FW: Error: end of DST Vienna 1918 is not in Jun
Janko Stamenovic
janko at teletrader.com
Mon Mar 3 13:27:08 UTC 2003
As far as I understand, the text means the following (my German is not perfect):
"1945 daylight saving ended without particular decree, because of the end of the war. That transaction was given by the entrance of the occupation forces and occurred therefore in different parts of the country on different times, for example in Vienna apparently on 2. April 1945."
I though that maybe it can be understood that it doesn't mean only that the daylight saving ended then, but that the occupation forces brought "their time", which was different in different parts of the country, since there were different troops? That is, that every Army had its own time rules? The other problem is that borders between the Armies certainly changed through the time.
On
http://www.magwien.gv.at/english/history/vhisaf.htm
we can find about Vienna: "The political context was no less complicated, the Allied Occupation Forces refusing to accept the Nazis' territorial expansion. The bottom line was that those districts which had existed until 1938 were divided into four Allied zones and the inner-city district was administered by all four powers, as the so-called "Inter-allied Zone". Districts 22 - 26, namely the 97 Lower Austrian communities which had been merged with Vienna in October 1938, were considered to form part of Lower Austria and, hence, came under Soviet control."
Therefore I deliberately pointed only to error in 1918, since it seems too hard point to solve without more information.
Btw, BEV is Austrian "Federal Office of Metrology and Surveying".
http://www.bev.gv.at
so I guess their "?" really means that it's difficult to set some reasonable time. But something has to be set.
There's one more difference between their info and zoneinfo, since one transition happens by them on 1946-10-07 (Monday) although 1946-10-06 as it is in zoneinfo looks better since it's Sunday (like the previous April transition, although it appears that they really almost always moved the clocks on Mondays (I don't know why) before and during WWII).
Best regards,
Janko Stamenovic
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Paul Eggert [mailto:eggert at twinsun.com]
> Sent: Saturday, March 01, 2003 06:20
> To: Janko Stamenovic
> Cc: tz at elsie.nci.nih.gov
> Subject: Re: FW: Error: end of DST Vienna 1918 is not in Jun
>
>
> > From: Janko Stamenovic <janko at teletrader.com>
> > Sent: Wednesday, February 26, 2003 5:17 AM
> >
> > http://www.metrologie.at/pdf/sommerzeit.pdf
>
> Thanks for the reference and for the correction. It also appears to
> me that the current data are wrong for 1945 in Vienna, and for 1980 in
> Austria. The BEV seems to be saying that in Vienna daylight-saving
> was observed for only 10 days in 1945, allegedly. So I'll propose
> something like the following patch to the "europe" file in my next
> batch of changes, which is due soon.
>
> @@ -558,20 +558,30 @@
> 1:00 EU CE%sT
>
> # Austria
> +
> +# From Paul Eggert (2003-02-28): Shanks gives 1918-06-16 and #
> +1945-11-18, but the Austrian Federal Office of Metrology and #
> +Surveying (BEV) gives 1918-09-16 and for Vienna gives the alleged #
> +date of 1945-04-12 with no time. For the 1980-04-06 transition #
> +Shanks gives 02:00, the BEV 00:00. Go with the BEV, and
> guess 02:00
> +# for 1945-04-12.
> +
> # Rule NAME FROM TO TYPE IN ON
> AT SAVE LETTER/S
> Rule Austria 1920 only - Apr 5 2:00s
> 1:00 S
> Rule Austria 1920 only - Sep 13 2:00s
> 0 -
> -Rule Austria 1945 only - Apr 2 2:00s
> 1:00 S
> -Rule Austria 1945 only - Nov 18 2:00s
> 0 -
> Rule Austria 1946 only - Apr 14 2:00s
> 1:00 S
> Rule Austria 1946 1948 - Oct Sun>=1 2:00s
> 0 -
> Rule Austria 1947 only - Apr 6 2:00s
> 1:00 S
> Rule Austria 1948 only - Apr 18 2:00s
> 1:00 S
> +Rule Austria 1980 only - Apr 6 0:00
> 1:00 S
> +Rule Austria 1980 only - Sep 28 0:00
> 0 -
> # Zone NAME GMTOFF RULES FORMAT [UNTIL]
> Zone Europe/Vienna 1:05:20 - LMT 1893 Apr
> - 1:00 C-Eur CE%sT 1918 Jun 16 3:00
> - 1:00 Austria CE%sT 1940 Apr 1 2:00
> - 1:00 C-Eur CE%sT 1945 Apr 2 2:00
> + 1:00 C-Eur CE%sT 1920
> + 1:00 Austria CE%sT 1940 Apr 1 2:00s
> + 1:00 C-Eur CE%sT 1945 Apr 2 2:00s
> + 1:00 1:00 CEST 1945 Apr 12 2:00s
> + 1:00 - CET 1946
> 1:00 Austria CE%sT 1981
> 1:00 EU CE%sT
>
>
More information about the tz
mailing list