[SubPro-IRT] [Ext] Re: Topic 21: Reserved Names

Fri Sep 29 22:27:24 UTC 2023

Thank you Michael for the clarification, and it goes thru my little syntax
check at the second look of the sentence.  :)

Best,

Ching

On Thu, Sep 28, 2023 at 3:33 PM Michael Karakash <michael.karakash at icann.org>
wrote:

> Hi Ching,
>
>
>
> Thank you for your email and input. While we are revising the document in
> this category to provide more clarity on the language based on our
> discussion during the previous IRT call, we do have a caveat to the
> “3-letter ASCII Combinations” category in the current draft language.
>
>
>
> It says: “3-letter ASCII combinations are eligible for delegation *unless
> used by ISO 3166 as ISO 3-letter code.”* Therefore, we are in agreement
> that they are prohibited if found on the ISO 3166 list.
>
>
>
> Thank you!
>
>
> Best,
>
>
>
> Michael
>
>
>
> *From: *Ching Chiao <ching.chiao at whoisxmlapi.com>
> *Date: *Thursday, September 28, 2023 at 11:20 AM
> *To: *Michael Karakash <michael.karakash at icann.org>
> *Cc: *"subpro-irt at icann.org" <subpro-irt at icann.org>
> *Subject: *[Ext] Re: [SubPro-IRT] Topic 21: Reserved Names
>
>
>
> Dear all ,
>
>
>
> For 1.2.1 *3-letter ASCII Combinations : *
>
>
> I am still under the impression that the 3-letter ISO3166 code is
> prohibited, primarily based on GAC Helsinki Communique :
>
>
>
> *20160630_GAC ICANN 56 Communique_FINAL [1].pdf *
>
> *Use of 3-letter codes in the ISO-3166 list as gTLDs in future rounds a.
> The GAC advises the ICANN Board to: *
>
>    1. *encourage the community to continue in depth analyses and
>    discussions on all aspects related to a potential use of 3-letter codes in
>    the ISO-3166 list as gTLDs in future rounds, in particular with regard to
>    whether such a potential use is considered to be in the public interest or
>    not. *
>    2. *keep current protections in place for 3-letter codes in the
>    ISO-3166 list in place and not to lift these unless future in- depth
>    discussions involving the GAC and the other ICANN constituencies would lead
>    to a consensus that use of these 3-letter codes as TLDs would be in the
>    public interest. *
>
> The SubPro WT-5 report should have remained the same position, but please
> correct me if I am wrong or missing something.
>
>
>
> Thank you very much !
>
>
>
> Best,
>
>
>
> Ching
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> On Fri, Sep 22, 2023 at 2:43 PM Michael Karakash <
> michael.karakash at icann.org> wrote:
