[registrars] DRAFT Standard form for use by losing registrars after a transfer is initiated
Ross Wm. Rader
ross at tucows.com
Thu Sep 11 15:53:06 UTC 2003
On 9/5/2003 6:14 PM Jim Archer noted that:
> Ross, this is nonsense. Most of the problems in this industry come
> either from unethical registrars or from resellers, who (1) don't
> understand what they are doing or (2) don't care what they are doing.
Jim - you are completely correct. The problem with transfers started
with one or two large registrars that ignored convention and exploited
loopholes within our agreement to the benefit of their on interests -
and to the detriment of industry.
The conversation over the last two years has focused on a) what
convention actually is and should be and b) what sort of policies we
need to have in place in order to ensure that the convention is upheld.
>
> It is fundamentally unfair to punish the smaller companies, who are
> trying to distinguish themselves from our competitors, because of the
> unethical acts of our competitors or, frankly, the unethical acts of the
> resellers of the bigger companies.
>
> More and more, registrars are being told *exactly* how to do business.
The new transfer policy is intended to tell registrars *what* to do -
there is some grey area that wanders into *how* territory, but these are
procedurally unavoidable.
>
> Rather than dictate how and when we all do something, why don't we hold
> the unethical agents responsible for their behavior? If the problem is
> bad apples, then don't throw out the entire bushel.
I couldn't agree more - problem is, the current contracts are just vague
enough that this type of behaviour is not only permissible, but actually
encouraged. The existing contracts make a mockery of customer choice and
domain name portability - and the statistics back this up.
I honestly don't see any other way of getting to a more appropriate
state without tightening up regulation and enforcement - it simply isn't
possible under the existing deal.
--
Regards,
-rwr
"Around computers it is difficult to find the correct unit of time to
measure progress. Some cathedrals took a century to complete. Can you
imagine the grandeur and scope of a program that would take as long?"
- Unknown
Got Blog?
More information about the registrars
mailing list