI3h06-RcgETJh-J4kMLvQtMGZn5lKnoQO8ikZnQ
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> i
>>>>>>>>>>> TNL6FLbYD67s4dF-tWj2IbgtPVbZIrmLhFiT8cZvRoXUKLem6cyG8n3JE6-tis8t
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> E
>>>>>>>>>>> kBPwKkOuqFU7azbPzFSZPBE0XjNt1o6W5MAy5yWOEr-3QLGcTYMC5oDDDwuftYuz
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 9
>>>>>>>>>>> pHDOyvEieReE36N1UxTeWXBI__3g1_xmHN4S0><https://protect-us.mimeca
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> s
>>>>>>>>>>> t.com/r/r0QiXaZk72F7OmWKc9_pO3HAiIAvI3h06-RcgETJh-J4kMLvQtMGZn5l
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> K
>>>>>>>>>>> noQO8ikZnQiTNL6FLbYD67s4dF-tWj2IbgtPVbZIrmLhFiT8cZvRoXUKLem6cyG8
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> n
>>>>>>>>>>> 3JE6-tis8tEkBPwKkOuqFU7azbPzFSZPBE0XjNt1o6W5MAy5yWOEr-3QLGcTYMC5
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> o
>>>>>>>>>>> DDDwuftYuz9pHDOyvEieReE36N1UxTeWXBI__3g1_xmHN4S0<https://protect
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> -
>>>>>>>>>>> us.mimecast.com/r/l1oPubFTSPL9jkLJYE-i_s_cVzwLdAYnEJLnyze4qcofGb
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> V
>>>>>>>>>>> p0De8ZHa2UK3gf0UhGuOGUKJQPGBL8lrGKGKjds5fxrj5NlbVvg9BxM3Opb82UmP
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> C
>>>>>>>>>>> znna5WJ9PwzhPNi5xrpUMWyCGaWGfCaocAES27yfoPTWBDpFvCjuT5lto5W4Svdm
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> L
>>>>>>>>>>> IEzA858Pp4koY144mx4sCSiYqVF1oSQjBUoaxLy4o0qUijmXox-r3SZwQHhehoe2
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 5
>>>>>>>>>>> fdF04TqxWWiSTMxwITNDqt5fEHRfaCHadDi3x8h2yaBwI4D9yYpnjwhcylZi_w_t
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> U
>>>>>>>>>>> 7osnBvi4lhetcT-sBjy_UxmIawTToN10n7w-_l-0AzyR-eFJd-kg218qDM3-LAJN
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> n
>>>>>>>>>>> PlGoBQ7sXSeedCLC_8MZKx2jkESGtfItjyfLdRPa4i03KBw0P7yCMwqaaG83u4Jp
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> w
>>>>>>>>>>> uR-pJjmqEhj_IYYcrKA-B6fCjuTzUuEUnmzG5IvmmhU4_FC5JETN9UcdPuTdmsRn
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 4
>>>>>>>>>>> IgbqDMivZgyLKNiyUi2PbzBwz2O4AmjzBgrFeG-75fubDeaQQBFnSdlGYaje4umI
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> N
>>>>>>>>>>> -mXeQ2jP1>>
>>>>>>>>>>> http://blog.blacknight.com/<https://protect-us.mimecast.com/r/wl
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 1
>>>>>>>>>>> MfvJ8aWTxnqz6FCsjG4QE5Lt8k3OKgMWheA8wVhCgpAj6NRi9Y8zMxa9MvTN2vhD
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> -
>>>>>>>>>>> EWNpvAhObo3t9Jl-Kh7ki557bXwOMPGhz-Up4X8e1Q8UR-DF0d4jYhrGpb0LrotD
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 5
>>>>>>>>>>> 0UduC3QQRYUJ24nEnbyayh-GPs3hk77LhEpDwYrSf4v_RqmohacWFuO-pMc6Ap8I
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 9
>>>>>>>>>>> JulleUf0h9FbW-MHMc1xlq8F7WXPVnekaa_Tg><https://protect-us.mimeca
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> s
>>>>>>>>>>> t.com/r/wl1MfvJ8aWTxnqz6FCsjG4QE5Lt8k3OKgMWheA8wVhCgpAj6NRi9Y8zM
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> x
>>>>>>>>>>> a9MvTN2vhD-EWNpvAhObo3t9Jl-Kh7ki557bXwOMPGhz-Up4X8e1Q8UR-DF0d4jY
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> h
>>>>>>>>>>> rGpb0LrotD50UduC3QQRYUJ24nEnbyayh-GPs3hk77LhEpDwYrSf4v_RqmohacWF
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> u
>>>>>>>>>>> O-pMc6Ap8I9JulleUf0h9FbW-MHMc1xlq8F7WXPVnekaa_Tg<https://protect
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> -
>>>>>>>>>>> us.mimecast.com/r/4W4r20DAZy2h6dpYp2Tzq7FTSQAmTYs1vfAQIkdyfvJMDu
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 0
>>>>>>>>>>> tcKmiKOwsAOTvBSlLTi59FHgM_on9QsvD9CudMpRih0I6gjXq2A4dY6O3q-el3Lc
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> y
>>>>>>>>>>> PasQf5tNiiIjFSoLe4-RGWuQcN2f9jXygxx1wp1E3sv8txhcCC1UoD9h6Kzi2vgT
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 9
>>>>>>>>>>> SkXvpFHliyZIF2T31a9K0Lwnl55R94GruRYOcDjbX7Gf_cm6XnmW7UXZuI--pr5K
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> L
>>>>>>>>>>> NxaqYBbS75-hjmGoQi0uOfRwccxXRwvyYLDmdbReZa5H9CpX_Ci4xt8r9IL23kJl
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> I
>>>>>>>>>>> OZSvO7l-a0YReANZnxal2lCMTQxwhNiLimdPtU5VOy2Ioa22r1qJ3jY-4L6N9nCH
