[NCAP-Discuss] [Ext] Re: Draft final Study 1 report

[Danny McPherson]

On 2020-04-24 15:42, Matt Larson wrote:

>> 
>>> We'd be grateful for your review and comment. We'll be following the
>>> same process as we did with the draft version of the report: this
>>> group has a chance to comment first and then the report will go out
>>> for a formal Public Comment.
>> 
>> Are we commenting on what we believe are Karen's conclusions and what 
>> she feels warranted by the "research" she's done?
> 
> You may comment on any aspect of the report that you choose, if you do
> so in a respectful way. There's no need to write "research": it's a
> cheap shot and I think you owe Karen an apology. Did she publish an
> academic-style peer-reviewed paper? No. Did she spend hundreds of
> hours reading many pages to come up to speed on a very technical
> topic? Yes. If that's not research, I don't know what is.

Matt I think you were taking me quoting research _way out of context, 
there was nothing personal intended there.

>> 
>> Some specific comments, for Karen, I suppose:
> 
> I'll let Karen address these questions, but I will make one more 
> comment:


I look forward to Karen's responses regarding her executive summary and 
conclusions.


Thanks,


-danny