[Gnso-ssc] SSC / Team review for RDS

Thu Apr 13 15:04:31 UTC 2017

Dear All,

That is my suggestion, indeed.

And i think :

- it acts for improving diversity as it includes one member from the 
contracted parties

- it acts for the future as it include people who will have to make the 
implementation and have the background of 25 +  years of whois 
management (registries / registrars) .

We have sometimes seen guidelines that became nightmares to implement 
for a day to day use.  So my suggestion, i think, does not weaken the 
technical expertise, and i think the 'ground experience' of whois was 
left aside (as it is difficult to measure) in the notes.

So, i think we should look at it in that way,

Best regards

Frederic

Le 13/04/2017 à 15:42, Johan Helsingius a écrit :
> Dear Frédéric (and all),
>
> So as far as I understand, you are suggesting making the
> list be:
>
> 1-3: Susan Kawaguchi, Erika Mann and Volker Greimann
> 4-7: Stephanie Perrin, Marc Anderson, Stefania Milan and
>       Timothy Chen
>
> That would be one person from the BC, one NCA and one RrSG
> appointee. I have to argue that that doesn't really improve
> the diversity, as it would create a situation where no
> non-commercial people are represented.
>
> As such I don't have a strong feeling this way or that, but
> as the original top 3 all come with a much higher score
> than the people ranked 4-7, I fear we would be selecting less
> qualified people in the name of a non-existent improvement
> in diversity.
>
> 	Julf
>
>
> On 12-04-17 17:22, Frédéric Guillemaut - SafeBrands wrote:
>> Dear All
>>
>> I am coming back to you regarding the selection that was issued by the
>> team on Monday.
>>
>> As i explained to you, i think the process should have taken one more
>> validation step, as it was scheduled.
>>
>> In fact, i still believe that this list, without any Registry or
>> Registrar, on this matter, is not a wise solution, or at least does not
>> send a right message of commitment to the community :
>>
>> To solve that issue, as i suggested, we could switch seats 3 and 4 (or
>> 5) to  include either Marc or Volker. This way, the voice of the team
>> would be stronger / have more credibility when they will have to push
>> their ideas to other components of Icann.
>>
>> This feeling is shared by both constituencies, and i really think it
>> would be easier,  to make this change within the team, to reach a
>> consensus based decision, before having to present that list to the gnso.
>>
>> That would not be the first time a list or guide is changed after
>> publication, and to me it is for the better,
>>
>> Please take that in consideration,
>>
>>
>> Best regards
>>
>>
>>
>>
>> -- 
>> photo 		
>> <http://www.linkedin.com/in/fredericguillemaut/> <http://twitter.com/safebrands>
>> Frédéric Guillemaut
>> Directeur Associé, SafeBrands
>>
>> Direct : +33 (0)4 88 66 22 07
>> <tel:Direct%20:%20+33%20%280%294%2088%2066%2022%2007>
>> France : +33 (0)4 88 66 22 22
>> <tel:France%20:%20+33%20%280%294%2088%2066%2022%2022>
>> Mobile : +33 (0)6 81 29 81 27
>> <tel:Mobile%20:%20+33%20%280%296%2081%2029%2081%2027>
>> fg at safebrands.com <mailto:fg at safebrands.com>
>> Skype: mailclub1 <#>
>> www.safebrands.com <http://www.safebrands.com>
>> Pôle Média de la Belle de Mai • 37 rue Guibal • 13003 Marseille • France
>>
>> <https://www.linkedin.com/in/fredericguillemaut/>
>>
>> N.B : En application des principes de respect de l'équilibre vie privée
>> vie professionnelle à SafeBrands, les mails qu'il m'arrive d'envoyer en
>> dehors des heures ou jours ouvrables n'appellent pas de réponse immédiate.
>>
>>
>> _______________________________________________
>> Gnso-ssc mailing list
>> Gnso-ssc at icann.org
>> https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/gnso-ssc
>>
> _______________________________________________
> Gnso-ssc mailing list
> Gnso-ssc at icann.org
> https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/gnso-ssc

-- 
photo 		
<http://www.linkedin.com/in/fredericguillemaut/> 
<http://twitter.com/safebrands>
Frédéric Guillemaut
Directeur Associé, SafeBrands

Direct : +33 (0)4 88 66 22 07 
<tel:Direct%20:%20+33%20%280%294%2088%2066%2022%2007>
France : +33 (0)4 88 66 22 22 
<tel:France%20:%20+33%20%280%294%2088%2066%2022%2022>
Mobile : +33 (0)6 81 29 81 27 
<tel:Mobile%20:%20+33%20%280%296%2081%2029%2081%2027>
fg at safebrands.com <mailto:fg at safebrands.com>
Skype: mailclub1 <#>
www.safebrands.com <http://www.safebrands.com>
Pôle Média de la Belle de Mai • 37 rue Guibal • 13003 Marseille • France

<https://www.linkedin.com/in/fredericguillemaut/>

N.B : En application des principes de respect de l'équilibre vie privée 
vie professionnelle à SafeBrands, les mails qu'il m'arrive d'envoyer en 
dehors des heures ou jours ouvrables n'appellent pas de réponse immédiate.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mm.icann.org/pipermail/gnso-ssc/attachments/20170413/d1bfdb9b/attachment.html>