[CPWG] GNSO TPR PDP meeting on Sep 5, 2022
John McCormac
jmcc at hosterstats.com
Wed Sep 7 12:39:50 UTC 2022
On 07/09/2022 07:13, Steinar Grøtterød via CPWG wrote:
> * Discussion:
> o Wonder if Compliance has some data?
> o Registrars have indicated that they don’t have data.
> o Without data we should remove it.
> o >From staff re: question about data: Compliance has provided
> data related to complaints about the lock itself in Phase 1A,
> but not specific enough in terms of hijacking. As to data to
> “prove” that a lock is necessary or not, we don’t have that
> level of breakdown/tracking to speak to that issue.
> o Compliance tracks transfer complaints in general, but does not
> break down to “inter registrar" vs. “COR”.
> o The best you can get is the NACK statistics from the Open Data
> Initiative, but only limited years and not recent. Does show
> significant use of the NACK, but can’t correlate it to hijacking.
I've got ICANN registrar transaction data back to 2001 (even extracted
it from various document formats) and have been tracking the data each
month. The raw CSV format reports are available on
https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/registry-reports
It seems that ICANN just doesn't pay attention to the quality of the
registrar transaction reports that are filed and some, like .AFRICA,
have not had any real data since they launched. Some registries file
partial or corrupted reports but ICANN seems overwhelmed by having to
deal with these reports. The Open Data Platform was a good idea but it
was a bit of a management solution that ignored fundamental data quality
issues.
It would be possible to produce historical NACK data from the reports if
it would be of any help. The main targets for domain name theft would be
the .COM/NET/ORG. The latest dataset on the ICANN site is from May 2022
while the latest on the ODP is 2020 data. The data to 202203 is
currently loaded into the large historical table here and this is the
txgain-nack historical data for .COM back to 2007 (gtld - Year/Month -
NACK):
| com | 200704 | 11090 |
| com | 200705 | 76148 |
| com | 200706 | 11769 |
| com | 200707 | 14099 |
| com | 200708 | 13182 |
| com | 200709 | 14322 |
| com | 200710 | 16652 |
| com | 200711 | 20028 |
| com | 200712 | 25344 |
| com | 200801 | 27895 |
| com | 200802 | 19313 |
| com | 200803 | 17447 |
| com | 200804 | 17145 |
| com | 200805 | 17804 |
| com | 200806 | 16762 |
| com | 200807 | 16345 |
| com | 200808 | 16184 |
| com | 200809 | 14881 |
| com | 200810 | 19241 |
| com | 200811 | 107859 |
| com | 200812 | 83442 |
| com | 200901 | 13736 |
| com | 200902 | 14673 |
| com | 200903 | 18566 |
| com | 200904 | 24207 |
| com | 200905 | 20245 |
| com | 200906 | 18223 |
| com | 200907 | 17276 |
| com | 200908 | 16222 |
| com | 200909 | 13942 |
| com | 200910 | 15386 |
| com | 200911 | 12386 |
| com | 200912 | 12786 |
| com | 201001 | 12483 |
| com | 201002 | 12458 |
| com | 201003 | 14498 |
| com | 201004 | 29430 |
| com | 201005 | 11345 |
| com | 201006 | 11580 |
| com | 201007 | 11046 |
| com | 201008 | 10850 |
| com | 201009 | 10315 |
| com | 201010 | 11402 |
| com | 201011 | 10782 |
| com | 201012 | 11187 |
| com | 201101 | 16472 |
| com | 201102 | 12050 |
| com | 201103 | 11822 |
| com | 201104 | 12852 |
| com | 201105 | 10815 |
| com | 201106 | 10565 |
| com | 201107 | 10100 |
| com | 201108 | 13567 |
| com | 201109 | 13484 |
| com | 201110 | 8625 |
| com | 201111 | 9120 |
| com | 201112 | 14957 |
| com | 201201 | 11250 |
| com | 201202 | 9663 |
| com | 201203 | 13135 |
| com | 201204 | 9097 |
| com | 201205 | 8388 |
| com | 201206 | 9610 |
| com | 201207 | 8320 |
| com | 201208 | 56036 |