>
> Dear IRT Members,
>
>
>
> We are pleased to share the proposed language of the AGB's Reserved Names
> [t.sidekickopen53.com]
> <https://t.sidekickopen53.com/Ctc/DL+23284/cFFT304/JkMbTjqZW6N38Bs6lZ3nDW7_2DwT5P384CW24SZyx2n6L28W8SFMB96H4M9QW4R09V-5wl0p0W19NNjM31vB7XW1pLBtG2G0Y7TW3pVhS08bfv_CW6BZXQ4908Gk_VDf1t96N_5mmN5J2P7-nT5xSW11L5hW3DcDYYW7387FW7TP3gsW83V4f33bb6D8W7C8HYs1FF_HPW3JMd2n7XF-Y0W7Ln8RW2vsCLCV-q3Pn8lt7hvN72qBy8-Md8ZN3Kk4R5WpRphW6KkDCp1KCgkqW20QZJ47cMxMyW6lYcGg6PGpWRW1R9XLw1ng25LW8fWLt97drLWzW1Gtw3d7fD7QYW5FF4yw2mFDVsW9k7rsl8s-dSbW3nzfNB8tbpLPN8jbX3xYTSGfN4nCSQNjTTHwW8P9d8K3Wpb55W154_jv2G8vjWVY3QK74Z50V2W2JL5qk8Yn8FrW2gzxvy3HV94tW3qfxKB4RhbycW2JBJbM4clRj8W2YN7bL1Jtth_W1RyPX21QS9fsW1g4H643G2TksW66LT0P29JC9pW972xGK5yC009W2G8hl550cb3XW93Q8fQ5k2lKVW2MGyyT5ZRCrJW4G9CMN8wqbFRW7TWChP7qWZy7W5DwQcM3wVP8LW8MPRNj2hCV4FW6Pz2jw1bzJzcW2dcdG57jBYYnW3bh8j98D6fBYW41TrZ47d6FfQVqYmqr4BDXJmW52XQP38slWfVW8BXFC42htBl3N2P1XjBXm4qtW8_6b3h59vWy1V8ZVcV1RMFyMW1PCC1s4tyyFJW4CyHhf7nGR24VFJ-Hm4Bc0_mW4bZmTW1shq1vW69NRfT2fxcJrW1zlNMT77WSQ9W3t0cxx5VTpq9W5Qk6-c1KSfGjN27wzlkXgkD8W3QNHl08d8WKzW3K9cYM2WnyflW25D7Db4dDXgHW5qw59z7jm3kCN9k5SfBWgtmpW78z1Cs47v3RkW7jmfh_2d54L6W55zKG67pRwDtW7_l0Xg5Z5VM-W62YPX86RMpVGVqkZGJ4rYY5sN12t3GclT3CsW2pdXYF2N1tm0W1djNYF94gk_SW45SZzY4gVv81W1VNN4v41FfrwVwJFzg1RsWMlW2LDXh52zQTJSf2Js4DP04>
> section based on the Board-adopted recommendations in Topic 21 of the Final
> Report [t.sidekickopen53.com]
> <https://t.sidekickopen53.com/Ctc/DL+23284/cFFT304/JlYbTjqZW95l6Qj6lZ3lRN3hlrs3DmwlkVYxRl53MjWp6W4FjVvC6DnBB7VwFl1Y7Q81M6VX3NN635HsFsW3V1Zxp7VmstQW5j-YJy8FBskBN1L1nS11FrDPW4l25fT6Wm5BnN85j95NbF5pSW6bZ2v62-D3pCW2D4Y0p4YZN-3W6v633P65pn3TW81dLNb23FHn-W2zPhr93FmlDVW3cJqvw4dfMdrW5nzLns2nsT7sW6mXY898tp9qcW2h5NvX5jVv9lW8NVHP45xPzF2W34ycJ74FvYzQW815kBH3HCK_0W7Pd_Tm62FRLMW8BJnVL8vSxsdW7p9rRx9h_MkhN29pFfYGWT_1W6NS3fV6LF1sNW8T1q4v19y1V9W6wt7HB36bDlVW6b4hGD6b5F-7N1PBJyVcldKVW4P6Xcs7q9kxFW8bZWqP2P6DHbVq2xRw8GKQbmW4hfScb3Kn1nXW8JYWZP3H0LxbW184B3Q92C2kLW6rxzGf3RwxnqW58bLfL4Hjmg5W5KYdz74rb5KxMwkP1Q98TWTN2cvqfGgdKW0W784TgR2L5sv_W8bclYd74gdHZW6MJTJl59FFZpW4Z1KXY3RcVf9N8_LKWjS55wnW81LJqP4PWqtrW6kycd33gl8pxW3xn0T02p4mMJN4dsLSWzG7tnVKp7qG4hnj8tW99N0fJ3lFkLXW2D2VDl7kH2pPN158PqgdGPhmMwgzHcC-7xYW1B8wlN1W9BNYW6w-Sh142zFsVW2KcNZH2tMtLvW9jhmVl2ycjbGW23Bz7p49Xm1GW4lQLbc6gNMxgW50j0pR7lTf1JW5cnnCm1_Hcl2W1tjbMQ1-_-0gW9cnV643-DDnBW1YnXDj9gDQF7W2d0wk82vKmsPW5NcZHh7hwmSNW4vZ4R15xwm95N310L8pbg1RKW1z5SWj7nvhG_W8rDphg1JRXngW91h8wv66hG8rW1-FsDw51P37_W41Hfjv762t-HMSPyL_9LV3WW2qkn_l7mz7w-W9jRWrt4F4QwzW95PPh04hm5FqW13pxkX7jnwz-V_HMpk1hlc57W4HyMqc8Wpc73W3z1Whq3Y613CN1dM5YMPQ-sFW37W16y2-l3cbW8w--Yw1G78YKVmRKNd8ZjbFsW7v1dtP8Yry9sVlV_hF4YW_VLW6MzM2q8QK20yW3yxvdC3BCy6XW1fvF6P1JwQK-W6VXMsH3-hpgGf1B-3kg04>
