[tz] Turkey name change
Letu Yang
letu_yang at apple.com
Wed Sep 6 21:06:53 UTC 2023
Thank you for the clarification!
Yes, I was talking about the backward file and the iso3166 file. I understand the none-ASCII7 char might be an issue to be supported by many old-fashioned users.
> On Sep 6, 2023, at 2:03 PM, Paul Eggert <eggert at cs.ucla.edu> wrote:
>
> On 2023-09-06 09:55, Matt Johnson-Pint via tz wrote:
>> Unlike CLDR, IANA tzdata doesn't capture such names - other in comments.
>
> Yes, TZDB is not a user-facing database so any Turkish guidelines about text seen by business customers should be a matter for CLDR or equivalent, not for TZDB. As far as I know, all Apple OSes use CLDR, so if CLDR says "Türkiye" Apple should be OK.
>
>
>> The tzdata name for Türkiye's time zone was and continues to be Asia/Istanbul.
>
> The zone is Europe/Istanbul; Asia/Istanbul is a link.
>
> Letu may be referring to the line "Link Europe/Istanbul Turkey" in the 'backward' file. Changing that line would disrupt the rare old-fashioned users who who have used TZ='Turkey' for decades. Adding another backward-compatibility line "Link Europe/Istanbul Türkiye" would fail to follow TZDB's naming conventions requiring ASCII for link names; also there's no need for such a line as old-fashioned users did not use TZ='Türkiye' and (as you suggested) modern users should be using TZ='Europe/Istanbul' anyway.
>
> Or perhaps Letu is referring to the line "TR Turkey" in the iso3166.tab file. Although iso3166 already has a comment about this sort of thing, the comment could be more explicit. Proposed patch attached and installed into the TZDB development repository (comments welcome as usual).
>
> It's also possible that Letu is referring to some other instance of "Turkey" somewhere in TZDB. If so, it'd be helpful to know exactly where, by sending us a draft patch.
> <0001-Document-iso3166.tab-naming.patch>
More information about the tz
mailing list