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 8
>>>>>>>>>>> stI-uLtVpkYUPc3RvOiu_yOfgfI1l70U4w-qK81Jaixy9HpNT1Ux06f6VAWKbEky
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> S
>>>>>>>>>>> x61Yb-Y6D7Eu4QgIjDhJlsJsub-Psbz12zynvHmip6LmH0FyLQpmZ8NhSxHFxm3Y
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> U
>>>>>>>>>>> X03mPL3m6Jw4wsHiFDp8mOLyq83OvhEiG8-KJrVmORyqJbvdaAGpN_hwtrXjLL30
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> r
>>>>>>>>>>> Kl_G8yzmQ>>
>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.blacknight.press<https://protect-us.mimecast.com/r/-M
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> R
>>>>>>>>>>> GGedz53TF8UWq3rKo8GI39ai_ismqN0UYggzFnhsCzIT83jwX24BSxN_VMtJYpUg
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> k
>>>>>>>>>>> SGF-Qst71LuBVQLY87bs-vewJiEDX8p5ABHKofJc69pmthPRFaowH9cz7b4wBdr4
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 5
>>>>>>>>>>> nD9yW3n5wmmAGAorNORPO2oD8fx1b7Ch4UucRtocG7TVoD8q8xePkXjqmELFjL3p
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> o
>>>>>>>>>>> was7Q8SOSYQE947lLpZzCcGrOwqu7wogrVuvk><https://protect-us.mimeca
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> was7Q8SOSYQE947lLpZzCcGrOwqu7wogrVuvk>s
>>>>>>>>>>> t.com/r/-MRGGedz53TF8UWq3rKo8GI39ai_ismqN0UYggzFnhsCzIT83jwX24BS
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> x
>>>>>>>>>>> N_VMtJYpUgkSGF-Qst71LuBVQLY87bs-vewJiEDX8p5ABHKofJc69pmthPRFaowH
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 9
>>>>>>>>>>> cz7b4wBdr45nD9yW3n5wmmAGAorNORPO2oD8fx1b7Ch4UucRtocG7TVoD8q8xePk
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> X
>>>>>>>>>>> jqmELFjL3powas7Q8SOSYQE947lLpZzCcGrOwqu7wogrVuvk<https://protect
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> -
>>>>>>>>>>> us.mimecast.com/r/zPN5CjAJdRJWk2B85RfU9bzzLTFtJr4NLfR-96KjMGyFiG
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> k
>>>>>>>>>>> nSAd74cCJ9GvA9kaD-vS8gui8v0NBYOirWVK2xaxEySYrhl2eJjehgZhqe6EM2RO
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> p
>>>>>>>>>>> f-ga40yWnn5xy-c-63NhmIm1zcBNoKTSYjeNP-JoK3ZTuo9fcXf-gjUC0geZ0i9l
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> A
>>>>>>>>>>> qAcPsy8IEGy_8nCJaqJ0jLbzqGABaam2zacCALcPGMdo7ZbSmL1Gxs2K3bztp9EW
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> X
>>>>>>>>>>> ROi2v6xvmD3GvF30-zcbF_W2yoR57XnsOemzhLSFe1TvxKwMC7qpk2ZcuWiNHdc6
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> I
>>>>>>>>>>> pLVyFrtCoJSOyZmRX5XwWUrqwrs3DfQJOrN3MfKD1mb52hx-puFq3DmM-8xYWTvo
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> y
>>>>>>>>>>> idluw_-iyz10fHE4jnJ8a0bNMzEjJsQlG80jFpqfalyc8sayVT7t6qzyZudj7E8-
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 6
>>>>>>>>>>> 7SeBCUbqzsbck6ckMrMqVZlZpG7MELOH-otpZvr-Y8ELA8omOG7Jx60KL9ssVcKQ
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> n
>>>>>>>>>>> EEIJ2zoKuO-w1CvJ6aO838upI02RQnBFQHaWAg2HIAC4FUg-N8MfLY-WEjSnVXkh
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> m i5PF3oy_h>> - get our latest news & media coverage
>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.technology.ie<https://protect-us.mimecast.com/r/suwZN
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> I
>>>>>>>>>>> iJfrdSpqE4iC56mMY3x3S91aHmdyA2bCRS-Fmr9Q1_uNxFISl4UXNQGJAa4ABDSo
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> M
>>>>>>>>>>> KKJoH4LBI6dPDpw1IcPIW2UD6KmY-khZffkUgGyGTLPU0VW-nWld8z7P0H2Ru_lA
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 2
>>>>>>>>>>> gyfCIuoaN7WmFU6IRQ9AVVBKNMpsRsxQkxp27qp4b1vr0Nu7xAxlXjinmqCYcWDy
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> v
>>>>>>>>>>> 6BlIGk1JID86YB5QMhEW98wyZ5sollRXTc><https://protect-us.mimecast.
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 6BlIGk1JID86YB5QMhEW98wyZ5sollRXTc>c
>>>>>>>>>>> om/r/suwZNIiJfrdSpqE4iC56mMY3x3S91aHmdyA2bCRS-Fmr9Q1_uNxFISl4UXN
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Q
>>>>>>>>>>> GJAa4ABDSoMKKJoH4LBI6dPDpw1IcPIW2UD6KmY-khZffkUgGyGTLPU0VW-nWld8
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> z
>>>>>>>>>>> 7P0H2Ru_lA2gyfCIuoaN7WmFU6IRQ9AVVBKNMpsRsxQkxp27qp4b1vr0Nu7xAxlX
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> j
>>>>>>>>>>> inmqCYcWDyv6BlIGk1JID86YB5QMhEW98wyZ5sollRXTc<https://protect-us.