> .
>
>
>
> Additionally, the agenda and a PDF version of the document for Tuesday’s
> discussion are accessible here [t.sidekickopen53.com]
> <https://t.sidekickopen53.com/Ctc/DL+23284/cFFT304/Jk8bTjqZW5BXHtx6lZ3mfW2mvyV32lFXBxW3dsjb_8ypWZsW13FQ2T3BQ9ZpW7Gy-QH6WyfVtW1GlSq_8mbM85W4GlXSQ4r9xLbW6vxMgL3DKFkpW43WCmG5jrNlDVkK6Ps30ppD_W7kchLF3HvcdYD1wzBpmC3XW1PQdGN39p054W99WkgS8V-nlKW2HlrY-8Q4396W2lM6F67_2VPvW3v0Yzr4gN07tW1GhCkg3VMdRBN4cl4c6hjLhNW8lWMXY6D186qW3BYMHk5l1LvZW73d9QM2_cYLJW2qSt7J3K2SG8W8jMQRh7Mqw0kW780pWS6qs4jtW7bJp4y3FVKNzW3VNh132PF4JZW7gsw2-6fTzwdW6W-Z1J74Q13nW3dpw7H7004bwW4Wx8rq4V2qsCW5HnQB34bpkQBW1899Wn5zyMGGW7ST9Qv57BlNqW1WPQP38-hCnHW2Rlv3N1xyGclW3wzGJh6Lm3T3W15W7mh8KP-fpW1wT-W_8ZbPD8W8JnLLn2LBqSPW2SsB132Rb__-VCtQDV4FhKB4W8vyRgC62Pk9DW3b8CWG26jC8CW6HcdBJ8sX4hpW15qpP0181fThN1G2XtyqPx_jW8MTxMt2dzKKGW80F8Zv5gvrtTW5Dh9fW8skkz_N9lF_bcG6B5SW4rDCpn5NcQMfW8PG2Kc98gWPbN77HrHThhNZJW1s2-1x2ZWr44W2Pc5tQ7WxxJPW8yGq0Z1RmJSyW51Jng61lKz6mW3qbnX56YQtFGW8ZQL-H6XJ8PpW35FmD58DrGScW72L4MT1nnHJGW6Pmfm79ctw2bW1QP2v35cMBPfW7R54XZ73NWllW5q9qGT2dl2z-W7tRcSS61dd54W7fXT-r5X3QwzW8KdTV58ThsqQV4l3wT98y8qfW44w-vX6vS1WkW2bsVg76Bnc18W21p_q_5ghMySW20TVxD5mGB4tW4KdHCz6wjtLRVNVYLV6r0lswVQQF271n0z_ZW2k5RHW682K2_W6n_mff3QMccyW7GtmlJ6FJWKnW8Hj-QW6XFd0dW23y6q22m9DF2W20rv8F8J81d3f8fJKr604>
> .
>
>
>
> If you have any questions or concerns, please feel free to reach out.
>
>
>
> Thank you!
>
>
>
> Best,
>
>
>
> Michael
>
> _______________________________________________
> SubPro-IRT mailing list
> SubPro-IRT at icann.org
> https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/subpro-irt
>
> _______________________________________________
> By submitting your personal data, you consent to the processing of your
> personal data for purposes of subscribing to this mailing list accordance
> with the ICANN Privacy Policy (https://www.icann.org/privacy/policy) and
> the website Terms of Service (https://www.icann.org/privacy/tos). You can
> visit the Mailman link above to change your membership status or
> configuration, including unsubscribing, setting digest-style delivery or
> disabling delivery altogether (e.g., for a vacation), and so on.
>
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://mm.icann.org/pipermail/subpro-irt/attachments/20230929/03ca8124/attachment-0001.html>