[Rt4-whois] Recommendations

[Omar Kaminski]

Also, this part is "to walk over eggs" like we say here (pag. 9 WRT):

"Impose standards on proxy/privacy services on what data is protected".

Should/could these standards be categorized? What was done so far?

How to deal with different levels of protection, specially on a
political point of view like in free speech?

Omar



2011/7/5 Kim G. von Arx <kim at vonarx.ca>:
> I got the time from our wiki.  I won't be able to make the call as I have my
> daughter and she usually wakes up at that time.
> Anyway, here are three, of many, suggested changes that I think may be
> prudent:
> 1. Make a distinction between legal and natural persons and also provide an
> exemption for certain natural person registrants to be "categorized" as
> "persons" requiring some privacy/protection, e.g., battered women shelters.
> 2. Implement a random audit of Registrants to verify the accuracy of their
> information in the WHOIS database.  This should include a global requirement
> for each registrant to confirm his/her/its contact details every year or
> every 6 months, e.g., send email to registrant, registrant needs to go to a
> link, provide some authentication tool, and confirm information.  Note, this
> is per registrant and NOT per domain name.
> 3. Provide some special access to law enforcement and UDRP applicants to
> WHOIS information for legitimate and reasonable reasons of natural and legal
> persons, but it needs to be a controlled access.
> Finally, thanks Lynn for the RFP.  Great work and I am fine with it.  While
> I think that the legal language should be tightened up, but since ICANN
> legal does not want to share theirs I don't see why we lawyers should put
> our neck out there and provide legal advice on that front.  In light of
> that, I am fine with the content of the RFP, but would urge ICANN to conduct
> its own due diligence with respect to the terms and conditions of the RFP to
> ensure proper legal protection.
> Kim
>
> __________________________________
> kim at vonarx.ca
> +1 (613) 286-4445
> "Shoot for the moon.  Even if you miss, you'll land among the stars..."
>
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Rt4-whois mailing list
> Rt4-whois at icann.org
> https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/rt4-whois
>
>