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> mimecast.com/r/CUWs47OhCB2aa9RLj9Ftm3OqyHdbegkLXSOpMV8uBRbvwT8Hs
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> S
>>>>>>>>>>> uNUBKuLqaFsB7wEKsfGHvZUVWYE-BMah9Ne8IWBG2s_bX5r7b_TJL__FuNOKKGwG
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> L
>>>>>>>>>>> -8U1r4vABiKSmYEwflrHGjQyceV-8DAd_fT1NCFaQJTyaRS0syYAweeUF8-iRaju
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> c
>>>>>>>>>>> VR2j2TBJBJdWPqQfVlJc9USo93NJROMUjbZ19wmQiF9AfNy9_OPxB3m0aLhvE0ZO
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 4
>>>>>>>>>>> ciBDl5x4cBlLzPLm1Yjva9JRou5CLrxVpqUAX1aaGCqGi1UqaZErXONEpv4r0LDd
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> v
>>>>>>>>>>> Xud_hwOHoD4gjKskjzkZoSqfXgfWeHDLtWlGygCxcKp2Gltk1vfrZVDQysBdb1iu
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> p
>>>>>>>>>>> hpR7R8ptrBwXr-qekyrlGwPnvmJ4b1zktVIjl3VTNZEtfoSxFdDJDyRnwRQo7gPw
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> r
>>>>>>>>>>> ON4tVFHPQQ6X3uw4CiOWAlwb2sGkEUkOj3bucsbxHpwc3Pq6O5ujbwB9uw08FQv2
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> _
>>>>>>>>>>> 5n3Cu_tw7LpdTxd1QMI8rfIRMqiFuB5vdiI-2hipGCXEpIXSbnB_h4aee2mjP129
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> n
>>>>>>>>>>> m7QevJ>> Intl. +353 (0) 59 9183072 Direct Dial: +353 (0)59
>>>>>>>>>>> 9183090
>>>>>>>>>>> Social:
>>>>>>>>>>> http://mneylon.social<https://protect-us.mimecast.com/r/c9ciyb99
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> C
>>>>>>>>>>> MvSHLw2MJX2WYjWAGojFAv6abNbJNSbdh-ZFyKYiMOesCOSW0IbP_Hk74wcQMPR4
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> L
>>>>>>>>>>> FdtPIo3qwpdVxkGjxnPEF73YlWOioKWfm0ASY6v7enF3zKmqddqH2G4dXIbPg_PV
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> q
>>>>>>>>>>> GwzzZzhWQxKSK2MKPyc4QXazyYJjS7H_X2JdIq2B8eAZeCDmgPBWH09Ix-VujUi5
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> p
>>>>>>>>>>> HJeE_GXWIlFrE4TTH0hP08WIPWYQvhY><https://protect-us.mimecast.com
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> /
>>>>>>>>>>> r/c9ciyb99CMvSHLw2MJX2WYjWAGojFAv6abNbJNSbdh-ZFyKYiMOesCOSW0IbP_
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> H
>>>>>>>>>>> k74wcQMPR4LFdtPIo3qwpdVxkGjxnPEF73YlWOioKWfm0ASY6v7enF3zKmqddqH2
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> G
>>>>>>>>>>> 4dXIbPg_PVqGwzzZzhWQxKSK2MKPyc4QXazyYJjS7H_X2JdIq2B8eAZeCDmgPBWH
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 0
>>>>>>>>>>> 9Ix-VujUi5pHJeE_GXWIlFrE4TTH0hP08WIPWYQvhY<https://protect-us.mi
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> m
>>>>>>>>>>> ecast.com/r/0oGY1mVf_smwKlCBVH2VOnpfmhsH1QKCI9PoPtiLiBYOkQKP5WYN
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> b
>>>>>>>>>>> 14N4SlMX7ATkUU7bDnJB3KdSXOHn_F7Li19YrJbT2HfbkvMlX4QZXNtM-djZW8By
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> m
>>>>>>>>>>> hcAivn1_ZLP2AfKbDLzRQmtzWdiif_JIJZ9hvfSwiUATjMrCjPDQ9T9eDIhS6VIc
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 7
>>>>>>>>>>> PQoyGuTTPlSDtMYVcWwoJ07XRHLWmFbQ8FODMPVY-EM3fEmYldXDJy7Ny6i2n6RQ
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> P
>>>>>>>>>>> 7Q6zU3B4jHg7VefC-bqS3GASQocWI-UUSAFU53eZEcCWcFa4-H1mi2LgFvtmsddI
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> S
>>>>>>>>>>> 1K73ev9yE13XK_mNgM6r1AUH6sEzkQXKc_gSb71qAt70xEUBTorPTxPkG0FEkZBb
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> -
>>>>>>>>>>> 6XlspCaqcxR4-6PzMMotyuWLBhZ15PH09fH4arj25zvTD6O-4WXLfkfHH8Iq7NAO
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> U
>>>>>>>>>>> GOV8ifAdQt74uWvJWU8Kja_RDjE7Z9NhMhCAAQmWozknnPPWSRPnwheQYRgPrmVI
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 0
>>>>>>>>>>> ZQt79ZlVbwiH7IioW4efxkCaQU3TOhOd_YjWWljTbAVTBWhbXPGl1CnbR12PBoP0
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> M
>>>>>>>>>>> ZMr>>
>>>>>>>>>>> -------------------------------
>>>>>>>>>>> Blacknight Internet Solutions Ltd, Unit 12A,Barrowside Business
>>>>>>>>>>> Park,Sleaty Road,Graiguecullen,Carlow,Ireland Company No.:
>>>>>>>>>>> 370845
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> From: James Gannon
>>>>>>>>>>> Date: Thursday 30 April 2015 07:45
>>>>>>>>>>> To: Graeme Bunton,
>>>>>>>>>>> "gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org<mailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org><mailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org%3cmailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org%3e><mailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org%3cmailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org%3e%3cmailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org%3cmailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org%3e%3e>"
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Subject: Re: [Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg] PPSAI Comment Period and
>>>>>>>>>>> Section
>>>>>>>>>>> 1.3.3
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> I would personally like to see if there is public traction for
>>>>>>>>>>> distinguishing between sites directly processing financial
>>>>>>>>>>> truncations and sites who use 3rd parties for processing
>>>>>>>>>>> financial transactions as this is a very important distinction.
>>>>>>>>>>> A simple and I hope non-controversial additional question to
>>>>>>>>>>> the
>>>>>>>>>>> ones below:
>>>>>>>>>>> If so, should domains which use a third party to process
>>>>>>>>>>> financial transactions (i.e Paypal, Stripe), and thus do not
>>>>>>>>>>> directly process financial information, be subject to the same
>>>>>>>>>>> restrictions?
>>>>>>>>>>> There are strong existing distinctions both in national laws
>>>>>>>>>>> and
>>>>>>>>>>> in regulations such as PCI-DSS between these two forms.
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> -James Gannon
>>>>>>>>>>> From:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg-bounces at icann.org<mailto:ppsai-pdp-wg-bou
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> n
>>>>>>>>>>> ces at icann.org><mailto:ppsai-pdp-wg-bounces at icann.org><mailto:gns
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> o -ppsai-pdp-wg-bounces at icann.org>
>>>>>>>>>>> [mailto:gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg-bounces at icann.org] On Behalf Of
>>>>>>>>>>> Graeme
>>>>>>>>>>> Bunton
>>>>>>>>>>> Sent: Tuesday, April 28, 2015 10:17 PM
>>>>>>>>>>> To: PPSAI
>>>>>>>>>>> Subject: [Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg] PPSAI Comment Period and Section
>>>>>>>>>>> 1.3.3
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Thanks to all WG members for a very productive call earlier
>>>>>>>>>>> today(and to Steve for his chairing acumen). The co-chairs and
>>>>>>>>>>> staff met this afternoon to tie down two loose ends from the
>>>>>>>>>>> call.
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Regarding the deadline for public comments on the Initial
>>>>>>>>>>> Report, we recognize there is considerable support for
>>>>>>>>>>> extending
>>>>>>>>>>> the public comment period to 60 days instead of the standard 40
>>>>>>>>>>> days on which we have all been planning. We are prepared to
>>>>>>>>>>> agree to this, but with the caveat that this will have
>>>>>>>>>>> repercussions on the pace and intensity of our work once public
>>>>>>>>>>> comments have been received. Specifically, if the public
>>>>>>>>>>> comment
>>>>>>>>>>> deadline is extended until July 3 (60 days after our
>>>>>>>>>>> publication
>>>>>>>>>>> date of May 4), we will need to plan on at least weekly calls
>>>>>>>>>>> throughout July and August, some of which may need to be more
>>>>>>>>>>> than an hour in length, to review these comments and move
>>>>>>>>>>> toward a Final Report.
