[Internal-cg] Please review: proposal finalization process

Russ Housley housley at vigilsec.com
Tue Dec 9 21:02:33 UTC 2014

I reviewed the draft "IANA Stewardship Transition Proposal Assembly and Finalization Process" document.  Nice job.  I agree with the vast majority of the document.


I think we should remove Question C from step 2.  The ICG proposal did not ask the operational communities to report on stress testing or scenario analysis.  I realize that some communities are doing this based on concerns raised within their community, but we did not ask everyone to do it, so we cannot fail to move the proposal forward at this point if it has not been done.


There is a typo in step 4.  The public comment will be similar to that in step 3 (not step 2).  Similarly, the subsequent step is number 5 (not 4)

The "proposal submission" step should be numbered 5 (not 6).


More information about the Internal-cg mailing list