[RZERC] [Ext] Re: RZERC meeting minutes 11 December 2017 Teleconference Call

[Peter Koch]

Mario, all,

On Mon, Feb 05, 2018 at 08:48:28PM +0000, Mario Aleman wrote:

> Thank you for flagging the comments in the minutes. You are right, Peter was an apology for this meeting and Russ was referring to Peter's suggestion on the mailing list. Apologies if this wasn't clear, I have double checked the recording and transcripts, and made the edits on the document attached. 

thanks for the updated version, which resolves almost the only remark I had.
The second version also improved the visual impression, but there's still some
font issue at the end of page2/start of page3 - unless that's the 'redline' effect.

Now that the remarks have been attributed more clearly, I have some questions
on substance, not questioning what was actually said.

First, I might have lived under the wrong assumptions that the SoI would be
collected and kept by staff. At least, I'm not sure we had been explicit about
publishing them on the RZERC website.  Not that I'd oppose, I just wonder whether
that was a decision taken some time back (didn't find it) or a false
assumption on my side.

Second, on the 'touch base call/mail', it's now probably late enough after the
11 Dec call that this continued conversation may count as such, but apart from
that, the recorded 'decisions' leave open what the transcript suggests
and without any need to change the minutes I'd like to suggest we ask
staff support to give us a ping early enough before an ICANN meeting so that
we'd have a chance to ask for a room just in case.  We're past that point
for San Juan, but that's OK for me.

Regards,
  Peter