>>>>>>>>>>> Otherwise, we jeopardize the prospects for getting the Final
>>>>>>>>>>> Report in front of the GNSO council no later than the Dublin
>>>>>>>>>>> ICANN meeting. As was noted on the call today, many additional
>>>>>>>>>>> steps need to take place even after this WG issues its Final
>>>>>>>>>>> Report before any new accreditati
>>>>>> on
>>>>>>>>> system can be implemented, so the time pressure imposed by the
>>>>>>>>> expiration of the Interim Specification at the end of next
>>>>>>>>> year is
>>>>>>>>> already real.
>>>>>>>>>>> Also, as previously announced over the past few weeks, if
>>>>>>>>>>> any WG
>>>>>>>>>>> members (or group of members) wish to submit a brief
>>>>>>>>>>> separate or
>>>>>>>>>>> additional statement for inclusion in the package posted for
>>>>>>>>>>> public comment next Monday, such statements need to be received
>>>>>>>>>>> by staff no later than Thursday, April 30.
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Lastly, the other loose end involves proposed revisions to
>>>>>>>>>>> section 1.3.3 of the Initial Report, which were presented on
>>>>>>>>>>> the
>>>>>>>>>>> call earlier today but which we did not have time to discuss
>>>>>>>>>>> fully. We agree that this section could benefit from some
>>>>>>>>>>> revision, but believe it should take the form of greater
>>>>>>>>>>> concision, not additional presentation of arguments for the
>>>>>>>>>>> divergent positions. Thus we suggest that section 1.3.3 be
>>>>>>>>>>> revised to read as follows:
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> ---
>>>>>>>>>>> Although the WG agreed that the mere fact that a domain name is
>>>>>>>>>>> registered by a commercial entity or by anyone conducting
>>>>>>>>>>> commercial activity should not preclude the use of P/P services
>>>>>>>>>>> , there was disagreement over whether domain names that are
>>>>>>>>>>> actively used for commercial transactions (e.g. the sale or
>>>>>>>>>>> exchange of goods or services) should be prohibited from using
>>>>>>>>>>> P/P services. While most WG members did not believe such a
>>>>>>>>>>> prohibition is necessary or practical, some members believed
>>>>>>>>>>> that registrants of such domain names should not be able to use
>>>>>>>>>>> or continue using proxy or privacy services.
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> For those that argued that it is necessary and practical to
>>>>>>>>>>> limit access to P/P services to exclude commercial entities,
>>>>>>>>>>> the
>>>>>>>>>>> following text was proposed to clarify and define their
>>>>>>>>>>> position:
>>>>>>>>>>> "domains used for online financial transactions for commercial
>>>>>>>>>>> purpose should be ineligible for privacy and proxy
>>>>>>>>>>> registrations."
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Public comment is therefore specifically invited on the
>>>>>>>>>>> following
>>>>>>>>>>> questions:
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> * Should registrants of domain names associated with commercial
>>>>>>>>>>> activities and which are used for online financial transactions
>>>>>>>>>>> be prohibited from using, or continuing to use, privacy and
>>>>>>>>>>> proxy services?
>>>>>>>>>>> * If so, will it be useful to adopt a definition of
>>>>>>>>>>> "commercial"
>>>>>>>>>>> or "transactional" to define those domains for which P/P
>>>>>>>>>>> service
>>>>>>>>>>> registrations should be disallowed? And if so, what should the
>>>>>>>>>>> definition(s) be?"
>>>>>>>>>>> * Will it be necessary to make a distinction in the WHOIS data
>>>>>>>>>>> fields to be displayed as a result?
>>>>>>>>>>> ---
>>>>>>>>>>> Thanks,
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Graeme Bunton & Steve Metalitz
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> --
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> _________________________
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Graeme Bunton
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Manager, Management Information Systems
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Manager, Public Policy
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> Tucows Inc.
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> PH: 416 535 0123 ext 1634
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>>>>>>>>> Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg mailing list
>>>>>>>>>>> Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org<mailto:Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org><
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> m
>>>>>>>>>>> ailto:Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org><mailto:Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at ican
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> n
>>>>>>>>>>> .org>https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg<htt
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> p
>>>>>>>>>>> s://protect-us.mimecast.com/r/w4cOGJpN8aqiFBeZDDCfM61L9zSPPQ8yJT
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> O
>>>>>>>>>>> suokgr0uUoFWQcH4C1vKnhAJR8I5CDUGd3f75FQZ0RrGQoOiumi5fkuGEeAdPoDj
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> A
>>>>>>>>>>> 3DGFVt5fCde0OuGcKsc4syb-86Vd3ZsMEWNubiso-WCMGJKqofC67xfNJVO1oqFP
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> A
>>>>>>>>>>> mL7abae98k88hH_BDY04YcHIhprEG-vGcToOzkceYzCw4sYw77Sj8DHh1iwNuJPK
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> a
>>>>>>>>>>> gRVm5XkaPrKRnvsIqURxFUU964UWsThNMfSE_TxYg9ZhC-Fg><https://protec
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> t
>>>>>>>>>>> -us.mimecast.com/r/w4cOGJpN8aqiFBeZDDCfM61L9zSPPQ8yJTOsuokgr0uUo
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> F
>>>>>>>>>>> WQcH4C1vKnhAJR8I5CDUGd3f75FQZ0RrGQoOiumi5fkuGEeAdPoDjA3DGFVt5fCd
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> e
>>>>>>>>>>> 0OuGcKsc4syb-86Vd3ZsMEWNubiso-WCMGJKqofC67xfNJVO1oqFPAmL7abae98k
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 8
>>>>>>>>>>> 8hH_BDY04YcHIhprEG-vGcToOzkceYzCw4sYw77Sj8DHh1iwNuJPKagRVm5XkaPr
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> K
>>>>>>>>>>> RnvsIqURxFUU964UWsThNMfSE_TxYg9ZhC-Fg<https://protect-us.mimecas
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> t
