[AT-Review] ATRT Schedule; something is missing

[Brian Cute]

Fabio,

Thanks for your reminder. We can meet directly after our meeting with the
Board today which ends at 5:30p.m.  We have the cocktail reception with the
Board at 7:00p.m. which allows 1.5 hours.  Alice, could you find an
available room for us.

Regards,
Brian

-----Original Message-----
From: Fabio Colasanti [mailto:fabio at colasanti.it] 
Sent: Saturday, December 04, 2010 7:26 PM
To: at-review at icann.org; Alice Jansen
Subject: [AT-Review] ATRT Schedule; something is missing


Dear all,

the ATRT schedule just circulated does not foresee a slot (slots) for
discussions within the group.  When we had last discussed the Cartagena
schedule over the telephone I remember distinctly that we had agreed to
having at least another meeting among ourselves (on Monday) after having met
the Board.

We should exchanging views on the comments received.   The most important
and challenging point made by a number of contributors was that the ATRT
should "walk the talk" by explaining in detail what it has done with the
input it has received all along its work.   This is a tough task.  We should
examine collectively the points raised (not that many) and agree on what we
should give as reasons for having followed or not followed them.   We cannot
ask the Board to give a full explanation of its decisions including the
follow-up given to the inputs received and not to that ourselves.   

The comments we have received touch a number of difficult issues (from the
absence of binding review mechanisms to suggestions that ICANN should be
incorporated in a more "international" jurisdiction).   Then there are a
number of general comments about the readability/presentation of the whole
document.   

There is also a very reasonable suggestion to comment on our experience as a
Review Team and give suggestions for the work of future Review Teams.

I have the impression that our work is not over yet.  

Fabio

_______________________________________________
AT-Review mailing list
AT-Review at icann.org
https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/at-review