[Tmch-iag] Materials for 16 Dec 11 IAG calls

[Tindal Richard]

P3.       

I think Approach 3 (the TMCH sends the notice) best meets the stated business requirements of existing business relationship and verifiably of transmission.    I think the Registry should advise the TMCH that the domain was registered, and the TMCH should then advise the trademark holder.  I think the least attractive option is Approach 2 (Registrar provides the notice).

P5.      

I think Approach 1 (Registry performs the check) best meets the business requirements.   Having the Registry check will simplify implementation and compliance issues (whether the Claims process is realtime or offline).    It's worth noting that the applicable Registry and Registrar will be in communication for the relevant domain regardless of who is responsible for the check.  As such,  I don't believe making the Registry responsible for the check introduces communications inefficiencies.

Look forward to the next group discussion.

Richard Tindal
Donuts Inc.




On Dec 7, 2011, at 11:44 AM, Karen Lentz wrote:

> Dear Colleagues,
>  
> Thanks again for the useful submissions and participation on the last IAG call on 30 November.   
> 
> For those who were not able to attend, materials from the call are posted
> at https://community.icann.org/display/cctrdmrkclrnghsiag/Home, including
> slides, documents, chat transcript and audio recording.
>  
> Note that any follow up submissions on the issues P1 and P2 are due by Monday, 12 December.  We’ll provide a brief update to those 2 issues after review of all the materials.
>  
> Schedule
>  
> For the call schedule going forward, note that there are 2 tracks that will proceed in parallel:  the process track (focusing on business process development, as now underway) and the technical track (focusing on technical implementation issues).
>  
> Therefore, on 16 December, there will be 2 calls taking place:
>  
> 1.       Process call (issues P3 and P5) at 13:00 UTC.
> 2.       Technical call (issues T1 and T3) at 16:00 UTC.
>  
> Both calls are scheduled for 90 minutes and will use the existing dial-in number and Adobe Connect room.
>  
> You may choose to attend both calls, if you wish, or focus only on one you are interested in.  The relevant documents for both are attached.
> 
> Process Track
> 
> Issue# P3 (Responsibility for Trademark Holder Registration Notice)
> 
> Issue# P5 (Responsibility to Perform Trademark Claims Checks)
> 
> We will discuss these topics, informed by your written comments, on the 16 Dec call.  Please submit your written comments to these issues by 13 Dec 2011 (23:59 UTC) to the mailing list.
> 
> As discussed previously, we are ultimately seeking your recommendations
> for either (1) one of the proposed options in the document or (2) your
> suggestions for alternatives that you believe to be more attractive and
> that should be considered.
> 
> In your written comments, please make sure to indicate:  (a) the issue
> number (P3 or P5), (b) the recommended option or alternative for the issue,
> (c) rationale (consideration of advantages and how any disadvantages could
> be minimized) and (d) any other comments.
> 
> Technical Track
> 
> Issue# T1 (Data Locations)
> 
> Issue# T3 (Communication Protocols)
> 
> We will discuss these topics, informed by your written comments, on the 16 Dec call.  Please submit your written comments to these issues by 13 Dec 2011 (23:59) UTC to the mailing list.
> 
> We are ultimately seeking your recommendations for either (1) one of the
> proposed options in the document or (2) your suggestions for alternatives
> that you believe to be more attractive and that should be considered.
> 
> In your written comments, please make sure to indicate:  (a) the issue
> number (T1 or T3), (b) the recommended option or alternative for the issue,
> (c) rationale (consideration of advantages and how any disadvantages could
> be minimized) and (d) any other comments.
> 
> We look forward to hearing from you.
> 
> Karen Lentz
> ICANN
> 
> 
>  
>  
>  
> 
> 
> <IAG-issue_T1.pdf><IAG-issue_T3.pdf><IAG-issue_P5.pdf><IAG-issue_P3.pdf>_______________________________________________
> tmch-iag mailing list
> tmch-iag at icann.org
> https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/tmch-iag

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://mm.icann.org/pipermail/tmch-iag/attachments/20111214/b7a8a0be/attachment.html