>>>>>>>>>>> .com/r/NkE1wHjmuxt3o9SjDC8u3UaEBOfWC2mFXjFJa1_yo4CBlxqC8_PtvDo7W
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> f
>>>>>>>>>>> WJYT_YaNpXYz45ijCcYjA7oYYpLl0toLP6bJpkzDTK3R9OrjFh5nT4QkOopUtxiq
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> u
>>>>>>>>>>> bExt6q7UZTuNoom_4ejyw2wpm9vymemagb7YNIBY9WQ1ySPRTD0g1HGkyw6BJZrB
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> T
>>>>>>>>>>> Q5bn3eb3Z2m63UxQvS6jFuhrBwNCteGQ-aziLTklBEQieWlioi2gYnClBNYrEHFg
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> v
>>>>>>>>>>> WWSEvgar2P-tWJHPPeIwuO1U_utMPhVBW-kuhn8kQ2mtOv5v6KvIjRrN8bV1DSkP
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> e
>>>>>>>>>>> uNGC4pfFkeDmG__ztmWkRIOq5sGpyoEOJHeydqHXpPURbDoGJH4X1-XBOw9xyUQU
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> H
>>>>>>>>>>> 2FxUzKjIYwzIsoWRAH-mtaFpnV-yPYzPFOpLczOu5V0S3wAh77gKBYS0Ims0rAmT
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> m
>>>>>>>>>>> 4RALGvo_wlPWZLAZZxcznxiU05FXCxycKWSOlLj6vi9pO9hzfr_77ovw17c-o3KH
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> H
>>>>>>>>>>> uMnCKx-PLdlg8F4Dlr-11-NMFS960KQ6y3mrSOt4DP_WEt8kbLW7HnKwQyhHZgE7
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> -
>>>>>>>>>>> jC7-oKZvPXlL_lzz0NbUCv9P-sLtO35WLCQIeslyoVS7lZahikA8xuNn1grSIZ>>
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>>>>>>>>> Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg mailing list
>>>>>>>>>>> Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org<mailto:Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org<m
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> a
>>>>>>>>>>> ilto:Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org%3cmailto:Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at ican
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> n
>>>>>>>>>>> .org<mailto:Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org%3cmailto:Gnso-ppsai-pdp-
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> w
>>>>>>>>>>> g at icann.org%3cmailto:Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org%3cmailto:Gnso-p
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> p
>>>>>>>>>>> sai-pdp-wg at icann.org>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg<https://
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> p
>>>>>>>>>>> rotect-us.mimecast.com/r/w4cOGJpN8aqiFBeZDDCfM61L9zSPPQ8yJTOsuok
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> g
>>>>>>>>>>> r0uUoFWQcH4C1vKnhAJR8I5CDUGd3f75FQZ0RrGQoOiumi5fkuGEeAdPoDjA3DGF
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> V
>>>>>>>>>>> t5fCde0OuGcKsc4syb-86Vd3ZsMEWNubiso-WCMGJKqofC67xfNJVO1oqFPAmL7a
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> b
>>>>>>>>>>> ae98k88hH_BDY04YcHIhprEG-vGcToOzkceYzCw4sYw77Sj8DHh1iwNuJPKagRVm
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 5
>>>>>>>>>>> XkaPrKRnvsIqURxFUU964UWsThNMfSE_TxYg9ZhC-Fg><https://protect-us.
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> m
>>>>>>>>>>> imecast.com/r/w4cOGJpN8aqiFBeZDDCfM61L9zSPPQ8yJTOsuokgr0uUoFWQcH
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 4
>>>>>>>>>>> C1vKnhAJR8I5CDUGd3f75FQZ0RrGQoOiumi5fkuGEeAdPoDjA3DGFVt5fCde0OuG
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> c
>>>>>>>>>>> Ksc4syb-86Vd3ZsMEWNubiso-WCMGJKqofC67xfNJVO1oqFPAmL7abae98k88hH_
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> B
>>>>>>>>>>> DY04YcHIhprEG-vGcToOzkceYzCw4sYw77Sj8DHh1iwNuJPKagRVm5XkaPrKRnvs
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> I
>>>>>>>>>>> qURxFUU964UWsThNMfSE_TxYg9ZhC-Fg<https://protect-us.mimecast.com
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> /
>>>>>>>>>>> r/NkE1wHjmuxt3o9SjDC8u3UaEBOfWC2mFXjFJa1_yo4CBlxqC8_PtvDo7WfWJYT
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> _
>>>>>>>>>>> YaNpXYz45ijCcYjA7oYYpLl0toLP6bJpkzDTK3R9OrjFh5nT4QkOopUtxiqubExt
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 6
>>>>>>>>>>> q7UZTuNoom_4ejyw2wpm9vymemagb7YNIBY9WQ1ySPRTD0g1HGkyw6BJZrBTQ5bn
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 3
>>>>>>>>>>> eb3Z2m63UxQvS6jFuhrBwNCteGQ-aziLTklBEQieWlioi2gYnClBNYrEHFgvWWSE
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> v
>>>>>>>>>>> gar2P-tWJHPPeIwuO1U_utMPhVBW-kuhn8kQ2mtOv5v6KvIjRrN8bV1DSkPeuNGC
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 4
>>>>>>>>>>> pfFkeDmG__ztmWkRIOq5sGpyoEOJHeydqHXpPURbDoGJH4X1-XBOw9xyUQUH2FxU
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> z
>>>>>>>>>>> KjIYwzIsoWRAH-mtaFpnV-yPYzPFOpLczOu5V0S3wAh77gKBYS0Ims0rAmTm4RAL
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> G
>>>>>>>>>>> vo_wlPWZLAZZxcznxiU05FXCxycKWSOlLj6vi9pO9hzfr_77ovw17c-o3KHHuMnC
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> K
>>>>>>>>>>> x-PLdlg8F4Dlr-11-NMFS960KQ6y3mrSOt4DP_WEt8kbLW7HnKwQyhHZgE7-jC7-
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> o KZvPXlL_lzz0NbUCv9P-sLtO35WLCQIeslyoVS7lZahikA8xuNn1grSIZ>>
>>>>>>>>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>>>>>>>>> Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg mailing list
>>>>>>>>>>> Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org<mailto:Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org<m
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> a
>>>>>>>>>>> ilto:Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org%3cmailto:Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at ican
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> n
>>>>>>>>>>> .org>>
>>>>>>>>>>> https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg<https://
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> p
>>>>>>>>>>> rotect-us.mimecast.com/r/w4cOGJpN8aqiFBeZDDCfM61L9zSPPQ8yJTOsuok
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> g
>>>>>>>>>>> r0uUoFWQcH4C1vKnhAJR8I5CDUGd3f75FQZ0RrGQoOiumi5fkuGEeAdPoDjA3DGF
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> V
>>>>>>>>>>> t5fCde0OuGcKsc4syb-86Vd3ZsMEWNubiso-WCMGJKqofC67xfNJVO1oqFPAmL7a
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> b
>>>>>>>>>>> ae98k88hH_BDY04YcHIhprEG-vGcToOzkceYzCw4sYw77Sj8DHh1iwNuJPKagRVm
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 5
>>>>>>>>>>> XkaPrKRnvsIqURxFUU964UWsThNMfSE_TxYg9ZhC-Fg><https://protect-us.
