[gnso-rds-pdp-wg] Now open: 18 January Poll on Purpose

[Stephanie Perrin]

Sorry, this discussion is important.  Your example proves my point.  
What you show below is a disclosure.  It is a disclosure of a limited 
set of data.  we are not supposed to be talking about disclosure at this 
point in our proceedings.  I leave it to the experts on whether this is 
"thin" in the sense of the thick transition discussion, I really don't 
know because we are focused on gTLD policy here.  My point is this is a 
disclosure.  We do not "collect" thin data per se, we collect a whole 
mess of mandatory data elements, as per the RAA.  Then we generate a 
whole mess as part of activating and making real the domain's 
existence.  Then we share (release) a small subset.

So talking about collecting thin data is misleading in my view.  Purpose 
of disclosing it is what we are in fact talking about. Calling it a 
purpose for collection opens the barn door.

Stephanie


On 2017-01-25 06:46, Sam Lanfranco wrote:
> Thank you Michele, ( ignoring the spell check driven typo of "think" 
> for "thick" (-: ). We should be able to put this "thin" discussion 
> behind us.
> The "thin" discussion should have taken about 2 email exchanges. Here 
> is CIRA's (thin) search for .ca domain names [disclosure: it is my 
> domain name]
>
> Domain name: artisanalpot.ca
> Domain status: registered
> Creation date: 2016/12/14
> Expiry date: 2017/12/14
> Updated date: 2016/12/19
> DNSSEC: Unsigned
> Registrar:
> Name: Web Hosting Canada (7081936 Canada Inc.)
> Number: 5000080
> Name servers:
> ns1.whc.ca 173.209.49.178
> ns2.whc.ca 198.245.53.176
> ns3.whc.ca 198.245.61.86
> % WHOIS look-up made at 2017-01-25 11:32:24 (GMT)
> % Use of CIRA's WHOIS service is governed by the Terms of Use in its Legal
> % Notice, available at http://www.cira.ca/legal-notice/?lang=en
> % (c) 2017 Canadian Internet Registration Authority, (http://www.cira.ca/)
>
> Nothing private is disclosed and LEA would have to resort to legal 
> means to get to what is in the "thick" data set.
> There are no ICANN policy  issues here.
>
> Sam L <artisanalpot.ca> (-:
>

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mm.icann.org/pipermail/gnso-rds-pdp-wg/attachments/20170125/0b54de74/attachment.html>