| com | 201209 | 86917 |
| com | 201210 | 8538 |
| com | 201211 | 7651 |
| com | 201212 | 7955 |
| com | 201301 | 9196 |
| com | 201302 | 8748 |
| com | 201303 | 9235 |
| com | 201304 | 8240 |
| com | 201305 | 7790 |
| com | 201306 | 8663 |
| com | 201307 | 9344 |
| com | 201308 | 6745 |
| com | 201309 | 6445 |
| com | 201310 | 6958 |
| com | 201311 | 5645 |
| com | 201312 | 5866 |
| com | 201401 | 10639 |
| com | 201402 | 7294 |
| com | 201403 | 13081 |
| com | 201404 | 18417 |
| com | 201405 | 7540 |
| com | 201406 | 7004 |
| com | 201407 | 6445 |
| com | 201408 | 7203 |
| com | 201409 | 9225 |
| com | 201410 | 7443 |
| com | 201411 | 7796 |
| com | 201412 | 7703 |
| com | 201501 | 8650 |
| com | 201502 | 7540 |
| com | 201503 | 8830 |
| com | 201504 | 7758 |
| com | 201505 | 8251 |
| com | 201506 | 7558 |
| com | 201507 | 7251 |
| com | 201508 | 7299 |
| com | 201509 | 7417 |
| com | 201510 | 8032 |
| com | 201511 | 7100 |
| com | 201512 | 6278 |
| com | 201601 | 7126 |
| com | 201602 | 10018 |
| com | 201603 | 8020 |
| com | 201604 | 7247 |
| com | 201605 | 7070 |
| com | 201606 | 6537 |
| com | 201607 | 6330 |
| com | 201608 | 7179 |
| com | 201609 | 6581 |
| com | 201610 | 6665 |
| com | 201611 | 6821 |
| com | 201612 | 6088 |
| com | 201701 | 8357 |
| com | 201702 | 8774 |
| com | 201703 | 9656 |
| com | 201704 | 8104 |
| com | 201705 | 6222 |
| com | 201706 | 6693 |
| com | 201707 | 5834 |
| com | 201708 | 6618 |
| com | 201709 | 6306 |
| com | 201710 | 7154 |
| com | 201711 | 6626 |
| com | 201712 | 6065 |
| com | 201801 | 6754 |
| com | 201802 | 6185 |
| com | 201803 | 6729 |
| com | 201804 | 12105 |
| com | 201805 | 7329 |
| com | 201806 | 10029 |
| com | 201807 | 8330 |
| com | 201808 | 23764 |
| com | 201809 | 10502 |
| com | 201810 | 10830 |
| com | 201811 | 10891 |
| com | 201812 | 10735 |
| com | 201901 | 12392 |
| com | 201902 | 9691 |
| com | 201903 | 10122 |
| com | 201904 | 9677 |
| com | 201905 | 11302 |
| com | 201906 | 17776 |
| com | 201907 | 33328 |
| com | 201908 | 11636 |
| com | 201909 | 10232 |
| com | 201910 | 12432 |
| com | 201911 | 12030 |
| com | 201912 | 11964 |
| com | 202001 | 21279 |
| com | 202002 | 14115 |
| com | 202003 | 13757 |
| com | 202004 | 20973 |
| com | 202005 | 15150 |
| com | 202006 | 18829 |
| com | 202007 | 22475 |
| com | 202008 | 19439 |
| com | 202009 | 9115 |
| com | 202010 | 8379 |
| com | 202011 | 9869 |
| com | 202012 | 10656 |
| com | 202101 | 9613 |
| com | 202102 | 7809 |
| com | 202103 | 11387 |
| com | 202104 | 7529 |
| com | 202105 | 13874 |
| com | 202106 | 14561 |
| com | 202107 | 14996 |
| com | 202108 | 20619 |
| com | 202109 | 6360 |
| com | 202110 | 5782 |
| com | 202111 | 7602 |
| com | 202112 | 7609 |
| com | 202201 | 8082 |
| com | 202202 | 7800 |
| com | 202203 | 8921 |
The April 2022 NACK was 7,576 and the May 2022 NACK was 32,349.
While ICANN Compliance may have some data on some domain name disputes,
more reliable data could be derived from some of the UDRP decisions
where domain name theft is a component of the dispute. There are also
tx-dispute fields in the registrar transaction rpeorts which may be of use.
Regards...jmcc
--
**********************************************************
John McCormac * e-mail: jmcc at hosterstats.com
MC2 * web: http://www.hosterstats.com/
22 Viewmount * Domain Registrations Statistics
Waterford * Domnomics - the business of domain names
Ireland * https://amzn.to/2OPtEIO
IE * Skype: hosterstats.com
**********************************************************
--
This email has been checked for viruses by Avast antivirus software.
www.avast.com
More information about the CPWG
mailing list