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> m
>>>>>>>>>>> imecast.com/r/w4cOGJpN8aqiFBeZDDCfM61L9zSPPQ8yJTOsuokgr0uUoFWQcH
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 4
>>>>>>>>>>> C1vKnhAJR8I5CDUGd3f75FQZ0RrGQoOiumi5fkuGEeAdPoDjA3DGFVt5fCde0OuG
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> c
>>>>>>>>>>> Ksc4syb-86Vd3ZsMEWNubiso-WCMGJKqofC67xfNJVO1oqFPAmL7abae98k88hH_
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> B
>>>>>>>>>>> DY04YcHIhprEG-vGcToOzkceYzCw4sYw77Sj8DHh1iwNuJPKagRVm5XkaPrKRnvs
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> I
>>>>>>>>>>> qURxFUU964UWsThNMfSE_TxYg9ZhC-Fg<https://protect-us.mimecast.com
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> /
>>>>>>>>>>> r/NkE1wHjmuxt3o9SjDC8u3UaEBOfWC2mFXjFJa1_yo4CBlxqC8_PtvDo7WfWJYT
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> _
>>>>>>>>>>> YaNpXYz45ijCcYjA7oYYpLl0toLP6bJpkzDTK3R9OrjFh5nT4QkOopUtxiqubExt
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 6
>>>>>>>>>>> q7UZTuNoom_4ejyw2wpm9vymemagb7YNIBY9WQ1ySPRTD0g1HGkyw6BJZrBTQ5bn
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 3
>>>>>>>>>>> eb3Z2m63UxQvS6jFuhrBwNCteGQ-aziLTklBEQieWlioi2gYnClBNYrEHFgvWWSE
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> v
>>>>>>>>>>> gar2P-tWJHPPeIwuO1U_utMPhVBW-kuhn8kQ2mtOv5v6KvIjRrN8bV1DSkPeuNGC
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> 4
>>>>>>>>>>> pfFkeDmG__ztmWkRIOq5sGpyoEOJHeydqHXpPURbDoGJH4X1-XBOw9xyUQUH2FxU
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> z
>>>>>>>>>>> KjIYwzIsoWRAH-mtaFpnV-yPYzPFOpLczOu5V0S3wAh77gKBYS0Ims0rAmTm4RAL
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> G
>>>>>>>>>>> vo_wlPWZLAZZxcznxiU05FXCxycKWSOlLj6vi9pO9hzfr_77ovw17c-o3KHHuMnC
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> K
>>>>>>>>>>> x-PLdlg8F4Dlr-11-NMFS960KQ6y3mrSOt4DP_WEt8kbLW7HnKwQyhHZgE7-jC7-
>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>> o KZvPXlL_lzz0NbUCv9P-sLtO35WLCQIeslyoVS7lZahikA8xuNn1grSIZ>>
>>>>>>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>>>>>>> Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg mailing list
>>>>>>>>> Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org<mailto:Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org<mai
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> l
>>>>>>>>> to:Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org%3cmailto:Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.or
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> g
>>>>>>>>> https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg<https://pr
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> o
>>>>>>>>> tect-us.mimecast.com/r/w4cOGJpN8aqiFBeZDDCfM61L9zSPPQ8yJTOsuokgr0u
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> U
>>>>>>>>> oFWQcH4C1vKnhAJR8I5CDUGd3f75FQZ0RrGQoOiumi5fkuGEeAdPoDjA3DGFVt5fCd
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> e
>>>>>>>>> 0OuGcKsc4syb-86Vd3ZsMEWNubiso-WCMGJKqofC67xfNJVO1oqFPAmL7abae98k88
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> h
>>>>>>>>> H_BDY04YcHIhprEG-vGcToOzkceYzCw4sYw77Sj8DHh1iwNuJPKagRVm5XkaPrKRnv
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> s
>>>>>>>>> IqURxFUU964UWsThNMfSE_TxYg9ZhC-Fg><https://protect-us.mimecast.com
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> /
>>>>>>>>> r/w4cOGJpN8aqiFBeZDDCfM61L9zSPPQ8yJTOsuokgr0uUoFWQcH4C1vKnhAJR8I5C
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> D
>>>>>>>>> UGd3f75FQZ0RrGQoOiumi5fkuGEeAdPoDjA3DGFVt5fCde0OuGcKsc4syb-86Vd3Zs
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> M
>>>>>>>>> EWNubiso-WCMGJKqofC67xfNJVO1oqFPAmL7abae98k88hH_BDY04YcHIhprEG-vGc
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> T
>>>>>>>>> oOzkceYzCw4sYw77Sj8DHh1iwNuJPKagRVm5XkaPrKRnvsIqURxFUU964UWsThNMfS
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> E
>>>>>>>>> _TxYg9ZhC-Fg<https://protect-us.mimecast.com/r/NkE1wHjmuxt3o9SjDC8
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> u
>>>>>>>>> 3UaEBOfWC2mFXjFJa1_yo4CBlxqC8_PtvDo7WfWJYT_YaNpXYz45ijCcYjA7oYYpLl
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> 0
>>>>>>>>> toLP6bJpkzDTK3R9OrjFh5nT4QkOopUtxiqubExt6q7UZTuNoom_4ejyw2wpm9vyme
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> m
>>>>>>>>> agb7YNIBY9WQ1ySPRTD0g1HGkyw6BJZrBTQ5bn3eb3Z2m63UxQvS6jFuhrBwNCteGQ
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> -
>>>>>>>>> aziLTklBEQieWlioi2gYnClBNYrEHFgvWWSEvgar2P-tWJHPPeIwuO1U_utMPhVBW-
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> k
>>>>>>>>> uhn8kQ2mtOv5v6KvIjRrN8bV1DSkPeuNGC4pfFkeDmG__ztmWkRIOq5sGpyoEOJHey
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> d
>>>>>>>>> qHXpPURbDoGJH4X1-XBOw9xyUQUH2FxUzKjIYwzIsoWRAH-mtaFpnV-yPYzPFOpLcz
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> O
>>>>>>>>> u5V0S3wAh77gKBYS0Ims0rAmTm4RALGvo_wlPWZLAZZxcznxiU05FXCxycKWSOlLj6
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> v
>>>>>>>>> i9pO9hzfr_77ovw17c-o3KHHuMnCKx-PLdlg8F4Dlr-11-NMFS960KQ6y3mrSOt4DP
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> _
>>>>>>>>> WEt8kbLW7HnKwQyhHZgE7-jC7-oKZvPXlL_lzz0NbUCv9P-sLtO35WLCQIeslyoVS7
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> l
>>>>>>>>> ZahikA8xuNn1grSIZ>>
>>>>>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>>>>>> Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg mailing list
