[NCAP-Discuss] Additional comments on the comments to the Scarfone Draft

[Danny McPherson]

I’ll avoid repetition for the above, one comment below.

> On May 6, 2020, at 7:28 PM, Rubens Kuhl <rubensk at nic.br> wrote:
> 
> I mentioned that in the past, as in we would have known thru LEAs after the many years of the program if something was exploited in the wild. 
> The detection cycle would be too slow for us to decide on future endeavours, but fact is that with so many years behind us, we know that the TLDs delegated in the 2012 round didn't cause it. 
> But, the delegation of .web might cause it, since Web is very meaningful and largely used. Shall we stop the path to .web delegation to prevent the risks you mentioned ? 

Since you’ve mentioned this twice now... 

While I haven’t explicitly looked at occurrence of wpad under .web at our roots and I’m only an influencer should it ever get delegated under my company’s control I’d venture there’s an extremely low (to zero) probability that wpad.web will ever be on the retail or secondary market, much less a premium, regardless of the volume of queries.

-danny