[Gnso-ppsai-pdp-wg] last transfer thoughts

[Kathy Kleiman]

Hi All,
I wanted to point out two other transfer scenarios where not publishing 
the Whois information of a proxy/privacy customer makes sense and seems 
fair:
1) I decide to transfer all my domain names to Blacknight from a US 
Registrar and its affiliated proxy/privacy service. In doing so, I sign 
up at transfer for Blacknight's proxy/privacy service.  Why shouldn't my 
personal data be protected in that transfer -- with the Whois shifting 
from one proxy/privacy service provider to another, both with my 
underlying personal data?

2) My Registrar loses its accreditation and all domain names are 
transferred to Tucows. I sign up right away for Tucows privacy service. 
Why should my personal data be published in this already-difficult 
situation?  Why should potentially thousands or even millions of 
registrants lose their privacy?

Best and tx,
Kathy