>>>>>>>> Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org<mailto:Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org<mail
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> t
>>>>>>>> o:Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org%3cmailto:Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org>
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg<https://pro
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> t
>>>>>>>> ect-us.mimecast.com/r/w4cOGJpN8aqiFBeZDDCfM61L9zSPPQ8yJTOsuokgr0uUo
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> F
>>>>>>>> WQcH4C1vKnhAJR8I5CDUGd3f75FQZ0RrGQoOiumi5fkuGEeAdPoDjA3DGFVt5fCde0O
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> u
>>>>>>>> GcKsc4syb-86Vd3ZsMEWNubiso-WCMGJKqofC67xfNJVO1oqFPAmL7abae98k88hH_B
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> D
>>>>>>>> Y04YcHIhprEG-vGcToOzkceYzCw4sYw77Sj8DHh1iwNuJPKagRVm5XkaPrKRnvsIqUR
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> x
>>>>>>>> FUU964UWsThNMfSE_TxYg9ZhC-Fg><https://protect-us.mimecast.com/r/w4c
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> O
>>>>>>>> GJpN8aqiFBeZDDCfM61L9zSPPQ8yJTOsuokgr0uUoFWQcH4C1vKnhAJR8I5CDUGd3f7
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> 5
>>>>>>>> FQZ0RrGQoOiumi5fkuGEeAdPoDjA3DGFVt5fCde0OuGcKsc4syb-86Vd3ZsMEWNubis
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> o
>>>>>>>> -WCMGJKqofC67xfNJVO1oqFPAmL7abae98k88hH_BDY04YcHIhprEG-vGcToOzkceYz
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> C
>>>>>>>> w4sYw77Sj8DHh1iwNuJPKagRVm5XkaPrKRnvsIqURxFUU964UWsThNMfSE_TxYg9ZhC
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> -
>>>>>>>> Fg<https://protect-us.mimecast.com/r/NkE1wHjmuxt3o9SjDC8u3UaEBOfWC2
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> m
>>>>>>>> FXjFJa1_yo4CBlxqC8_PtvDo7WfWJYT_YaNpXYz45ijCcYjA7oYYpLl0toLP6bJpkzD
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> T
>>>>>>>> K3R9OrjFh5nT4QkOopUtxiqubExt6q7UZTuNoom_4ejyw2wpm9vymemagb7YNIBY9WQ
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> 1
>>>>>>>> ySPRTD0g1HGkyw6BJZrBTQ5bn3eb3Z2m63UxQvS6jFuhrBwNCteGQ-aziLTklBEQieW
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> l
>>>>>>>> ioi2gYnClBNYrEHFgvWWSEvgar2P-tWJHPPeIwuO1U_utMPhVBW-kuhn8kQ2mtOv5v6
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> K
>>>>>>>> vIjRrN8bV1DSkPeuNGC4pfFkeDmG__ztmWkRIOq5sGpyoEOJHeydqHXpPURbDoGJH4X
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> 1
>>>>>>>> -XBOw9xyUQUH2FxUzKjIYwzIsoWRAH-mtaFpnV-yPYzPFOpLczOu5V0S3wAh77gKBYS
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> 0
>>>>>>>> Ims0rAmTm4RALGvo_wlPWZLAZZxcznxiU05FXCxycKWSOlLj6vi9pO9hzfr_77ovw17
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> c
>>>>>>>> -o3KHHuMnCKx-PLdlg8F4Dlr-11-NMFS960KQ6y3mrSOt4DP_WEt8kbLW7HnKwQyhHZ
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> g
>>>>>>>> E7-jC7-oKZvPXlL_lzz0NbUCv9P-sLtO35WLCQIeslyoVS7lZahikA8xuNn1grSIZ>>
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>
>>>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>>>> Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg mailing list
>>>>>> Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org<mailto:Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org<mailto:
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org%3cmailto:Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org>>
>>>>>> https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg<https://prote
>>>>>>
>>>>>> c
>>>>>> t-us.mimecast.com/r/w4cOGJpN8aqiFBeZDDCfM61L9zSPPQ8yJTOsuokgr0uUoFWQc
>>>>>>
>>>>>> H
>>>>>> 4C1vKnhAJR8I5CDUGd3f75FQZ0RrGQoOiumi5fkuGEeAdPoDjA3DGFVt5fCde0OuGcKsc
>>>>>>
>>>>>> 4
>>>>>> syb-86Vd3ZsMEWNubiso-WCMGJKqofC67xfNJVO1oqFPAmL7abae98k88hH_BDY04YcHI
>>>>>>
>>>>>> h
>>>>>> prEG-vGcToOzkceYzCw4sYw77Sj8DHh1iwNuJPKagRVm5XkaPrKRnvsIqURxFUU964UWs
>>>>>>
>>>>>> T
>>>>>> hNMfSE_TxYg9ZhC-Fg><https://protect-us.mimecast.com/r/w4cOGJpN8aqiFBe
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Z
>>>>>> DDCfM61L9zSPPQ8yJTOsuokgr0uUoFWQcH4C1vKnhAJR8I5CDUGd3f75FQZ0RrGQoOium
>>>>>>
>>>>>> i
>>>>>> 5fkuGEeAdPoDjA3DGFVt5fCde0OuGcKsc4syb-86Vd3ZsMEWNubiso-WCMGJKqofC67xf
>>>>>>
>>>>>> N
>>>>>> JVO1oqFPAmL7abae98k88hH_BDY04YcHIhprEG-vGcToOzkceYzCw4sYw77Sj8DHh1iwN
>>>>>>
>>>>>> u
>>>>>> JPKagRVm5XkaPrKRnvsIqURxFUU964UWsThNMfSE_TxYg9ZhC-Fg<https://protect-
>>>>>>
>>>>>> u
>>>>>> s.mimecast.com/r/NkE1wHjmuxt3o9SjDC8u3UaEBOfWC2mFXjFJa1_yo4CBlxqC8_Pt
>>>>>>
>>>>>> v
>>>>>> Do7WfWJYT_YaNpXYz45ijCcYjA7oYYpLl0toLP6bJpkzDTK3R9OrjFh5nT4QkOopUtxiq
>>>>>>
>>>>>> u
>>>>>> bExt6q7UZTuNoom_4ejyw2wpm9vymemagb7YNIBY9WQ1ySPRTD0g1HGkyw6BJZrBTQ5bn
>>>>>>
>>>>>> 3
>>>>>> eb3Z2m63UxQvS6jFuhrBwNCteGQ-aziLTklBEQieWlioi2gYnClBNYrEHFgvWWSEvgar2
>>>>>>
>>>>>> P
>>>>>> -tWJHPPeIwuO1U_utMPhVBW-kuhn8kQ2mtOv5v6KvIjRrN8bV1DSkPeuNGC4pfFkeDmG_
>>>>>>
>>>>>> _
>>>>>> ztmWkRIOq5sGpyoEOJHeydqHXpPURbDoGJH4X1-XBOw9xyUQUH2FxUzKjIYwzIsoWRAH-
>>>>>>
>>>>>> m
>>>>>> taFpnV-yPYzPFOpLczOu5V0S3wAh77gKBYS0Ims0rAmTm4RALGvo_wlPWZLAZZxcznxiU
>>>>>>
>>>>>> 0
>>>>>> 5FXCxycKWSOlLj6vi9pO9hzfr_77ovw17c-o3KHHuMnCKx-PLdlg8F4Dlr-11-NMFS960
>>>>>>
>>>>>> K
>>>>>> Q6y3mrSOt4DP_WEt8kbLW7HnKwQyhHZgE7-jC7-oKZvPXlL_lzz0NbUCv9P-sLtO35WLC
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Q
>>>>>> IeslyoVS7lZahikA8xuNn1grSIZ>>
>>>>> --
>>>>> _________________________
>>>>> Graeme Bunton
>>>>> Manager, Management Information Systems Manager, Public Policy Tucows
>>>>> Inc.
