[bc-gnso] Another Last Call: BC Position - Baseline Registry Operations Report

Steve DelBianco sdelbianco at netchoice.org
Tue Mar 30 22:57:58 UTC 2010

Another Last Call before closing on a BC comment.

Attached is the draft BC position regarding the report on Baseline Registry

Berry Cobb circulated the draft back on 23-Mar (see below).  I¹ve signaled
my agreement.

Absent objections by COB tomorrow, we will file as consensus BC comments on


On 3/23/10 3:16 AM, "Berry Cobb" <berrycobb at infinityportals.com> wrote:


Attached is the first draft of the CBUC position statement for the Baseline
Registry Operation report released by ICANN.  Overall, I feel KPMG performed
well and provided meaningful views of the data. It is ashamed that more
participants were not a part of the sample data.

My Registry operations experience is limited, so I ask the BC team to take a
strong look at the report and the initial comments I provided.  I especially
invite our members that have direct Registry operations experience
to enhance our position about this study and its future use by the gTLD
Evaluation teams.

This material is sure to have a direct impact to the next Draft Applicant
Guidebook version 4 to be released just prior to Brussels.  In a
quick review, the following are what I believe to be sections of the DAGv3
where  this study could influence the Application Evaluation Criteria, or
the Application Process both of which will be used by the gTLD Evaluation

1.2.2 Required Documents for Application
1.4.2 Application Form
2.1.2 Applicant Reviews
2.1.3 Registry Services Review
2.2.1 Technical/Operational or Financial Extended Evaluation
2.2.2 DNS Stability Extended Evaluation
2.2.3 Registry Services Extended Evaluation

The comment period closes April 1st, so I ask for your quick
turn-around.  As Steve DelBianco eluded to in our last BC call, there are a
large number of comment period closings converging at once.  I thank you for
your quick response.  I will compile all feedback and incorporate changes on

Berry Cobb
Infinity Portals LLC
San Jose, CA
mailto:berrycobb at infinityportals.com
http://infinityportals.com <http://infinityportals.com/>

-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: BC_Position_RyBaseline_Draft_03312010.docx
Type: application/octet-stream
Size: 81940 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://mm.icann.org/pipermail/bc-gnso/attachments/20100330/e169e0e0/BC_Position_RyBaseline_Draft_03312010.docx>

More information about the Bc-gnso mailing list