>>>>> PH: 416 535 0123 ext 1634
>>>>>
>>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>>> Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg mailing list
>>>>> Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org<mailto:Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org<mailto:
>>>>>
>>>>> Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org%3cmailto:Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org>>
>>>>> https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg<https://protec
>>>>>
>>>>> t-us.mimecast.com/r/w4cOGJpN8aqiFBeZDDCfM61L9zSPPQ8yJTOsuokgr0uUoFWQcH
>>>>>
>>>>> 4C1vKnhAJR8I5CDUGd3f75FQZ0RrGQoOiumi5fkuGEeAdPoDjA3DGFVt5fCde0OuGcKsc4
>>>>>
>>>>> syb-86Vd3ZsMEWNubiso-WCMGJKqofC67xfNJVO1oqFPAmL7abae98k88hH_BDY04YcHIh
>>>>>
>>>>> prEG-vGcToOzkceYzCw4sYw77Sj8DHh1iwNuJPKagRVm5XkaPrKRnvsIqURxFUU964UWsT
>>>>>
>>>>> hNMfSE_TxYg9ZhC-Fg><https://protect-us.mimecast.com/r/w4cOGJpN8aqiFBeZ
>>>>>
>>>>> DDCfM61L9zSPPQ8yJTOsuokgr0uUoFWQcH4C1vKnhAJR8I5CDUGd3f75FQZ0RrGQoOiumi
>>>>>
>>>>> 5fkuGEeAdPoDjA3DGFVt5fCde0OuGcKsc4syb-86Vd3ZsMEWNubiso-WCMGJKqofC67xfN
>>>>>
>>>>> JVO1oqFPAmL7abae98k88hH_BDY04YcHIhprEG-vGcToOzkceYzCw4sYw77Sj8DHh1iwNu
>>>>>
>>>>> JPKagRVm5XkaPrKRnvsIqURxFUU964UWsThNMfSE_TxYg9ZhC-Fg<https://protect-u
>>>>>
>>>>> s.mimecast.com/r/NkE1wHjmuxt3o9SjDC8u3UaEBOfWC2mFXjFJa1_yo4CBlxqC8_Ptv
>>>>>
>>>>> Do7WfWJYT_YaNpXYz45ijCcYjA7oYYpLl0toLP6bJpkzDTK3R9OrjFh5nT4QkOopUtxiqu
>>>>>
>>>>> bExt6q7UZTuNoom_4ejyw2wpm9vymemagb7YNIBY9WQ1ySPRTD0g1HGkyw6BJZrBTQ5bn3
>>>>>
>>>>> eb3Z2m63UxQvS6jFuhrBwNCteGQ-aziLTklBEQieWlioi2gYnClBNYrEHFgvWWSEvgar2P
>>>>>
>>>>> -tWJHPPeIwuO1U_utMPhVBW-kuhn8kQ2mtOv5v6KvIjRrN8bV1DSkPeuNGC4pfFkeDmG__
>>>>>
>>>>> ztmWkRIOq5sGpyoEOJHeydqHXpPURbDoGJH4X1-XBOw9xyUQUH2FxUzKjIYwzIsoWRAH-m
>>>>>
>>>>> taFpnV-yPYzPFOpLczOu5V0S3wAh77gKBYS0Ims0rAmTm4RALGvo_wlPWZLAZZxcznxiU0
>>>>>
>>>>> 5FXCxycKWSOlLj6vi9pO9hzfr_77ovw17c-o3KHHuMnCKx-PLdlg8F4Dlr-11-NMFS960K
>>>>>
>>>>> Q6y3mrSOt4DP_WEt8kbLW7HnKwQyhHZgE7-jC7-oKZvPXlL_lzz0NbUCv9P-sLtO35WLCQ
>>>>>
>>>>> IeslyoVS7lZahikA8xuNn1grSIZ>>
>>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>>> Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg mailing list
>>>>> Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org<mailto:Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org<mailto:
>>>>>
>>>>> Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org%3cmailto:Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org>>
>>>>> https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg<https://protec
>>>>>
>>>>> t-us.mimecast.com/r/w4cOGJpN8aqiFBeZDDCfM61L9zSPPQ8yJTOsuokgr0uUoFWQcH
>>>>>
>>>>> 4C1vKnhAJR8I5CDUGd3f75FQZ0RrGQoOiumi5fkuGEeAdPoDjA3DGFVt5fCde0OuGcKsc4
>>>>>
>>>>> syb-86Vd3ZsMEWNubiso-WCMGJKqofC67xfNJVO1oqFPAmL7abae98k88hH_BDY04YcHIh
>>>>>
>>>>> prEG-vGcToOzkceYzCw4sYw77Sj8DHh1iwNuJPKagRVm5XkaPrKRnvsIqURxFUU964UWsT
>>>>>
>>>>> hNMfSE_TxYg9ZhC-Fg>
>>> _______________________________________________
>>> Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg mailing list
>>> Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org
>>> https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg
>> _______________________________________________
>> Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg mailing list
>> Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg at icann.org
>> https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg
>
More information about the Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg
mailing list